winnie lee

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Please stop fabricating lies and claiming that this is the behavior of Ningning’s fans. Please explain who the fans of the person Ningning responded to and those who left these hateful comments actually are.@ChinaKarinaBar

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Ningning warned two haters (one with over 100k followers, the other with over 500k) because they infringed on her family’s rights to their image and privacy: they used her mom’s picture as their avatar and wrote nasty comments along with it.

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

I have no idea why anyone would make up lies that this is Ningning’s fans’ doing. What does Ningning protecting her family have anything to do with Karina’s fans?

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Haters use pictures they’ve deliberately manipulated. They’ve also made up lies about Ningning’s family elsewhere. We’re sharing this to show how vicious they are. So what if the original picture used by the person Ningning responded to is different? That doesn’t change anything.

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

You say it was our fan page that photoshopped the image. Please show us the proof. I truly do not understand what relationship you have with those who use such avatars to harm Ningning’s family members. Why are you speaking out for them?@ChinaKarinaBar

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

Beneath the post made by the hater whom Ningning responded to, someone used this image. If you have a conscience, don’t continue to question this.

[winnie lee @winnerleee520]

@NingNing_Bar 一直想把宁艺卓维权歪曲成粉圈战争的Karina粉丝到底安的什么心

[winnie lee @winnerleee520]

@NingNing_Bar 支持宁艺卓维权

[CHINA NINGNING Bar @NingNing_Bar]

1. 我方维权声明从头至尾从未提及柳智敏本人及其粉丝群体。措辞一再严谨，目的就是不误伤无辜。矛头始终仅指向那两名已被平台封禁、性质极其恶劣的黑粉博主，以及SM公司与aespa团队。部分人士持续转移焦点、颠倒黑白，若当真理直气壮，为何不敢在国内主流平台公开发声对质？
当下国内舆论，很多权威媒体、法律人士、普通博主与路人，几乎全面理性站队支持宁艺卓，宁艺卓微博持续涨粉，维权举动已成美谈。这恰恰印证了公道自在人心。艺人合法维护家人权益天经地义，宁艺卓的勇敢赢得全网赞誉。而某些人连在微博公开@我方对线的底气都没有——究竟是谁在畏惧承担法律责任？

2. 宁艺卓维权事件的起因，是其母亲作为完全无辜的素人，其照片被恶意截取用作头像，并配文侮辱性言论大量传播。在宁艺卓本人亲自提醒后，对方仍拒不更换，这才是核心事实。柳智敏若有受伤害之处，柳智敏粉丝请向SM公司及aespa团队追责，而不是对宁艺卓维护家人的正当行为过度应激、横加指责。
出道五年间，SM娱乐公司始终未采取任何取证或诉讼等法律手段保护宁艺卓。面对针对自身的各类不实评价，宁宁秉持职业素养，始终保持克制与隐忍。然而，家人是她不可触碰的情感底线，此次她不得已公开表态，实属无奈之举。作为支持者，我们将坚定不移地支持宁艺卓女士及其家属依法、合理维护自身权益。

3. 长期以来，黑粉对宁艺卓实施了一系列严重侵权及网暴行为：
盗用其家人照片做社交头像并配文侮辱言论；
捏造其母亲黄谣，肆意侮辱女性；
非法盗用宁艺卓个人身份信息绑定社交平台及游戏账号；
反复公开传播她的身份证件照片并加以羞辱；
扒出哈尔滨家庭地址，散布邮寄死老鼠、上门泼红油漆等威胁论。
你们所谓“开盒韩国人”的指控完全是无稽之谈。中国人是不可能扒出韩国人身份信息的，韩国【家族关系登记簿（户籍系统）】不向无关第三方开放查询。只有本人、直系亲属、持有合法委托书才能申请调取。不存在随便找人就能入侵官方数据库查到父母、兄弟姐妹名字的渠道。 宁艺卓粉丝绝无能力和渠道对柳智敏做出这样的恶劣行径。

4. 所谓“宁吧移花接木”的指控，核心依据不过是那张配字头像并非出自被封的10万粉账号，而是柳智敏其他散粉所使用。据此反咬我方造谣那名侵犯宁艺卓家人肖像权的10万粉违法博主，纯属偷换概念。为一个公然网暴无辜素人家属的违法博主竭力辩护，究竟是何立场？
我方站子核管聊天记录可完整证实：文案中两张配图系并列关系，绝无从属误导。一张完整交代了宁宁警告10万粉博主事件的前因后果，清晰对应宁艺卓的公开回复；另一张对应一众黑粉恶意P图的侵权行为。用词上，我方严格区分hater（单数，指为黑而黑的喷子）与professional anti-fan bloggers（复数，指专门注册账号长期辱骂宁艺卓的人），定义清晰。若仍质疑截图真实性，我方可直接提供沟通全程视频证据。

5. 以“综艺截图属公开图片”为由，为恶意截取、肆意羞辱素人的行为开脱，这是典型的法盲逻辑。公开绝不等于可以在未经授权下随意使用。根据《中华人民共和国民法典》第一千零一十九条，任何组织或个人不得以丑化、污损等方式侵害他人肖像权，未经同意不得制作、使用、公开他人肖像。
黑粉侵权要害在于“未经同意”。宁艺卓家人作为独立民事主体，肖像权受法律同等保护。综艺播出绝不代表放弃肖像权，更不意味授权他人用作头像侮辱。将素人照片当作头像或发博文配以侮辱性文字，是典型的侵权，请你们立刻停止为黑厕和极端粉丝的违法行为辩解洗地。

6. 部分人在国内平台被事实驳斥到无法立足，便换上另一副面孔转战外网，构陷抹黑、刻意制造对立。身为粉圈引领者，这种两副面孔的操作令人不解。风波初起，我方站子便第一时间发布公告，全程引导粉丝理性合法维权，规范取证流程，坚守底线，杜绝过激。宁艺卓勇敢为家人维权，本是正当之举，却被刻意曲解攻讦——这正是某些人一贯手法：混淆施害者与受害者的身份，将水搅浑。根源始终在那些纵容极端粉丝作恶、肆意消费无辜家属的人。
在此，我站郑重呼吁相关粉圈带头者立即停止在外网的无端抹黑与构陷，不再煽动对立。也奉劝所有年轻网友，理性健康上网，学习基础法律知识，敬畏法律，拒绝成为网暴的帮凶。

[TTluvning @allningning]

6, lzm and 66 means k
64 means k solo stans
that's all I wanted to say

[KETCHUP AND LEMONADE @NING2Xningmeng]

Since when did Ningning's position in the group change?

[winnie lee @winnerleee520]

我装你老母在这满嘴喷粪，是不是p的你们最清楚，在微博用别人妈妈当头像的时候就想着要这样倒打一耙是吧狗屎

[Reflectshark @kerina_2000411]

你他妈个臭逼的才是眼瞎吧 眼和宁艺卓一样爆炸了吧？？你野猪吧上面发的那两张图和翻译不是p到骂公头像去了？野猪粉给野猪老母自己批图还他妈逼的给野猪叫冤上了你脸被宁艺卓这个野猪撕了？

[nah @heavenisyong]

sama kayak dulu waktu dia live buat klarifikasi masalah berat badan, dia bacain komen komen jelek eh malah dibilang, "kenapa sih harus balesin yang jelek jelek doang kan bisa diskip" jiirrr ya terserah dia lah orang lagi bela diri sendiri ada aja salahnya

[🦋 @yizhuozone]

lmfaooo aespa fan they say 🤣 she's protecting her mother and her family, not her job to protect other groupmates, did they ever speak up for her? no

[Ningning Studio @ningningstudio]

We do not intend to fixate on whether the perpetrators are Karina’s fans. We are simply fed up with the slander and false accusations ChinaKarinaBar has leveled against cnms. Hope everyone can focus on the infringers themselves rather than which idol’s fans they happen to be.

[𝗳𝗹𝘂𝘁𝘁𝗲𝗿 @flutter1023]

260723 GMP

#aespa #æspa #에스파
#NINGNING #닝닝 #宁宁 #宁艺卓

[winnie lee @winnerleee520]

@ningningstudio upupupupupupupup

[Ningning Studio @ningningstudio]

Multiple users across platforms continue using Ningning’s mother’s portrait for harmful circulation, meaning the infringement is ongoing. If you spot such content on any platform, please gather evidence promptly and submit it via https://t.co/0tKd9DLcWe.

[winnie lee @winnerleee520]

@nikonntta Karina粉丝已经开始造谣式澄清了呢