@techczech I appreciate the kind words! You’re spot on when you say “responsible to whom?” One thing that set me on this path was seeing all the survey questions that used the word “others.” “To me, pleasure is spending time with others.” The “who” is important!
Haven't read the paper but the tweet storm about it makes perfect and aligns with the explanation I have adopted. Collectivism-individualism scale for measuring cultures does not make sense because (among others) people in collectivist cultures often find it difficult to collaborate with strangers. How people are expected to be responsible to whom is what makes the difference. Hope this get traction in the field @ThomasTalhelm.
@paul_hundred You nailed the summary! More concise than my version. 👏 And when you disambiguate, you can find social class (left graph) and political (right graph) differences that earlier measures mostly miss.
When they disambiguated between collectivism as feel-good altruistic sentiment and nuts-and-bolts responsibilities, this is the map they got for the latter
A new paper led @ThomasTalhelm@wei_liuqing separates two conflated ideas of collectivism: general prosociality and close-relationship responsibilities. Responsibilism Scale" focuses on behavioral duties to specific people. https://t.co/ICQILdHVHB
By "don't work," they meant they produced weird results, like people in China saying they value independence more than Americans. https://t.co/1RovHTzIWc
And this meta-analysis of 76 survey studies finding no differences in collectivism between East Asia and the West. Seems weird! 🧐 https://t.co/7jSMKjyCu4
These explanations have evidence behind them, but I think they miss the bigger problem. The problem was in our heads all along. What do people think collectivism is?
So here's the big idea: Remember those 76 studies that failed to find East-West differences in collectivism? If we understand collectivism as responsibilism (and NOT warm fuzzies), I bet we'll find those differences people were looking for! So I made a survey.