read this late, damn. would've offered my 2016 work called "punctuations" that's made up of redacted text from Duterte's first State of the Nation Address, all words and letters removed, only spaces and punctuations intact
I'm offering a USD$500 reward to the first person who can present pre-2020 human-written text that the latest version of @pangram flags as AI.
The specific requirements to claim the reward are:
1. At least 750 consecutive words.
2. Pangram flags it as 75% or more AI generated.
3. You provide proof that the text was first written in 2019 or earlier and is unmodified.
4. The text was ostensibly human written. This requirement only exists to avoid trick answers like output from GPT-2, machine translation, markov chains, the same word 500 times etc.
Regarding requirement #3, unfortunately in 2026 there's no way to prove that new text wasn't AI generated, so what I need provided is proof that the text existed in 2019 or earlier, before AI writing got so good. For example, valid proof might be:
- A link to the text on a website that's been logged by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine before 2020.
- A link to a paper published on a third party website with a pre-2020 publication date. Note: I will need to be able to access the paper through the same website that has its publication date. Otherwise someone could send a modern AI generated paper and simply link to the date and abstract of a paper with the same name but different content.
- A chapter from a book edition with a known pre-2020 publication date where I can access a pre-2020 copy for myself. Note: For the same reasons as above, simply sending a passage of text and a link to a book's name and publication date doesn't prove anything on its own. The ideal situation would either be that there's an eBook of it available somewhere with a known pre-2020 upload date, or it's a well-known enough book that the content simply couldn't be faked everywhere.
Q&A:
"Why are you offering this reward?"
Some people are blaming the detector because they don't want to admit to using AI for their writing. I don't like people lying for personal gain.
"Are you affiliated with Pangram in any way?"
No.
"How do I submit something to you?"
Just reply to this tweet with the necessary info and I'll have a look when I can.
"How can I trust you to judge fairly?"
I'll publicly reply with my verdict on submissions and the world can judge me. The world can also judge you - please only submit something if it really fits all the criteria. Especially since I'll need to review all submissions in my free time.
"But it's my private writing, can I send it to you privately?"
If it's always been private then how will you prove that it's pre-2020?
"I have the perfect example but I left the text with my girlfriend in Canada."
She can submit it and win $500.
"Won't this be trivially easy to claim? I heard even chapters of Don Quixote and Moby-Dick get fully flagged as AI!"
Tell me which chapter and win $500.
"Conversely, isn't 750 words at >=75% a high bar? If Pangram is so reliable, why not 1%?"
At very low word counts Pangram IS somewhat unreliable, and with a monetary incentive I can imagine someone scanning every book on Project Gutenberg just to find one paragraph that's falsely flagged as AI. At the same time, most claims that Pangram is flagging human writing as AI have it showing the entire text as AI. I recently saw someone on X say that they personally knew of "thousands" of examples of human text that was flagged like this (unfortunately they declined to mention any). So I've set the bar somewhere in the middle.
"But Pangram was trained on existing text; that's why it always flags OLD text as human but falsely flags NEW text."
As far as I'm aware this isn't really how Pangram works. But I'd love to be able to award this bounty for new human writing, it's just that there's no way to verify people's honesty online for the new stuff.
"How will you pay out if I win?"
However works. Probably an international bank transfer via @Wise .
"How can I help?"
When someone says they know of an old published paper or story that Pangram flags as AI, you could point them to this tweet. They can win $500.
"How long will your offer last if nobody wins?"
As long as this post is up. If you're reading this, it's still available.
I built an open-source chain analysis tool that anyone can use.
It requires no payment, no login, and no data you search is ever seen by Tracey’s server.
Everything you search in Tracey is processed directly in your browser.
All of Tracey’s heuristics are public and have clearly described shortcomings. The entire website comes with tooltips explaining to you what each step does. Most of its clustering rules are pulled from the disclosed research papers, some I wrote myself to be more conservative.
I built Tracey for myself, but thought it might be useful to other people as well – especially in light of all the recent thefts of funds. It can’t help you create evidence, but it may help you find some leads on where your money is moving on bitcoin. 1/4 🔽
Writing is the superpower of humankind. It is our truest form of magic.
Writing allows you to conjure up something of value where nothing previously existed. It costs little for you to write down the lessons of your life and yet those few minutes spent writing can be life-altering for the right reader. As I once saw it put: "there is someone out there with a wound in the exact shape of your words."
Furthermore, writing is the foundation of nearly every technology and innovation because we have to record what we know before we can build upon it. And these innovations are passed down from generation to generation, allowing our children to inherit a richer intellectual fortune than what we were born into. The world is richer because we write and nobody is made poorer in the process.
was reviewing old notes for my first full-length collection when I stumbled upon a 2017 bookmark, which was a year after I began formalizing drafts for this manuscript
Ludwig, man, you are sorely missed by this world, or perhaps one could say, this world has you, missing in it
“it’s so boring now”
no you’re just older
“Projects don’t get the same excitement anymore”
yeah because everyone playing around with them has a mortgage and kids to think about now
"machines are not fixed objects but processes in becoming, defined by the networks of relations in which they are embedded"
Griziotti summarizing Simondon
cogent read
https://t.co/sfj0SvJgR9
@resistancemoney in writing i refer to any output and the generic ideas around what LLMs could do as "the generative" -- a specific contrast compared to anything else that could be argued to be "organic"
- doesn't mean tho that "the generative" in this case couldn't be classified as "creative"
@resistancemoney I self-studied biblical Greek and Latin as preparation for seminary (before philosophy). I gave up after a year 🤡
It takes a lifetime to study biblical texts as comparative literature. I have zero respect for anyone who dismisses these disciplines.
Sad to share I have been let go from The Block.
It’s been a great two years working with some of the best journalists in crypto media. I’m proud of the stories I wrote, the edits I made and the people I got to know. I wish the team all the best as the company tries to rightsize. It’s been a difficult time for crypto media, with many worthy competitors cutting back or closing down entirely — but if any firm could weather the storm, it is likely The Block.
This could not have come at a worse time. My wife and I are expecting a baby girl next month and we just closed on an apartment.
If you know of any role in media, research, content or otherwise that could use a strong writer/editor with deep crypto knowledge, experience breaking and shaping stories under deadline, and a track record of thriving in fast-moving newsrooms as well as putting together long-term editorial packages, I’d be grateful to hear about it. Happy to share clips or chat.
@resistancemoney makes it interesting if an LLM could match a neurodivergent's response if trained as such
Q: "give me examples of what a flower could be"
A: "the sky remains because it is blue"
i recommend anyone who travels to use grapheneos and set up a duress pin & pw (and rotate both before every trip). the chances of being forced to unlock your phone, whether at a border crossing or somewhere on the street, are only going up in this insane world. it's _your_ fucking phone, your data, and your private life. nobody except you has any right to access its contents. period.
https://t.co/82h4VzIWms
@davidzmorris I applied to two roles at Anthropic and made Claude Fable 5 criticize my arguments. Works great for cleaning out fuzzy logic and piecing together statistics and data, but doesn't really do any real thinking of its own. Human judgment would be of 1000x value from here, I guess.