I’ve been asked a few questions about the CCTV tapes stolen from Hillsborough stadium on the evening of the disaster, so thought I would do a thread on it
This is the crime report for the theft from 21/4/89
Note the double underlining of the “NO PUBLICITY” instruction
@totalcrime
During the Hillsborough inquests (with jury) and subsequent criminal trials, we weren’t able to comment on it for nearly 8 years in total, and the void was filled with misinformation by idiots on social media who didn’t understand the Attorney General’s directive & contempt of court laws (nor any actual facts about the disaster)
The contempt laws just led to a greater flow of misinformation, whilst suppressing fact-checked media - not a good outcome for anyone
@DeannaLouise93@david_conn@TonyEvans92a I make it that since the Inquests went active in 2014, we weren’t able to talk about Hillsborough for 80 months in total - nearly 8 years in total.
We seem to be the only country that doesn’t trust a jury not to look at Twitter
Just a note on Hillsborough and alcohol, given the debate now going on about drinking within view of football pitches.
1. In 2 lengthy inquests and a public inquiry, no credible evidence has been put forward that drinking on 15/4/89 was any different to any other big game of the era
2. Hard data sources such as pub takings, CCTV footage, numbers of arrests, pub/ shop licensee reports and litter bins all suggest that fan behaviour and drinking was unremarkable
3. The Hillsborough Independent Panel found that alcohol consumption was ‘reasonable and unexceptional for a sporting event’
4. The Panel (and the 2016 inquest jury) also found that drinking by *fans* played no part in the genesis of the disaster
5. However, it is not clear what senior police commanders were doing in the run up to the game in their ‘missing hours’. Investigators appear to have hit a wall of silence here.
6. Various inquiries have criticised South Yorkshire Police for promoting - without evidence - a portrayal of drunkenness causing the disaster, in order to deflect from their own very serious failures.
7. The National Police Chiefs Council (formerly ACPO) have apologised for blaming fans for the disaster, and for the police failures that did actually cause it
3/ Your right about the outer cordon not being there in 1989
SYP cut manpower significantly vs 1988 to save overtime, & abandoned the outer ring of crowd barriers in the approach to the ground that worked well in 1988 in regulating the flow of fans to the concourse
Had it been there, fans could have been held there rather than have a dangerous crowd build up in the bottleneck outside the Leppings Lane
4/ We’d know more about why that cordon wasn’t there and other poor planning decisions, if all the minutes of the police planning meetings hadn’t mysteriously disappeared in the aftermath of the disaster, together with other vital evidence such as the control room log and CCTV tapes
When Hicks and Gillett put LFC in serious danger we didn't blame other clubs and how they were able to do things... we blamed our owners. So why are City fans angry at everyone but their owners? Who agreed to the rules that they broke that have put the club in serious danger
What are Man City up to here?
They’ve been nicked because it’s was found that the government were behind sponsorships city claimed were from companies
Now they’re saying, it wasn’t the companies, it was the government, almost an admission of guilt
Is their plan now to try and make it a diplomatic issue and make the PL and UK prosecution to take on Abu Dhabi as a country as opposed to Man City the club?
An attempt at trying to muscle and threaten their way out of cheating. Another reason to seriously consider expelling them from the league.
No evidence has been seen that drinking on 15/4/89 was any different to any other big game at Hillsborough
If you look at hard data sources (rather than rumour and witness evidence) sources such as pub takings, CCTV footage, numbers of arrests, licensee reports and litter bins all suggest that fan behaviour and drinking was unremarkable
We’re saying that:
1) there were no significant amount and no more than other big games of the era that didn’t turn into a disaster - a handful were spotted by CCTV tailgating, jumping a turnstile barrier or one fan bribing at the turnstile
2) most in Sheffield without a ticket were trying to buy outside as before the internet/eBay/ StubHub etc there was match day market for spares that was then common practice and perfectly legal
3) they were anyway irrelevant to the cause of the disaster as there were fewer fans on the terrace than tickets sold - where did all the ticketless fans go?
The issue was distribution across the terraces rather than the total volume.
I’ve put together the analysis below on why multiple inquests and inquiries have consistently found ticketless fans were utterly irrelevant to the causes of the disaster
The Hillsborough disaster can’t have been caused by ticketless fans as it was scientifically proven in court that there were fewer fans on the terraces than there were tickets sold
The 2016 inquest jury found unanimously that fans did not cause or contribute to the disaster
@gordysocceruk Would have been made at Chief Constable level
Mole did offer to police the game and have Duckenfield shadow him, but Duckenfield declined the offer
We’d know more if the minutes of the Mole handover meeting hadn’t disappeared off the face of the earth
There were actually a couple over the drink drive limit, but none of them were driving or operating machinery…they were at a leisure event.
You’d expect a train driver or pilot etc who was driving and died in a crash to have a blood alcohol test after death, but not a 10 year old kid a football match
Just a note on Hillsborough and alcohol, given the debate now going on about drinking within view of football pitches.
1. In 2 lengthy inquests and a public inquiry, no credible evidence has been put forward that drinking on 15/4/89 was any different to any other big game of the era
2. Hard data sources such as pub takings, CCTV footage, numbers of arrests, pub/ shop licensee reports and litter bins all suggest that fan behaviour and drinking was unremarkable
3. The Hillsborough Independent Panel found that alcohol consumption was ‘reasonable and unexceptional for a sporting event’
4. The Panel (and the 2016 inquest jury) also found that drinking by *fans* played no part in the genesis of the disaster
5. However, it is not clear what senior police commanders were doing in the run up to the game in their ‘missing hours’. Investigators appear to have hit a wall of silence here.
6. Various inquiries have criticised South Yorkshire Police for promoting - without evidence - a portrayal of drunkenness causing the disaster, in order to deflect from their own very serious failures.
7. The National Police Chiefs Council (formerly ACPO) have apologised for blaming fans for the disaster, and for the police failures that did actually cause it
Indeed. The 2016 inquest jury specifically found that fans did not cause (nor even contribute to causing) the Hillsborough disaster
That finding was unanimous
However failing by South Yorkshire Police, Sheffield Wednesday FC and theirs engineers, Sheffield City Council, the FA and South Yorks Ambulance Service were identified
@martinsross1@IanByrneMP I’m not arguing that point one way or another.
I’m just responding to extensive online chatter yesterday that Hillsborough was caused by drunken fans, when it objectivity wasn’t