Here is a direct quote from a reply you posted 4 hours ago. "I don't stand on Guard for packies and Muslims fucker".
Man you have a lot of anger issues. Stay off the coke with Escobar. That tin foil hat is on way too tight. I'd trust you with money as much as Bill Cosby as a bartender.
I guess you didn't read his reply to a reply. Speak out all you want but if you make racist remarks, I will call you out. Yeah the numbers check out. StatsCan’s got the visible minority share heading for like 40% by the early 2040s and fertility’s at 1.25, so the old majority just keeps getting smaller. So what do we do?
Real median pay is higher than it was in the 70s and 80s, even if it feels slower and more uneven than the overall economy growing. Productivity has still been the main thing lifting living standards over time. Debt and immigration added to total growth, but they didn’t replace it.
Slowing both will probably cool the overall economy. Whether pay then starts rising faster depends on productivity actually picking up from tighter labor markets. It could take decades.
@KJJTax Your mom said the only reason she keeps letting you back is because you're gone in under four minutes. Efficiency isn't the flex you think it is.
Shrinking the population can make the numbers look better per person if you’re mostly cutting people who aren’t adding much. That’s the basic idea.
The catch is most of the shrinkage comes from people having fewer kids, which means more old people and fewer workers paying for everything. The unemployed people already here often can’t or won’t take the jobs immigrants do (hard physical work, different skills, wrong location).
Fewer immigrants overall might help on paper, but it can just leave more empty jobs and higher costs unless the people already here step into them. High-skill people who actually fill gaps are different from just adding numbers.
Shrinking economy + rising lower incomes isn’t sustainable. Total incomes = total production. A smaller pie means higher bottom incomes only via redistribution, debt, or asset drawdowns—finite. Job losses hit the bottom hardest, and growth (not transfers) has driven almost all historical poverty reduction.
I do understand what you are saying. A week in the States makes the flags, the directness, and the sense that people aren’t waiting for permission to speak stand out. Those differences are real.
But I thing it also turns a short trip into a story about Canadians being scared and overly dependent, and that doesn’t really hold up—especially with what’s been coming out of the White House.
Americans do fly more flags. Ownership rates are higher. The pride isn’t as independent of politics as it looks, though. Gallup’s numbers show Republicans still scoring sky-high on “extremely or very proud” while Democrats have dropped hard into the 30s. Canadians are usually less theatrical about it, and there have been stretches where the maple leaf got treated like a political statement. I don't think most people still aren’t checking the news before they put one up. My maple leaf has been flying for over 15 years and no one has ever said anything about it in a bad way.
The current administration has made the comparison messier. Trump has kept floating the 51st state idea, said economic force is how you’d get there, and kept calling Canadian leaders “Governor.” Tariffs have escalated, including 50% rates on big chunks of Canadian goods after talks broke down over demands Ottawa saw as sovereignty issues. Canada hit back. When the government next door is casually talking about absorbing you and using trade as leverage, the “we’re not like Americans” line stops being pure smugness.
The U.S. protects more offensive speech on paper. Canada has hate-speech rules that have stuck. In practice I think both countries have plenty of people who bite their tongues depending on the room and which side feels under fire.
Americans have generally scored higher on individualism and produced more startups. Canadians run a bigger safety net and, in recent multi-country surveys, rate their fellow citizens as decent and trustworthy at much higher rates. That’s a real difference in how people handle risk, not just timidity.
“We’re not like Americans” is often a lazy way to claim superiority, and you are right to call that out. At the same time, the data on trust and polarization doesn’t support the idea that the Canadian difference is nothing but fear and niceness. Both countries have people who take chances and hold opinions. They just weigh the trade-offs differently, and a short visit will always catch the freer-feeling parts while missing the more fractured ones.
America has a lot of great people. The present administration is another matter. Just look at the mid-term message that was sent this past week. The MAGA habit of calling the prime minister “Governor,” labeling Canadians nasty and ungrateful, and posting those AI memes of Trump standing over a beaten-looking Carney isn’t confidence. Not to mention all the lies from the administration that can easily be disproven, yet are soaked up by a large percentage of his followers as truth. There are plenty of Americans who hate our guts based on these lies. It’s just bullying with a flag on it, and it makes the Canadian reaction to keep some distance feel a lot more reasonable.