This is borderline incoherent. Comparing 100,000 Somalians stealing from the public purse today to the influx of Italians in 1906 (the year Cato picked) is absurd. The Sixteenth Amendment (allowing for a federal income tax) wasn't even passed until 1913.
Then there's the fact that the entitlements didn't become a substantial fraction of public expenditures until the 1960s, so it was impossible for an immigrant to take more than he produced until that time.
Then there's the fact that GDP is a pretend measure of productivity.
Then there's the fact that Cato ignores all the off-balance sheet costs of immigration like wildly increased health care costs (the emergency room is "free" for the immigrant), increased auto insurance (illegals don't buy insurance, increasing the cost for the rest of us), increased property taxes due to the need to fund higher public school enrollments, and increased housing costs (higher demand drives prices up).
Then there are the soft, but enormous, costs from immigration: the break down in social cohesion, loss of social capital, and loss of trust, increase in identity politics, and all the rest.
But all of this is secondary.
Because the primary point is this: This is our country.
And the problem with immigrants is that they are not us.
They may be great people. They may be honest. They may be hard working. None of that matters now.
Because, they are not us.
And too many of them here at one time will destroy what it means to be "us."
And there are too many of them here right now. At this moment. Today.
And since this is our country and not theirs, we do not need any reason at all (though we have plenty of them) to say: "Enough. Every illegal has to leave immediately and, further, we need a 50 year moratorium on legal immigration after which time our descendants can revisit the issue."
After all, this is our country. Not theirs.
@CatholicVote Pro Life Inc gets an opportunity to virtue signal opposition and fundraise on this, while continuing to attack Trump despite him scoring them their biggest victory ever that they themselves failed to accomplish
While this graphic might be accurate for a lot of the old guard GOP, it needs an update in light of the changes the GOP has undergone throughout the Trump era, and to represent another factor involved in this effect.
Almost every democrat policy involves increasing entropy in some way, creating greater disorder within our society. Right wing policies are centered around the opposite. It is always easier to do the former than the latter, and additionally, the democrats have built an entire institutional framework around ensuring more of our civilization falls into disorder.
Think of illegal immigration, for example. To remove one illegal immigrant, you need:
- A system that can track and identify them
- Agents and equipment to locate and detain them
- A facility to hold them
- A court and judge to oversee their case
- Vehicles to transport them
- Funding and time to account for all of the above
- You'll also be fighting an entire institution designed to exploit any possible method to slow or stop your attempts to do all of this
To allow an illegal immigrant in you need:
- Nothing, you just let them in
This graphic suggests republicans as playing an equal role in securing the leftward drift of the country. The conclusion from this would be the withdraw from support of the party. This is not a reasonable response to the situation as we face it today.
The real ratchet is that every disordered action the democrats commit to is orders of magnitude more difficult to fix than it is to do. We need to be doing everything we can to ensure these people do not hold the reins of power. There is nothing to be gained from playing the "both sides are bad" game.
Invaders who refuse to assimilate discriminate against local girl
When she speaks their language in her own country (because they refuse to learn English) all the sudden they are nice
I want so many deportations that I don’t have to press 1 for English in the US.
"Candidate quality" is by and large just a talking point that is effectively used to muzzle conservatives, and most conservatives fall for it. It is insufficient and a distraction from Republicans' real disadvantages.
I am not saying candidate quality doesn't matter, but it's mostly marginal.
When Dems have "bad" candidates (Jones 2025, AES 2026, Fetterman 2022), they generally still win albeit by a slightly lesser margin than the "better" candidate on the same ticket.
When Republicans have "bad" candidates (Moore 2017, Graham 2026) red states are flipped and it's catastrophic.
Democrats have ballot harvesting, an extremely loyal voter base, and the entirety of the media narrative on their side to mitigate devastating losses and pummel "bad" Republicans.
Republicans need to compete on voter loyalty, ballot harvesting, and offense against opponents if they want to win elections. You can spend all your energy trying to find "perfect" candidates, and you'll either lose anyway and/or lose the entirety of your platform.
This feels a little insincere, but I’ll bite.
I don’t want to retype all the stats that most people have probably seen by this point so I will simply rehash the following: any post-election political “analysis” that does not first and foremost address the statical shocks and anomalies that make this midterm election the strangest in my lifetime and maybe in American history has already disqualified itself. Dismissing it as saying “yeah well the GOP did fine compared to recent years but the Dems showed up like it was a presidential year” and leaves it at that is immediately and overwhelmingly disqualifying.
If Republicans voted for in a midterm like that, we would take California. If we took California — and even if it was *just* California — you and Dems alike would be asking questions that seem a lot more absurd and detached from reality or “sensible commentary” than the ones people like me are asking right now.
So, Republicans broke a lot of records and lost seats they have not lost (prior to this election) yet this century, in almost a whole century, or some in even over a century. Furthermore, House seats of incumbents over time have about a 98% reelection rate and senators are about 92%. Yet we lost an absolutely shocking and I mean shocking amount of 3-6x incumbent seats that two years ago went red by 10-20 or and still got slaughtered without data showing Republicans defecting in unusual numbers.
Furthermore, Republicans broke a lot of records for most votes for a race in state history. In many cases, even if they did not get those records they still got enough votes to win any prior race in their states history, and yet still got slaughtered.
Continuing, Dems have gotten more votes than most Presidential candidates this century and are even close to getting more votes than Obama did in 08’ when he broke a record for most votes for a candidate in US history — a record not broken again until… 2020. And all of this in a midterm?
I can just keep going and going but you get the point.
All political “analysis” — which is really generous to call it that — focuses purely on **plausible** explanations and nothing more.
**This is not good enough!**
From a simple game theoretic approach, no matter where on earth your starting point was, none of this “strategizing” would make sense for even a second.
Where do you anticipate getting the extra 15-20mm votes from in 2 years? Where? And what if they break another record? In 2026 total Dem projections are approaching 2x the vote count that 2014 had. What is your plan for that perpetually rising ceiling for Dem votes?
If you don’t focus on Qtards, taking the election as being functionally fraudulent or stolen is far more brave, honest, and practical, where everyone pretending otherwise is trying to save face for being so wrong before and turning this into a reframing of how they were only temporarily disgraced but are still super serious and dignified and sensible in their disposition.
This is embarrassing and it is difficult to not hate everyone doing this.
So let me provide a brief breakdown for you:
The **nature** of our “democracy” is two-sided. There is the governing side and the winning of elections side. The governing side doesn’t really matter all that much right now because if we ever lose an election again we are functionally done for. So only as an input into the winning of election side is it really worth our primary focus.
And if you understand the election to be practically stolen you understand your existential battle is one of harvesting votes and manufacturing the infrastructure and safeguards around this more than it is about sensible speculation about which policy is going to get us 20-30mm to appear out of thin air in two years because the fucking high integrity geniuses on X put the magical string of words in their tweets together right.
So tell me, again, which one is more pragmatic?
The one that wants to desperately harvest votes or… debate Iran
This actually proves the point that Hispanics are an ethnic 5th column. The U.S. gains nothing from having Hispanics in the country, they’re financially burdensome, culturally alien & politically hostile.
They are the primary driver of demographic change & national decline.
If you want to drive young men away from the Church, demand that they sacrifice their neighborhoods and their nation for the material benefit of immigrant lawbreakers. “But they contribute to the economy!” says the bishop. This looks like corporate neoliberalism wearing Catholicism as a skin suit.
@GmorganJr I’m sure you graduated from there right? Or you’re a fan because your uncle’s best friend’s cousin’s old roommate went there so it’s a “family” thing. Like 99% of the rest of your fraud fake Larp Catholic fan base
Trump has endorsed an immigration deal with Democrats every year since 2017, and he has shot the bills down every time.
Trump has offered a pass to illegals who work or have ties here, then does the opposite. So far this is only words, his actions keep blocking amnesty.
Trump said he likes legal immigration, then cut it the sharpest levels since 1924. He said he wants student visas — they halved. He said take a softer touch on deportations: ICE arrests surged to the highest levels ever.
Look at the actions next to the words, then react.
Trump literally just made Stephen Miller his chief of staff and you still have people thinking comments like these are anything other than PR language for the general public.
@GmorganJr Good thing we have a very unbiased Notre dame fan giving us this critical analysis that’s totally correct and not shaded at all by his desire for the outcome of the play to benefit his non alma mater