@FFerdyansha@desa231295@idextratime Kalo kamu mau baca rule of the game, disana jelas kalo terjadi goal akibat sentuhan tangan baik sengaja ataupun tidak sengaja, itu pasti handball.
Dan disana ada beberapa rule yg memperkuat kenapa itu ga penalti, 1. Karena bola dari rekan setim, 2. Karena bola terlalu dekat
They are not lying; they simply moved from one valid interpretation of Shahada (physical) to another valid interpretation (astronomical presence).
I will explain, because you requested it.
To an outsider or a scientist, it looks like a lie. However, from a theological and administrative perspective, it is a matter of jurisprudence (Fiqh) and the definition of what constitutes the witnessing of a crescent.
The core of the misunderstanding lies in the Quranic verse: “So whoever among you witnesses/sights (shahida) the month, he should fast it” (2:185).
In linguistic and legal terms, the word shuhud (witnessing/sighting) is an example of دلالة ظنيّة (Speculative/Non-Definitive Indication), i.e: the word "witness/sight" in the verse is open to multiple interpretations based on ijtihad.
For this reason, Scholars have historically applied three different interpretations to what it means to "witness/sight" the crescent:
1- Shahada of the Eye: This is the physical sighting of the crescent (whether with naked eyes or advanced optical aid)
2- Shahada of Presence: This argues that if you are present in your city (not traveling) when the month begins, you must fast.
3- Shahada of Taqdir (calculation/estimation): This supports using the birth of the new moon (conjunction) as the witness.
Saudi Arabia uses the Umm al-Qura calendar for its daily administrative life. This calendar is not based on "will it be seen?" but rather "has the new moon been born and is it present in the sky?"
When the official moon-sighting committees go out and the sky is cloudy or the moon is too low to be seen, the authorities often default to the Umm al-Qura calculation to maintain national consistency. In their view, if the moon is astronomically present (the birth has occurred), the condition for the new month has been met; applying the Shahada of Taqdir.
The Umm al-Qura criteria considers the month to have begun if the moon sets after the sun at the coordinates of Mecca, even if only by a few seconds. In such cases, the moon has been witnessed technically, even if it is invisible to the eyes/binoculars.
The data for today (February 17, 2026) in Mecca demonstrates exactly how this technical sighting works:
- Conjunction (Birth of the Moon): 3:01 PM (Mecca Time).
- Sunset: 5:52 PM in Tumair.
- Moonset: 5:54 PM in Tumair.
- The "Lag Time": 2 minutes.
To an astronomer, these 2 minutes are irrelevant because the moon’s illumination is too low (less than 1%) to be seen.
However, to the Saudi Supreme Court, the condition of presence has been met. Since the moon remained above the horizon for two minutes after the sun disappeared, it is "witnessed" or "sighted" by calculation (Taqdir).
Thank You.
- Ahmadulbadawy AbdulRaheem.
#Ramadan2026
#RamadanKareem
@SherlyS824488@ainunnajib Mungkin ini sebenarnya yang mau disampaikan mas nun.
Masalah dosa atau enggak, mengikuti ijtihad insyaallah tidak salah.
Yang salah adalah merasa sombong karena metode nya paling benar dan menganggap yang lain berdosa.
@lirikrumpang@NauTheCoffee Kenapa kalau ogah deket2 zionis, dia bisa jadi ketum dikemudian hari?
Jelaskan secara logika sederhana aja bang, saya awam nih
@DuniaPermata@ainunnajib Seharusnya begini atau begitu adalah bagian dari ijtihad, dilandasi ilmu, mengikuti ijtihad tidak salah, yang salah merasa sombong metodenya paling benar.
@AgiMaulanaXyz@ainunnajib Banyak loh yang menjelaskan dengan ilmu, tp nun itu tidak membuka ruang diskusi, merasa pendapatnya paling benar.
Bisa dilihat dari dia nge reply di akun2 MU yang menjelaskan khgt dengan narasi yang cenderung menyalahkan yang diulang2 dan menggunakan AI.
@ybajaaa@afrkml Seluruh dunia mana nih, arab puasa tgl 18
Mengapa tgl 18? Ini ijtihad, insya Allah tidak salah mengikuti ijtihad, yg salah adalah merasa sombong dan merasa metode dan pemahamannya paling benar
@KholisNh@Benyami86590827@ainunnajib Dan sikap manusianya untuk menerima perbedaan juga beda-beda.
Ada yang bilang untuk bahan diskusi, tapi membuat narasi seolah paling benar dan yang lain salah.
@ainunnajib@yudisudiyono 1. Anda selalu menegaskan kata LIHAT, MELIHAT.
2. Anda bilang bukan kebenaran absolut, tp timeline Anda mengatakan seakan yg puasa tgl 18 salah dan tidak mengikuti Nabi
3. KHGT = salah?
4. Mendiskusikan dg membuat narasi seakan puasa tgl 18 = salah?
@FaisalArq @wak_kadirr 1. Ga bisa pilih pemain? Masalahnya ada pemain yg bisa dipilih ga? Klub izinin pemain ga?
2. Ga bisa bikin pemain main hebat? Kalau teknik dasar masih berantakan, mau main hebat gimana.
Eh eh coba deh guys. Sekali setahun, atau seenggaknya sekali seumur hidup deh, kalian KUDU baca/baca ulang kisah Nabi Nuh Alaihissalam. Soalnya seru banget dan banyak pelajaran yg bisa diambil.
Atau sini aja deh, aku ceritain!
[Sebuah Utas]