There's quite a difference between having a "libertarian streak" and being a libertarian. A liberal does, in fact, view corporate coercive and monopoly power as something that has to be regulated and counter-balanced. Since Musk doesn't have the right to use violence, his primary power is monopoly power, that which keeps people from being able to walk away. It's important that he not be able to say "you'll never work in this town again" and make that true. It's important that NASA or the US government have other viable alternatives than SpaceX as a supplier - that's a real problem at the moment. And I think it's very important to separate the cases where Musk's behavior is problematic from those where our dependence on him is. I'd love to see more viable competition in every industry he's in.
That position resonates with me, emotionally. Why should some people have excesses others are denied if they're result of human choice rather than a dictate of nature? But I'm at heart a systems thinker, and I'm quite conflicted about authority - I've seen too many cruel, manipulative, zealous, or confused people in power - most systems thinkers exposed to real social systems end up with at least somewhat of a libertarian streak. Once the AIs take over and we have the abundance the tech bros dream of, maybe a socialistic (not communistic) system could actually work. But with 20th century or early 21st century technology - there are just so many systemic reasons that I see authority winding up being either oppressive or inhibitive of progress and prosperity, longer-term. I've looked at this many times, from many angles, and I keep coming to the same conclusion. Once I eliminate what appears to be impossible and incorporate my life experience - the American liberal bargain seems better than most other alternatives, and it's one I at least feel I understand.
Before you misunderstand me, when I talk about intelligent or hard-working people, I'm mostly talking about *people we have invested in over long periods of time*. Good education systems, strong social nets, etc. - the kinds of things even Joseph Stiglitz would agree with.
But we do have a values disagreement here. I don't fundamentally view inequality as immoral if it's raising up the low. That would be Rawls' position, and he was more worried about inequality than I am. Inequality has social costs and those costs have to be deterred. But I'm always fine with someone else having something that I don't, even happiness, if it's more likely to add to my life than take from it. I think knocking down all the tall poppies is dangerous - if we indulge in it, we will all loose out. I'm aware that's an almost uniquely American position today, but I do find it to be the more moral one.
I (and others in my family) have number of allergies an food sensitivities. But I'd rather see you be able to enjoy that dessert that I can't rather than have you be helf back because I wasn't given your gift. I think that's the right moral position.
As far as curtailing Musk, someone will. It just won't be Trump and his GOP.
I do view something like DOGE as necessary. The mechanism was oligarchic, but real technical and methodological problems were fixed, and needed fixing. Such shakeups are periodically necessary - just Musk's axe-swinging and violation of clearance were way over the line.
"I'm not at all sympathetic to an argument comparing the US government to a large company." There's a lot to unpack here, and keep in mind I agree with you on the difference in function. But the "it serves everyone rather than to make money" is a little sloppy. What *is* most important here is the difference in risk profiles. If a business takes a risk, it costs a few jobs and maybe an organization. If the government knocks down a load-bearing wall, people can starve, go into bankruptcy, be denied helathcare, or die. You can't always just demolish government functions and not expect catastrophic consequences. The impacts of corporate failures are more limited.
Europe is more egalitarian and procedure-oriented, and I respect that. But it's also more bureacratic, and it pays dearly for that. It's much harder to fire in Europe - and much harder to hire, which is why the ratio of development and innovation to education and its pool of highly intelligent people is surprisingly low. It's not the worst place to live by far, but I'll take America in my circumstances.
I understand your position regarding USAID, and I'm not saying they didn't do important and needed things. But they also supported highly partisan things. And paid for it. I feel like being against that would like being against the falling rain - it's just natural consequence. I don't want people to lose jobs, but I also view jobs as somewhat volatile. I've known dozens and dozens of people who have lost their jobs, though no fault of their own. And then got new ones. That's just how it works. If your friend ended up in long-term underemplyment, though, they have my deep sympathy.
Justice is... aspirational more than guaranteed, in the sense we'd often like to see it. But still... pride goeth before the fall - quite, quite often. Musk is no less vulnerable, ultimately, than Jensen.
The US military owns Starshield. Musk can advise but they get the final say. Outside of the Trump administration and a GOP Congress, Musk's power there *will* be curtailed - as it should be.
DOGE is... unfortunate, of course. Something had to happen, but axes being dropped so haphazardly were not the right way. I'm probably less sympathetic to that argument than some, though, because in large companies in the tech industry, that's how everything has been done all my working life. Big negatives, sometimes big positives - often jobs affected. Volatility is the price, but it does have benefits - Europe is the counter-example.
PEPFAR is what concerns me most about what happened in DOGE because it affects lives, not just jobs. USAID broadly... less so - deeply partisan organizations die partisan deaths. It's the kind of karma that Musk will soon be facing, honestly, when Trump falls from power. He's made a lot of powerful enemies, and they don't follow rules much better than he does, whatever they say.
Journalistic obstruction and violation of regulations? Yes, where the law is broken legal consequences should follow.
A bigger threat and a bigger asset both. You seem to be seeing only one side of the equation. Keep in mind that SpaceX would not die without Musk, but it likely would stagnate. At any point you "pull" him, you don't lose what exists, just what might be built. Like Terafab, which has enormous potential implications for American competitiveness and reindustrialization.
And as far as red lines being crossed, are you referring to Starlink/Starshield? Because the more I learn about that, the muddier it sounds. So far, I can see grounds for not liking the guy, but I don't see a smoking gun for "you got involved in policy and politcs so you must leave public life." Frankly, I'd be afraid our country wouldn't be that free if anything I'm currently aware of would be seen as justification for that.
@SteveKerins I think there's some common ground. I *do* think powerful men ought to be held to account. For example, Jensen couldn't stay at Nvidia. I just think we ought to tread carefully while applying the practice.
I understand. And everyone can be replaced, more or less. But I've spent enough time in large organizations to understand the cost of that, and exactly how much value leadership provides, how rare effective leadership is, and how strange it often looks. I'll stand by my statement.
@TheRocsWorld@JoseonOne A lot of people are looking out for #1 first and principles are justifications. You see this with every topic, from free speech to all the rest. But I donβt need their noise.
@TheRocsWorld People often conflate the two, even when they don't realize they're doing it - on the sending and receiving end. That's why I'm wary of the framing: aim at what you want in the future, not what we have to overcome from the past, and we'll be more likely to achive it.
@CartoonsHateHer I meanβ¦ a little? We all want a million contradictory things, if weβre introspective enough to notice. But wanting to be seen as useful is a much more dominant force.
@StevenMathern@AdamHoltererer I'm not using Hermes, but Gemini Sub isn't supposedly available in API (At sufficient rates). For my projects, I just send out subagents in cli (muse-code, grok, codex, agy - whatever subscription I'm playing with this month).
@S___Elliott Yes. Of course, weβll have better ability to deter and fix if we have sufficient and more powerful AI than adversaries - plus more focus on defense in depth in our network infrastructure. Itβs a hard race to get out of.