Yefet Cohen, Samaritan communal leader and the curator of the Samaritan museum speaking to Pavel Bernstein: "The Most High chose the name - Israel (Jacob). Israel doesn't [exclusively] belong to the Samaritans, nor to the Jews. There is no Samaritan religion, just as really, there is no Jewish religion. We are [both] the Nation of Israel."
To be clear, Jacob has absolutely no clue on what the consensus view of the Samaritan community is are on Ashkenazi Jewish indigeneity. He just posts a hearsay anecdote about what a Jewish person said 'all the Samaritans were saying' in 1967, and claims to speak for all of them.
The NYT in 2021 reported on about the nuances of Samaritan identity; a Samaritan they interviewed said he identified as a Palestinian and an Arab growing up, but came to strongly support Israel because he believes Israel preserves the existence of the Samaritan community. The NYT mentioned both Samaritan Likud voters and Samaritan members of the PLO. https://t.co/bFhT9ugeO9.
The general tenor of the article is that the Samaritans seem to have more cultural similarities with the Palestinians, but are treated well by Israel and many see support for the state as being in their interest. Regardless, it appears that the community straddles both sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict, and its views cannot be summed up in the reductive and frankly disrespectful manner Jacob attempts to. If one wanted to figure out what Samaritans think about these issues, one would have to carry out a detailed anthropological study, not just meme.
"Turks in Berlin were eyewitnesses to violence against German Jews that day, and some of them were targeted by the mob because they “looked Jewish.”
"Seeing a lot of dark-skinned people gathering, Germans mistook the Turks for Jews who were planning a counter action and raised an uproar, but the police intervened and resolved the issue."
See: Mistaken for Jews: Turkish PhD students in Nazi Germany by Marc David Baer
And as I understand, the fella you posted is a mixture of Turkish, Kurdish, Bosnian, Libyan, and maybe more distant Peninsular Arab
“Marek Edelman had a ‘typical Jewish appearance,’ so his being sent to the Aryan side was out of the question.”
— The Leadership of the Jewish Combat Organization during the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: A Reassessment, p. 55, note 56
@notistotny They were able to make ‘educated guesses’ primarily because of segregation and the actual physical identifier they used was checking for circumcision.
@AbdAshtart4@heatmappr these are from the public 2026 Moriopoulos sheet, for which I don't have individuals for, only averages. For individuals, I'd have to go to some other dataset.
@GoatIced@Quinctilus@History__Speaks I'm eager to learn that Jews might be the last holdout of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. We thought it was gone, but it lives on through Dror Horowitz in the vegan cafes of Tel Aviv
@Quinctilus@History__Speaks How should I understand "an (Eastern) European colonial settler endeavor" ?
Do you throw that in there because they were living in Eastern Europe at the time or is there something more meaningful to it?
Is Zionism an expansion of Polonia or the Lithuanian Grand Duchy?
@realjewishlarry@Agam_isdagoatt Which Sephardi diaspora is your family from? Are you Sephardi on both sides?
Not trying to dox you, just curious, since your opinions are even more atypical for a Sephardi
Hitler did hate both. In light of his policy for Czechs, the changing attitudes and views of Croats, the selection of Polish kids/infants by phenotype for Germanization, Slavs in SS units, existence of SS units that were mostly Slavic by membership, should we really place the 2 hatreds into the same category?
I'd separate identity from state support here. Italian Americans in the west are overwhelmingly South Italian and weren't treated well by the state that they left, nor is Italy in some constant precarious position, like Israel. Meanwhile, they'll still give Italian first names to their kids generations later.