Rassie, the Ref and Rugby’s Ugly Underbelly
Here we go again. Another Springbok defeat to France, another Rassie Erasmus meltdown, and another embarrassing episode for South African rugby.
You’d think we’d have learned something by now. Apparently not.
Rugby is one of South Africa’s greatest passions. But there’s a darker side to our beloved game. And frankly, I’m getting sick of it.
I’m talking about the growing culture of bullying, intimidation and outright nastiness that seems to follow the Springboks whenever things don’t go our way.
Remember November 2022? The Boks lost 30-26 to France in Marseille. It was supposed to be a special occasion for English referee Wayne Barnes, officiating his record 101st Test.
Instead, it became a nightmare.
Barnes and his wife Polly were subjected to horrific online abuse. Death threats, threats of sexual violence and disgusting messages involving their children. The Rugby Football Union was sufficiently alarmed to lodge a formal complaint with SA Rugby.
And who was busy posting clips questioning Barnes’s decisions? Our very own Rassie Erasmus.
I’m not suggesting Rassie personally encouraged anyone to threaten Barnes or his family. Barnes himself has said he doesn’t know whether Rassie’s posts caused the abuse. But surely Rassie understands that when someone in his position publicly questions a referee’s performance, a certain breed of supporter takes that as an invitation to pile on.
Fast-forward four years and we’ve gone full circle.
The Boks lose 21-19 to France in Paris last weekend. Three days later, Rassie acknowledges that his team deserved to lose and had only themselves to blame.
Fair enough. That’s leadership.
Then out comes the familiar grievance catalogue.
This time Rassie went considerably further by asking whether a TMO who saw infringements and deliberately ignored them would be guilty of match-fixing or manipulating the result.
That’s an extraordinary suggestion to put into the public domain without compelling evidence.
Let’s be clear: Rassie Erasmus is a brilliant rugby coach. Two World Cups, tactical innovations that have transformed the game, and an extraordinary ability to get the best out of his players. His place among rugby’s coaching greats is secure.
But being a genius doesn’t give you a free pass to behave like a petulant child whenever things don’t go your way.
The bigger problem is what this behaviour does to the culture surrounding our game.
Spend five minutes on social media after a Springbok defeat and you’ll see what I mean. Every controversial decision becomes evidence of a conspiracy. Every referee who makes a mistake is apparently incompetent, biased or corrupt.
And anyone who dares challenge the mob risks being labelled unpatriotic.
Refereeing rugby is an extraordinarily difficult job. The laws are complicated, interpretations vary, and officials must make split-second decisions under enormous pressure.
Even after countless slow-motion replays, experienced pundits frequently disagree.
When someone with Rassie’s influence raises the possibility of corruption in a dispute over refereeing decisions, I believe he gives oxygen to the worst elements of rugby fandom.
We’ve already seen the sort of abuse referees can face with Wayne Barnes.
What young referee, watching all this unfold, would willingly sign up for a career where a bad afternoon at the office might result in death threats against their family?
And without referees, we don’t have a game.
Rassie has every right to be angry. He has every right to raise concerns through the proper channels.
What he doesn’t have is the right to undermine the integrity of the sport simply because he doesn’t like the outcome.
And we supporters need to look in the mirror too.
I’ve supported the Boks through wonderful victories and some truly miserable defeats. I’ll continue doing so.
What I won’t do is defend the indefensible simply because the man responsible has delivered two World Cups.
To my South African friends talking about knee drop tackles. You seem genuinely incapable of imperial and independent though without Rassie’s say so…
To clarify.
This tackle has been used by your team in the same game and during the NZ series.
You lost the game on Friday for the following reasons
- poor selection
- poor discipline
- a deserved red card
- a missed kick
- not being able to control du Pont
You didn’t lose it due to any referee. Your coach knows that and so do your players.
The reaction to the defeat on here has been toxic and pathetic. Due to the hysteria you seem to have when you lose (implying there is a conspiracy against SA rugby). Because of that your coach is banned until 3 games before the next World Cup.
The cult of Rassie has actually hurt your chances of winning another World Cup! The fact you cannot see this is beyond ridiculous.
Likewise Weisse was lucky not to get a straight red and have you down to 14 for the whole second half.
I’m a huge fan of SA rugby and have openly written of my admiration for the boks and Rassie. Particularly during the greatest rivalry series but honestly this is under 12 parents of a child stuff… blaming the ref and crying over one rugby match.
Learn from the all blacks and Australia and the class with which they handled their defeats at the weekend. And do better
As soon as Oom Rassie said the words “match-fixing” and “manipulation”, he was screwed. I don’t think he meant what some of us heard. And in some ways, he has a fair point.
The real issue is that we’re all missing where this ACTUALLY starts.
I don’t believe for a second that Rassie meant the ref was getting money in a brown paper bag. shoved under his chair in the changing rooms. He was going through his thoughts in real time. Stream of consciousness. Upfront and honest (jeez how much do we neeed more of that in our game!). In his second language. In a room full of experienced journalists who know how to ask the right leading questions to get the headline they’re looking for.
What he was trying to get at is this. When you ratify a bunch of new laws and tell the world “this is what we’re going to enforce”, and then you DONT enforce them, the referees and the officiating team have an unduly high effect on the outcome of the game. A penalty that should be given and isn’t can have as much influence on the result as a penalty that is given.
But there’s a side of this we are missing. World Rugby explicitly told the TMOs not to get involved as much! Most of us fans have been complaining about this whole “team of four” concept. Where the ref, the ARs and the TMO work as a team. Each chipping in at various points. "Its gone too far" we cry. We’re getting too many calls, particularly from the TMO.
So at its briefing for referees and coaches before the November Tests, World Rugby gave the TMOs a mantra: “If in doubt, stay out; in the grey, stay away.”
https://t.co/bn3jF2DhRQ)
That’s World Rugby explicitly telling TMOs not to get involved where they don’t need to.
In that very same briefing, hip-drop and knee-drop tackles were named as a priority.
Think about the absurdity of that. You bring in new laws to police, then tell one quarter of your refereeing team to get involved less. That crack is the hole Rassie has fallen into.
As an aside, if you want a conspiracy theory, here’s the one I think belongs here. Felix Jones was apparently heavily involved in getting the hip-drop and knee-drop rules written. From all accounts, he was influential in shaping World Rugby’s stance and pushed hard to get it included.
https://t.co/OUIWpNjsWi
I wonder if this wasn’t the strategic, tactical part from the Boks. We all know they worked pretty hard on the hearts and minds campaign around the maul laws. Which obviously benefits them. Its one of their primary attacking weapons.
The Springboks are very much a "carry-more, pass-less" team. They gets massive benefit from post-contact metres. "We’ve got big boys who can carry hard at you and through you." Post contact meters = quicker ball = better attack. A knee drop is a way for a smaller, less physically imposing team to stop big ball carriers in their tracks. Limit their post-contact metres =slow the ruck = get more jackals etc.
I actually wonder if the Boks pushed really hard to get the knee-drop law brought in because it benefits them strategically. That’s why they’re so pissed. They got a law brought in that should help their big ball carriers. And at the first opportunity it’s not really being enforced.
Anyway, that’s my conspiracy theory.
Back to the point at hand.
All of this, all the wailing and gnashing of teeth, the clipping of videos, all of it, stems from one thing. Rugby is trying to litigate out every chance of injury. It’s a trend of injury catastrophism that started with all the concussion stuff five or six years ago. Its almost like we believe every injury deserves a law to counteract it.
I want to introduce a concept here: realpolitik. Realpolitik is an approach to governance that doesn’t worry about what the ideal situation is. It worries about what can actually, practically be done. A German writer, Ludwig von Rochau, coined the term in 1853, after the liberal revolutions of 1848 failed. He started out as an idealist. His lesson was that ideals change nothing unless you deal with the world as it actually is.
An example. We all know that if every speed limit was 20 km/h, fewer people would die on our roads. Nobody actually does that. We care about lives, but we also accept that people need to get to work and get around. So we accept some risk as the price of getting on with life. The idealist sets the limit at 20 and wonders why the country has stopped moving. The realist sets it at 110 on the freeway, comes down hard on drink drivers and hoons, and accepts that driving will never be perfectly safe. But life can function.
Should rugby be safer? Yes. But it should be as safe as PRACTICAL, not as safe as POSSIBLE. The game has made massive strides towards being safer, but don’t for a second think you can ever make rugby safe. Yet we keep piling law upon law upon law, under the guise of safety, into a game that’s already incredibly complex.
Every new law creates more scenarios where fans, journalists and coaches can nitpick decisions on minor technicalities and highly subjective views. It’s toxic for the game.
Rassie says there were 17 knee drops. Planet Rugby says it found two clear and four marginal. @CharlieFelix went through all 223 French tackles and found something different again.
(https://t.co/NBKj8uaJXu)
So we’ve got professional coaches, professional journalists and armchair experts all finding different stuff. And that’s after the game, with the benefit of sitting down and going through the video frame by frame.
Yet we expect referees to make those decisions in real time.
To me, this is not the fault of the referee. It’s not the fault of Rassie. It’s World Rugby. They are creating cognitive overload for everyone.
Newsflash for you: rugby is a dangerous fucking sport. Every contact/combat sport is. You can get hurt, and sometimes in ways that have long-term, even permanent, consequences. I said this years ago and got absolutely blasted for it. Anyone who says to me “I didn’t realise I could get hurt playing rugby in a way that affects me for the rest of my life”, I’m sorry, but that is naive. Anyone remember Max Brito? That was 1995. Anyone seen Muhammad Ali and Joe Frasier in their latter years? Hear their slurred speech and glazed eyes. Come on mate, please dont tell me no one had any concept theres a risk here.
Rugby is a dangerous sport. But let me tell you the other truth, and the boys from @RugbyPodcast are 100% correct on this: the RISK IS THE REWARD. The risk is what attracts us to the game. The risk is what makes it so special to have a beer with someone in a different jersey than yours after the game. Bash each other during the 80 minutes, share a laugh after. No matter what you do, you will never, ever remove that risk. And you dont want to. World Rugby seems intent on doing its best though.
Does that mean we just let everyone smash each other willy-nilly? No, absolutely not. Remove the dirtiest foul play. If you want to protect the head, which I think is absolutely right, then penalise or card a straight shot to the head. Not a shot to the shoulder with incidental head contact. Looking at you Lood. That’s rubbish. We need to embrace the concept of a rugby incident. Simplify the tackle laws. Simplify the breakdown laws. Stop creating scenarios where people can nitpick tiny little things. It’s not healthy for the game.
Referees do an unbelievable job. Trust me, going out there and getting 95% of your decisions right means you are elite at what you do.
The issue is the denominator. Say a ref has 500 decisions to make and gets 99% right. He gets 5 wrong. But we’ve now created a game where instead of 500 decisions, he has 2,000. Same 99%, and now he gets 20 wrong. He didn’t get worse. The game got more complicated.
So now we need a team of four to make those decisions. Then we tell different parts of that decision-making team: "Get involved, ummm actually don’t get involved, get involved with this, ahhh no, don’t get involved with that". The goalposts are constantly moving. There’s no way these guys can win.
Again, as soon as Rassie said the words “match-fixing” and “manipulation”, he was in trouble. Even though it isnt what he meant, in my view. You just cannot say that. You open yourself up for punishment. But that is not where the problem starts.
Stop trying to add laws to remove every type of injury. In rugby it’s not IF you’re going to get hurt. You ARE going to get hurt. No matter how many hip drop or knee drop laws we add.
The risk is the reward.
Simplify the tackle. Simplify the breakdown. Simplify the game. Stop giving people avenues to nitpick every little decision. And let the boys and girls play.
#RassieErasmus #Rugby #Springboks
Melbourne man Hayden Flinn was working in Hong Kong when he received the devastating news that his 13-year-old daughter had died suddenly.
He and his 15-year-old son flew home after both testing negative twice and being fully vaccinated. Upon arrival, they were locked in a hotel room for two weeks while his daughter’s body remained with the coroner.
He was barred from viewing her and from being with his wife as the funeral was arranged.
He is now taking the Victorian government under Dan Andrews and Brett Sutton to the Supreme Court over the detention.
Cases like this contributed to the anguish and resentment many felt under one of the world’s harshest COVID restrictions.
The government was tyrannical and cruel. If justice were to prevail, Andrews and Sutton should be jailed. These were crimes against humanity. We were treated worse than animals.
Never forget what they did to us.
What a day in Cardiff ❤️🏉
Relive Saturday’s epic win over the All Blacks in just 150 seconds & don't miss the next chapter against Australia this weekend 🔥😍
Secure your tickets now 🎟 https://t.co/3ZxGIGRBsV
#CymruAmByth