AN OPEN LETTER TO FUNDEDNEXT
Over $19,000 in Profits Denied — Is This Really How We Treat Traders?
Dear @FundedNext,
I'm writing this publicly as Rami Asalya, founder of Traders Cave, on behalf of my student, Sham Fares, who has been denied a Performance Reward of over $19,000.
I have spent over 12 years in the financial markets, mentoring traders and helping people build the discipline, knowledge, and consistency required to succeed.
And today, I find myself asking a very serious question:
Since when did taking similar trades on accounts belonging to the same trader become a reason to deny someone the profits they worked so hard to generate?
Sham did not use a trade copier. She did not use automated software. She manually executed her trades based on her own analysis and trading decisions.
Yet FundedNext has decided to withhold more than $19,000, citing its copy trading policy.
I understand that prop firms have rules. I respect the importance of compliance, and I always teach my students to respect the conditions of the firms they trade with.
But there is a difference between enforcing rules and enforcing them in a way that raises serious questions about fairness.
If a trader identifies an opportunity in the market and independently executes the same idea across accounts they personally own, does that automatically make them a copy trader?
If manual execution is prohibited under certain circumstances, how clearly is that communicated to traders before they invest their time, money, and effort?
And most importantly:
Should a trader lose over $19,000 without receiving a detailed explanation of the specific trades and evidence supporting such a serious decision?
We're talking about real people here.
People who spend countless hours studying charts, managing risk, controlling their emotions, and working toward financial independence.
For Sham, this isn't just a number on a dashboard. It's the result of dedication, discipline, and hard work.
What concerns me most is the message decisions like this send to the trading community.
Are prop firms supposed to encourage disciplined, profitable traders, or make them increasingly afraid that their profits could be denied after they've earned them?
I am not asking FundedNext for special treatment.
I am asking for transparency, accountability, and fairness.
If Sham violated a clearly established rule, provide the specific evidence, explain exactly how the violation occurred, and demonstrate why withholding the entire reward is justified.
But if the decision is based primarily on similarities between manually executed trades, then I believe the case deserves a serious and independent review.
FundedNext has built its reputation on providing opportunities to traders worldwide.
The question now is whether that commitment extends to protecting traders when a payout dispute arises.
I respectfully call on @FundedNext to reconsider Sham Fares' case, provide a transparent explanation, and allow a senior compliance review of the decision to withhold her $19,000+ Performance Reward.
To the trading community, I want to ask one question:
Do you believe a trader should lose $19,000+ simply because they manually executed similar trades across their own accounts?
I'd genuinely like to hear your thoughts.
Rami Asalya
Founder, Traders Cave
12+ Years in Financial Markets
#FundedNext #PropTrading #TradingCommunity #TraderRights #Transparency