To be a real Human, one needs intelligence, courage, tenacity, curiosity, and a strong sense of justice. Remove any one of the five and you end up with the equivalent of a lemon. Remove the sense of justice and you end up with a monster.
Mohammad Abu al-Khair Shukri, Syria’s Endowment Minister, urged mosques to celebrate “conquests and victories” by Damascus-affiliated forces in eastern Syria, invoking the Quranic verse “Al-Anfal,” which many Kurds associate with the 1988 Anfal genocide under Saddam Hussein in Iraqi Kurdistan in which over 100,000 Kurds were killed.
Incredibly, the placebo effect is (mostly) not real.
It is a result of statistical confusion. Whenever you have a group with extreme values, they tend to exhibit regression to the mean. Eg. on average, sick people tend to become more healthy over time.
Thus if you give one group medicine, and one group placebo, the placebo group will also tend to get better over time, because of regression to the mean.
People have then misinterpreted this to think that it is the placebo pill that actively does this.
If you want to demonstrate a placebo effect, you have to construct a study where there are three groups:
• A. treatment
• B. placebo
• C. no treatment, no placebo
If B and C get different outcomes, that would demonstrate a placebo effect.
When this has been tried, mainly there has been no provable placebo effect. See the paper in the screenshot. (There is some evidence for an effect for pain, but this get's into a slightly different debate.)
The fact that the placebo effect is mainly not real, fortunately frees us from having to come up with convoluted explanations, as to why the placebo effect would work even when we tell the patient that it is a placebo, as in the quoted tweet.
My girlfriend @abigailandwords has written an important, beautiful, and heart-wrenching story about her experience with endometriosis. It is, among other things, a reminder of the fallibility of doctors and the value of trusting your gut. Give it a read.
https://t.co/WgXTp0yTGC
"This emphasis on the unconscious driving our behavior and influencing our judgements, decisions, and choices has been vastly over-emphasized."
https://t.co/THhtUsrkQV
"We suspect that some readers will find this claim -- that Fodorian modularity exists at the intentional level of analysis -- tendentious, but they should not... consistent throughout his work... Fodor collapsed intentional and functional levels together" https://t.co/eUpWzT2mgA