what there is no overwhelming agreement on is what will happen the day after. how do we build a livable future here, for both israelis and palestinians. israel leadership is not thinking of this now, future looks grim. THIS is where protest effort and outrage should be invested.
can someone ELI5 me what can "the lean and mathlib communities" do in a couple of days to verify a multi-million-lines lean proof that cannot also be done by a single person (that is, checking the premise, running the verifier and waiting)
The Lean FRO and Mathlib Initiative have released a joint statement on the Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis.
On November 20, Levent Alpรถge released a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis as a Lean library of 17 million lines of code. Over the past day, the Lean and Mathlib communities worked together to verify it. The statement certifies the proof as correct and describes how it meets all necessary verification criteria.
Congratulations to Levent on this achievement, and thank you to everyone in the community who contributed to the verification.
Full statement: https://t.co/edxEbkodw7
my hot take on RH and this entire trend: to my machines finding long Lean proofs to hard problems I don't care about is like machines finding md5 hash collisions. cool it can be done but not too suprising (we know its hard, we know its doable), and kinda useless overall so meh.
(it is still kinda interesting because a human was able to intervene and guide the search, which is much harder to do currently for md5 collision search. but at the core its heuristic search with a very strong heuristic)
@existsShachar sure, but for this i would trust mathematicians more, no? though, yeah, verifying the premise and its formalization is indeed a legit thing to do. i was curious if they did more than that, like sanity checks on the code or whatever
educate yourself
...
no no not with chatgpt!
(here is a bunch of namedropped serious books that are marginally relevant and you will never read anyhow, and a bunch of conspiracy blogs)
its hard to make an impact in a positive way when the general public associates you with crazy detached views of reality. cannot make a change without distancing.
even within the academic community: i can say that me personally, i considered facct a serious important venue at the beginning. i now don't, and i dont care enough to try and find out "the truth" let alone submit there, because to the outside, you are very strongly associated with this group of radicals who shall not be named