A man deposits $10,000 in a bank.
The bank thanks him and records the deposit on its balance sheet. But not where you might expect. For the bank, that $10,000 is actually a liability – because technically it belongs to the customer and might have to be returned.
So the bank does what banks do. It lends $9,000 of that money to someone buying a car.
Now something interesting happens. The $9,000 loan appears on the bank’s books as an asset – because someone now owes the bank money.
So the same $10,000 is doing two jobs at once. The depositor believes he has $10,000 safely in the bank. The borrower now has $9,000 to spend.
That $9,000 gets deposited somewhere else. The next bank lends $8,100. That gets deposited again. Then $7,290 gets lent out.
Soon the original $10,000 has quietly turned into tens of thousands of dollars of loans scattered across the economy.
Everyone believes they have money. Depositors see balances in their accounts. Borrowers have the money they spent. Banks show healthy assets on their balance sheets because people owe them money.
And here’s the best part.
Banks charge interest on all those loans – maybe 7%. But the depositor who supplied the original money might earn only 0.5% on their savings account.
So banks collect interest on money that mostly wasn’t theirs to begin with – and keep the difference.
The system works beautifully.
As long as nobody asks for the money back at the same time.
- @scottmelker
@Devon_Eriksen_ You don’t fix bad choices by taking away the vote. A republic is designed to absorb them. We need ideas that strengthen the American experiment, not weaken it.
The more people distance themselves from the true cost of healthcare, the more expensive it will become.
If AI can destroy the current system, everyone will be better off.
Medicare Will Start Paying AI Companies a Share of Any Claims They Automatically Reject | Frank Landymore, Futurism
AI companies are becoming a "whole new bounty hunter."
It's long been the practice of private health insurers to require "prior authorization" before you can get the treatment you need. Often, they'll try to deny as many of these claims as possible — including with the use of AI models.
Government-backed plans like Medicare, however, have tended to cover what private insurers don't, and without the laborious application process.
But that could be poised to change. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services said it'll experiment with its own version of prior authorization by using AI models to screen claims, as part of its new belt-tightening program called the Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction model, or WISeR.
And get this: as the New York Times reports, the AI companies selected for this experiment will get paid a share of the money they saved by blocking people from their healthcare. Those savings could look like billions of dollars over the next six years — and that's if the program doesn't get expanded.
This basically deputizes the AI companies as a "whole new bounty hunter," David A. Lipschutz, the co-director for the Center for Medicare Advocacy, told the NYT. In other words, they're clearly incentivized to deny claims above all else.
For now, the program, which begins in January, will be limited to six states: New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, Arizona, and Washington. Officials assert that the AI tools will only be used to judge claims for about a dozen different types of procedures it deems to be wasteful and providing little benefit, including steroid shots to relieve pain, per the NYT. Moreover, the models won't be used to review emergency services and hospital stays, the director of the Center for Medicare and Medication innovation Abe Sutton said.
Experts aren't convinced that it'll stay that way for long. "You're kind of left to wonder, well, where does this lead next?" Vinay Rathi, an Ohio surgeon and an expert in Medicare payment policy told the NYT. "You could be running into a slippery slope."
Officials also assure that the final decision on denials — or in the industry parlance, "non-affirmations" — would be done by an "appropriately licensed human clinician, not a machine," and Sutton said that there'll be penalties for wrongful rejections.
The conduct of private insurers, however, suggests that keeping humans in the loop isn't a safeguard against rampant abuse. A 2023 ProPublica investigation found that Cigna used an algorithm to automatically examine and deny claims, which were then approved by human doctors who didn't even look at the patient records. United Healthcare allegedly used an AI algorithm called "nH predict" to reject claims, too, even though it allegedly had an error rate of over 90 percent.
Even disbarring any possible nefarious intentions, is there evidence that the AI models will be any good at being objective arbiters of who gets to see a doctor and who doesn't? As the NYT explains, these systems typically look at a patient's history to see if they meet an insurer's criteria, such as having tried physical therapy first before getting back surgery.
But recent research has shown how AI systems can erroneously tell patients not to seek medical care because of something as insignificant and random as a single typo in a document. The work even found that the models exhibited an alarming gender bias, telling women not to see a doctor more often than with men.
Don't worry, though. We'll sure all this will get ironed out as the AI models are prematurely empowered to decide whether you get healthcare or not, while their owners get paid based on how many people they reject.
https://t.co/UQCISzZ8U3
@RBReich That sounds like a great idea, if you can opt in for it. Work extra hours for the first part of the month and then take some time off at the end of the month.
Labor laws are so strict now that is not even an option even if the employee and the employer agree to it.
@ScottAdamsSays There is a documented example of a prankster...
Prankster: "Eat this fruit and your eyes will be opened"
later...
Lead Developer: "Who told you that you were naked?"
@OwenGregorian@ScottAdamsSays I expect no less from an all-powerful government. The fact that they rule by proxy is evidence that they know it is wrong.
@DavidSacks If they can solve this problem, all other problems will solve themselves.
Why do so many people carry the "collectivism" message and so few carry this message?
@JoeBiden COVID19 was the largest contributing factor to Trump's election loss. How exactly are you taking credit for the win and how do you plan to win again?
@DrDeepMD The food pyramid has to be the most effective, government funded propaganda ever pushed on the American public.
Current research shows the pyramid is likely the biggest culprits in the obesity and diabetes epidemic.