baran A

computer engineering👩‍💻
& Clothing designer👗

[baran A @149240b2dc0c427]

@EngPor3134 @EWaraha @PoporSapsiree You can only buy fake members 🤣 but the reality won't change... I hope we don't see an "Angpour" divorce a while from now 🤣
พวกคุณทำได้แค่ซื้อสมาชิกปลอมเท่านั้นแหละ 🤣 พวกคุณกำลังอยู่ในโลกแห่งจินตนาการล้วนๆ เลย...

[BK 𓍼 @commentGL]

Curtir fotos da parceria é alimentar fanservice ❌

Beijar a parceira na frente dos fãs não é alimentar fanservice ✅

[★ @aurora21babyyy]

les juro que jamás voy a entender como alguien puede decir que te ama, que le gustas, hablan de un futuro juntos y luego mentirte, ocultarte cosas, borrar conversaciones, tenerte en la sombra, ocultarte a ti, burlarse de ti, verse con alguien a escondidas, hablarse con más personas, hacerte sentir insegura, engañarte y luego culparte por tu desconfianza

[kerot potato 🥔 @kerot_ostin]

Engfa, u keep lecturing your fans to focus on your work instead of your private life which would have been fine if u were not the one who started this career sharing every little thing including brushing your teeth. How your work partner was sleeping on your lap. Knelt on stage in front of her. Talked about making merit to meet her in the next life. How serious you are that you waited for her for more than a year. How you will always be there when she turns around. But since those were years ago, OK, let’s move on from that.

A year ago you pulled your work partner for a kiss in Paris in front of 200 hundred fans. OK, maybe a year ago is too distant for your short memory.

Last June 27, u were a surprised guest in Charlotte’s event bundled with a surprised presscon where u famously said that u & Popor are NOTHING. That was just over 3 months ago. If you want us to focus on your work instead of your personal life u should have SHUT UP after that & told your lover not to be an attention seeking asshole.

But instead u frequently go live in the succeeding months to give lectures about life & love like some preacher. U also repeatedly said that u are single & lonely. And you promised your fans that they will hear from u first if u are dating.

BUT in fact you u not single. Let’s not fool each other here. There was something even before June 27. You LIED when all these years u sell this image of being honest, transparent, REAL. And what’s worse is that u lie so blatantly that we feel insulted taken as fools.

And there is that fateful day on September 12 when your lover decided to expose how much love there is between you two. Is she not aware that u promised your fans they will hear it from u? Is she not aware how u love giving a list of the qualities u are looking for a partner that includes understanding your work & being respectful? Why are u SHAMELESSLY putting the blame on fans & not on your lover who broadcast your private matters on social media? You think it’s “manly” that she went on to release that statement amid all the backlash? Engfa, it was not the FIRST TIME your dear Popor provoked a fandom & disrespected the work partner. She INTENTIONALLY invited the chaos. She knew how exposing your relationship, your lies, will trigger a massive scandal. Are u that dumb not to see that?

Do u know how much of an insult that is that u were like a giddy teenager on national TV blushing about your lover’s public declaration of love in the wake of your hurt fans? When her actions caused harm to the EngLot brand that is not just about u but another person who worked on building it for almost five years? When a big event that involves many people were marred by a scandal.

U had the nerve to praise her before you could utter a single sorry to the many people negatively affected by her crazy act. If not for the backlash after those two interviews you wouldn’t bring your sad face back and finally give a forced apology to your fans.

U asked what can u do, it happened already. U know what u could have done? U should have come up and apologized yourself immediately instead of that statement from your assistant & mother.

U know what u should do in the future if u want people to focus on your work? Tell your lover to stop provoking fans, seek clout & attention. While u should shut up unless necessary. No one is forcing the two of u to use IG for public display of affection.

Stop painting your fans as villains who are preventing u to live your life, make mistakes & learn from it. U are free to do all that while being mindful that u are a public figure that directly benefits from public attention & in return carry social responsibilities.

Take that mirror u were talking about the other day and take a hard long look at yourself @EWaraha

[skyandstars @starsandsky2112]

I'm sorry if this post comes across as harsh or toxic. I NEED to say this.

“Interfans go, leave, I don't care.” Biased? Wild? Seriously? Who the hell do you think you are? The way you talk about international fans, you'd think they're some kind of animals crawling at your feet, desperately chasing after you.

Mind you, many of these people have a good upbringing, loving families, successful careers, comfortable lives, and some might even be far richer than you. They have lives OUTSIDE of you. They're not beneath you just because they chose to support you.

And yet, some of them STILL chose to stay. Not because they lack self-respect, but because unlike you, they value those FIVE YEARS. The memories, the emotions, the time, the effort, and the hard-earned MONEY they invested in you. Five years might be easy for you to dismiss when you've always been on the receiving end. For the people who gave, it's a different story.

But let me say this to every single fan: YOUR SELF-RESPECT COMES FIRST.

Even if this kid, whom I absolutely adore, told me to walk away tomorrow, I'd gladly walk away. I'd still wish her well, but I would NEVER beg anyone to let me support them. My love for an artist will never be greater than the respect I have for myself.

And to the interfans from MY country, I'm genuinely requesting you all to STEP AWAY. I can't speak for fans from other countries, but to my fellow people, come on. We are built differently. We were not raised to keep accepting disrespect just because we once loved and supported someone.

You can cherish those five years without sacrificing your dignity for a sixth.

You don't owe anyone your loyalty at the expense of your self-respect.

And to some of y'all coming here telling me I'm disrespecting the kid by not listening to what she said, you're entitled to your opinion, just as much as I'm entitled to mine. If you have something to say, so do I. Feel free to unfollow or block me, as usual. Nobody's stopping you🙃

With that being said, I’m taking a break from this headache of an app. See y’all later, maybe✌️

[someproblemhere @someproblemhere]

การปรากฏตัวในไลฟ์ล่าสุด คือภาพสะท้อนของการใช้ "บทบาทผู้ถูกกระทำ (Victim Narrative)" เพื่อเบี่ยงประเด็นเรื่องสัจจะและความโปร่งใส .
ในขณะที่ "สื่อกระแสหลักในประเทศเลือกที่จะไม่พูดความจริง" พยายามละเลยข้อเท็จจริงเรื่องการไม่เคารพผู้บริโภค และช่วยฟอกขาวเพื่อรักษาคอนเนกชัน PR และขายข่าวเรตติ้ง... แต่ในสายตาของ "แ��รนด์ระดับสากลและผู้จัดงานมืออาชีพ" บริบทมันต่างออกไปโดยสิ้นเชิง
สื่อท้องถิ่นอาจช่วยปกปิดความจริงและบิดเบือนภาพจำให้ดูเป็นเหยื่อเพื่อเซฟกระแสในบ้าน แต่เอเยนซี่และแบรนด์ชั้นนำประเมินความเสี่ยงจาก Brand Safety และความซื่อสัตย์ เมื่อเห็นการจัดการวิกฤตที่ไร้ความเป็นมืออาชีพ แบรนด์ใหญ่จะเลือก "เงียบและไม่ต่อสัญญา (Quiet Non-Renewal)"
การซ่อนตัวหลังสคริปต์ความสงสารและการที่สื่อไม่พูดความจริง ไม่สามารถลบกลไกธุรกิจได้—เพราะมูลค่าที่แท้จริงในระดับสากล สร้างขึ้นจาก สัจจะ ความจริงใจ และความรับผิดชอบ ไม่ใช่การปกปิดความจริงครับ
Last night’s live stream was a textbook attempt to use a Weaponized Victim Narrative and performative sorrow to evade core accountability.
While local mainstream media deliberately avoid the truth—choosing to stay silent on core issues like consumer disrespect and broken trust just to preserve PR access and drive clickbait—global brands and industry peers see through the noise.
Local media may turn a blind eye to the truth and assist in whitewashing the story, but top-tier sponsors evaluate artists on Brand Safety, integrity, and commercial risk. When confronted with unpredictable liability, double standards, and unprofessional crisis management, major brands quietly respond with "Quiet Non-Renewal."
Hiding behind performative vulnerability while local media conceals the truth will never alter commercial realities: True global brand equity is built on integrity, transparency, and genuine respect for consumers—never on media-assisted cover-ups.

[Muffin de canela 🏳️‍🌈 @balmain1996]

Engfa dijo tantas veces que Charlotte debía crecer y madurar que ahora es más madura Charlotte que Engfa. Sigue así, reina ♥️

[Cami 🐶🤍🐰 @CamilaUM234]

C: Siempre nos hemos amado, pero ambos fingíamos. Éramos demasiado jóvenes para entender qué era el amor en aquel entonces. Pero nunca pudimos soltarnos de la mano

/En esa rueda de prensa Char tambien dijo eso, a ver si entienden que ella ama a Engfa

[alinn @alincharm]

อย่าหลงรักคนในอดีต จนมองไม่เห็นความจริงตรงหน้าในปัจจุบัน การที่เขาดีกับเราในวันนั้น ไม่ได้แปลว่าเขาจะดีกับเราในวันนี้ อย่าตัดสินคนจากสิ่งที่เขาเคยเป็นในอดีต แต่ให้ดูว่าปัจจุบันเขาในวันนี้เป็นแบบไหน และอย่ากลัวที่จะตัดใครออกไปจากชีวิต เพียงเพราะเขาเคยมีความหมายกับเรา

[shady ᴱᴸ @shady_oneee]

i do want to believe she’s acting this way because of nawat, because he needs a new ship now that the el one is coming to an end. but we still have months to go before cha’s contract ends.

engfa, you say you don’t want to give us false hope by blurring the lines between work and professionalism, yet you’ve always insisted that what the two of you shared was genuine. you’ve never seemed to be faking anything, nor did you ever need to. we stayed by your side even during those months when you barely looked at each other. so i’m honestly not sure what exactly you meant by saying that.

but at this point, it’s hard to remain indifferent to the whole situation, especially after you confirmed that you were once in love and that you were dating.

you don’t owe us the details of something so private, and i respect that. but considering all the years we’ve been through together as a fandom, i can’t help feeling that we’re being treated far too coldly right now. you speak as though our doubts and questions are somehow ridiculous, when they’re actually quite understandable given everything you’ve told us and everything we’ve witnessed ourselves. we’re only human. we get attached, we get emotional, and we care deeply about the things that have brought us so much happiness over the years.

you keep explaining things and answering our questions, yet somehow it feels like you’re not really addressing any of them. it’s always the same professional, distant phrases that leave us with more questions than answers. and honestly, that hurts at this point. not because we believe we’re entitled to know everything, but because after all these years, i think a little more warmth and understanding wouldn’t be too much to ask for.

[Rocío A. 🧤🧣 @rociooaalvarado]

igual pensando todo de manera fría, es como súper oscuro todo lo que hizo E. Pq creo que está muy cegada, y enojada. Y cuando despierte, si es que lo hace, es imposible que no se de cuenta, del daño que le hizo a C, y no hay nadie que no se arrepienta dsps.

[微醺小熊猫🐼Englot🇨🇳 @lutang960182047]

我想说几句感受：

有人可能把Englot在MGI框架下合作关系的结束，当成天塌下来的大事；可回看这半年，这真的突然吗？这难道不是早就知道、迟早会发生的事吗？粉丝一直盼着她们离开那个有毒的环境，而因为合约期限不同，必然会有一个人先离开公司，不是吗？可能我们期盼的是一次平缓的降落，而不是一次迫降，一个完美的告别，但结局其实是一样的。如果这次事件，加快C离开的速度，未尝不是一件好事，她还有广阔的天地去探索。

E说，Englot除了完成已有的双人工作，其他她们不再接受了；但Englot的羁���，依旧保持它本真的样子。
至于这段关系会不会延续到职业之外，那是她们两个人要去面对、要去学习的课题。不是粉丝能替她们走的路，也不是一句“永远在一起”就能解决的事。

说实话，我知道工作关系框架下CP的结束对大家来说都非常难过，面对未知的未来，难过得像自己青春里的一盏灯突然灭了，也需要时间治愈，拥抱每一个在心痛中挣扎的家人🫂。

但回到E和C两个人身上，Englot首先不仅仅是标签，是hashtag的一个话题，Englot里面包括两个鲜活的人类—Engfa和Charlotte，一开始就真诚而真实的与彼此相处，这是两个有情绪、有自我，会心动、会开���、会吃醋、会生气、会难过、会沉默、会逞强、会把在意藏起来的人类。她们需要从“ship”里真正跳脱出来，去学习彼此该如何相处。

作为内容创作者，我很清楚，一段音乐、一个滤镜、一次慢放，就能让画面看起来浪漫得像永远；我也知道，有些片段剪出来会很有趣，会让人心动。但真正的她们，我们可能只了解5％，她们的真实现实生活，也不仅仅是Tiktok里的片段。

也是在内容创作过程中，我发现她们很多时候并不擅长处理彼此的关系，即使岁数看似成熟，但一个人的情感处理方式和她的工作阅历无关，可能更多的是关系到她们的童年和情感创伤——两个人都会有情绪失控的时候，都会吃醋，却因为自尊，也可能因为工作关系的限制，不说，也不表现，在意彼此但很逞强。那些吃醋的片段被剪成视频，过了两三年，她们才意识到对方真的会吃醋；相爱但不说出口。即使是将近五年的今天，我依旧认为她们还是不太擅长处理情感问题😂因为在工作的环境下，她们要顾虑的事情太多了，她们连吃醋都不敢说，连在意都要藏，也许还要走很多弯路。可如果她们脱离ship这个环境，真正仅作为两个人类去相处，或者她们仍然想发展彼此的关系，那她们就必须自己去探索、去学习：学习沟通，学习倾听对方的需求，学习如何真正携手走下去。没有BGM，没有滤镜，没有重拍，没有后期。她们只能跌跌撞撞地学，可能最后就是走向不同的路，遇见的机会少了，但羁绊不断，兜兜转转还是会遇见对方。

也许未来，她们会成为把对方放在心里、远远祝福对方的人。
也许不再并肩，不再同框，不再有那些让我们心动的瞬间。
但Englot这五年的美好时光和回忆，
不光是粉丝的，也是她们的。
五年，不仅仅是五部series，不仅仅是几段视频，不仅仅是几个tag，最重要，它从来不是一场营业，它是有两个人类和113一个家，用真诚和真心打造的！
五年是她们和我们真实走过的青春，是笑过、哭过、并肩过的日子。
那些光，不是假的。
那些眼泪，不是假的。
那些曾经下意识护住对方的瞬间，也不是假的。

所以，别再用仇恨给这段关系收尾。
我们可以难过，可以舍不得，可以哭，可以意难平。
但请记得，她们比我们更早面对失去。
她们不是我们人生里的角色，她们是活生生的人。

如果这就是结局，
愿它不是谁输谁赢，
而是两个女孩终于从ship里走出来，
学会作为自己，作为人类，去爱，去告别，去成长。

Englot，五年，刻骨铭心。
哪怕以��不再并肩，也愿她们各自���光。
愿她们被温柔对待。
愿我们记得就好。
记得，就已经是爱过。

PS：我依旧和Englot在一起，不打算离开，因为我直说了吧，我五月推算的塔罗（我也看到有很多人不同时间推算的，都出现了非常相似的内容，我相信宇宙冥冥之中自有天意），一步步都实现了，包括近期C走向时尚路线的时间点，所以我要留下来见证一下后续🐼😎

[baran A @149240b2dc0c427]

#EngfaWaraha
ฉันหวังว่าเราทุกคนจะใช้ชีวิตอยู่อย่างสันติสุข🙏
Inglot Never Dies💔
#EngfaWaraha

[baran A @149240b2dc0c427]

@Beale_Harkness สถานการณ์อันน่าเกลียดนี้ไม่ใช่เรื่องของการที่ชาร์ล็���ตต์จะจากไปอย่างราบรื่น แต่เป็นเรื่องของหนี้สินมูลค่า 180 ล้านบาทของ MGI ต่างหาก

[mehak🌷💌~ @Beale_Harkness]

If someday it comes out that this was all staged, Nawat is forcing Engfa to do all this coz popcorn is a sponsor + E is still bound by contract and as a condition to let Char get out of the contact peacefully,
i swear i ll lose my mind & k*ll that man (u guys better be my alibi)

[barrosoChar2203 @AleBarr77971928]

Eu venho aqui hj serei breve mas eu gostaria a todos fãs de Engfa mais todos mesmo,
Irei fazer uma pergunta bem objetiva e pfv só de sua opinião aqui quem realmente vá falar a vdd PFv,
Quando Charlotte por anos sofreu todos tipo de agressão não física mais mentalmente, espiritual e que quase a levou a morte, pq vcs não expressaram este tipo de sentimento que hj vcs estão em todos os streaming fazendo pela Engfa,
Vcs deixaram de seguir Charlotte, vcs soltaram a mão dela, no momento que mais ela queria vcs lá
Vcs a humilharam, vcs jogaram a dignidade dela no chão tudo por causa da imagem, da Engfa do Nawat, aí eu deixa está pergunta,

1 vcs acham certo tudo que Engfa está fazendo com sua ex parceira,

2 vcs acham que este ano todo quem mais amor e quem mais cuidou de seus fãs e se preocupou sempre foi ou Charlotte

3 vcs acham digno de vcs, fãs que estão a 5 ano nesta caminhada juntos com elas aceita tudo que Engfa está fazendo, acaba com englot assim sem deixa sua ex parceira de GL fala,

4 vcs irão migrar do englot para o novo Shipper, engpop, ou vcs terão dignidade de apoia Charlotte sim ou não

Última pergunta, vcs acham certo está dando tags para uma mulher que do nada soltou a mao se quem ela passou 5 anos dizendo que não soltava que a pouco dia disse em uma entrevista que são amigas e em 3 dias. Não teve a coragem de tocar no nome da Charlotte, pfv pense e reflitam imagine se fosse vcs de que maneira vc agiriam, pfv se puder compartilhar para chegar aos fãs todos delas para tentamos acabar com está situação e começamos a viver uma nova história,
O que eu entendi neste dias e vendo estes vídeos, da entrevista da Engfa eu entendi a ingfa tomou sua decisão de nao caminha mais com Charlotte,e ela fez sua escolha,
E hj lendo o recado da Charlotte eu entendi
, tudo, quando ela diz cada pessoa faz sua escolha e nós temos que aceitar
Então vamos responder está pergunta
Abraço volto dia 18 com Charlotte estamos de férias os Smiley junto com CHar vamos tomar banho de amor e anda descalço na areia deixaremos bankoker por um tempo longe
E ingfa curtindo seu novo parceiro
Até a volta dia 18 estamos de volta e que acabe logo isso, como Charlotte disse vamos viver o nosso melhor bjusss charlotinhas e até breve

[Peuuwithenglot @EngfaChar069]

I deleted my last post after spending the entire day fighting with my own heart. I tried to convince myself to forget them, move on, and even be angry with Engfa. I thought that if I let my anger take over, maybe it would become easier to let go of everything I've felt for the past four years.

But the truth is, I couldn't do it.

No matter how hurt I am, I cannot erase four years of memories and affection overnight. And then I reminded myself that Engfa is human too. We all make mistakes, we fight, we misunderstand each other, and sometimes our pride speaks louder than our hearts. But does every fight have to be the end? Must two people who once meant so much to each other become strangers forever?

Engfa and Charlotte, if there's one thing I wish you would do, it's this: look into each other's eyes. Forget the cameras, the fans, and the world outside. Just look at each other as two people who have shared so much of their lives.

Close your eyes and ask yourselves honestly: After everything that has happened, after staying apart, are you truly convinced that you can live the rest of your lives without each other?

If the answer is yes, then go ahead. Choose your happiness. Nobody should be forced to stay where their heart no longer wants to be. But if there's still something left unsaid, something worth understanding, please don't let anger or pride make a decision you might regret for years.

There's a saying: "If you love someone, let them go. If they come back, they are yours." But I believe love isn't only about coming back. Sometimes, it's about having the courage to return, apologise, listen, forgive, and try to understand each other again.

Because it's easy to walk away in a moment of anger, but staying beside someone through difficult times takes patience, maturity, forgiveness, and experience. Four years doesn't guarantee forever, but those years deserve to be remembered with honesty and respect.

I don't know what November 8th will bring. Maybe nothing will change. Maybe we'll finally find some clarity. I don't want to assume anything or create expectations that neither of them has given us.

But I'll wait until November 8th. Not because they owe us a reunion, but because my heart needs a little more time. For four years, I've cared about them both, and despite all the hurt and disappointment, I still want happiness for them.

If they're happier apart, I'll learn to accept it. But if there's still a part of them that chooses each other, I hope they find the courage to listen to their hearts before it's too late.

Some bonds may not last forever, but that doesn't mean they were never real. And before walking away from someone who once meant everything, perhaps we should ask ourselves one honest question: Have we truly understood what we're leaving behind?

I don't know how their story will end. I can only hope that whatever they choose comes from honest hearts, clear minds, and no regrets about the words left unsaid.

For now, I'll choose patience over anger and hope over regret. I'll wait. 🫂❤️‍🩹....

All the best englot.. @binkbinkB_ thank you my friend you have been the best part of this couple house.. thank you @Englothome always being the strongest of all...

[Cindy Waratin 🐰🐶 | 🇲🇽🦎 @Cindy_Waratin]

Engfa: No estoy diciendo que lo que hizo esa persona el día del fan meeting haya sido valiente o maduro. Solo me refería a la forma en que actuó después, porque creo que lo que hizo tuvo una gran consecuencia para ella. Puede ser porque ustedes y yo lo vemos desde ángulos diferentes. Si piensan que yo valoro o apruebo el error cometido el día del fan meeting, la respuesta es no. No tienen idea de lo que pasó a puerta cerrada. No saben que la regañé y que tomé medidas respecto al incidente, ya que yo también estaba preocupada por los sentimientos de mis fans ese día.
​Creo que después de que ella tomó medidas, el tema debió haber parado ahí. De hecho, ella pudo haberse quedado callada y no hacer nada. Pudo haber dicho que me etiquetó por accidente o que fue un error de dedo. Por eso me quedé atónita con su publicación (de disculpa). Jamás en mi vida me había topado con pretendientes que escribieran o dijeran cosas tan extensas como esa.
​Pienso que tal vez malinterpretaron lo que dije con las acciones específicas. Entendieron que yo aprobaba lo que pasó el día del fan meeting. Eso es incorrecto.
​Sabía que la publicación del día del fan meeting molestó a mis fans, así que ella tenía que dar la cara. Y lo hizo. Simplemente consideré que el hecho de que alguien pida disculpas por su error es un acto de valentía y madurez. No tengo idea de cómo la gente lo interpreta de forma diferente.

#EnglotEnEspañol #Englot
#อิงฟ้ามหาชน #EngfaWaraha

[alif/✿ ‎ @_alifyou7]

: พาร์ทคู่
อฟ : จริงๆรายละเอียดดีเทลเรื่องสัญญาเนี่ย มันไม่สามมารถจะพูดได้ว่าจะยุติลงเมื่อใด แต่มันได้มีการตกลงเกิดขึ้นแล้วว่ามันจะยุติเร็วๆนี้ ซึ่งเรื่องของงานมันมีตอนนี้เราไม่ได้มีการรับงานเพิ่ม มันมีแต่ต้องเคลียร์งานที่เหลืออยู่ พี่ก็จะทำให้เต็มที่ในพาร์ทนั้น ที่เราจะได้เจอกัน แต่สุดท���ายไม่ว่าในอนาคตข้างหน้าจะได้กลับมาเจอกัน หรือได้ทำงานกัน นอกเหนือจากบริบทอื่นๆไหม ความสัมพันธ์ของอิงล็อตมันก็ยังคงเป็นสิ่งนั้นเสมอ พี่ยังจำความที่เราเข้ากองกันวันแรกได้ พี่ยังจำความรู้สึกที่พี่มีต่อแฟนคลับคู่ได้ แต่ทุกสิ่งทุกอย่างมันเป็นไปตามกาลเวลา ที่ต้องมีจากและบริบทมันเปลี่ยน แค่ต้องยอมรับในพาร์ทการทำงาน ไม่ต้องกังวลว่าหลังเหตุการณ์จะเกิดขึ��นมันจะกระทบพาร์ตเนอร์ไหม เพราะว่าการตกลงคุยกันมัน ตกลงกันก่อนที่จะเกิดเหตุการณ์ขึ้นแล้ว เรื่องการตกลงเรื่องการรับงาน การคุยงานต่างๆ สำหรับพี่นะที่คุยกับกอง

/โอเคค่ะ พาร์ทเนอร์รู้รึยัง

[แอมเบอร์ @notmysundaybe]

Mind you these were under Charlotte mother TikTok comments by Engfa fans not even once Engfa reprimand her fans to stop bullying Charlotte not a single video, instead she join them with her family and friends to bully Charlotte since 2023