@KVanValkenburg I wonder if foot size is a factor people aren’t considering.
Even when looking at athletes around same height between sports, soccer players generally have much smaller feet vs NBA/ NFL. Even if you’re a great athlete you’re likely to be clunky on the ball in size 13+
A critical element that the "rulebook purists" arguing Balogun deserved a red card are conveniently overlooking:
BALOGUN was the one who was challenged from behind.
The Bosnian player played *through* Balogun from behind and placed himself in the path of Balogun's natural step.
When he begins taking that step, Balogun has no idea the Bosnian player would even be in front of him. In that sense, you can't really even consider his move a "challenge." It was simply a step that incidentally landed in the same place the opponent's foot did.
In fact, the reason Balogun's step came down so hard is *because* the Bosnian player challenged into him and knocked him off balance.
This is not "reckless" or "excessive force" by any stretch of the imagination.
The red card was *obviously* unjustified from the outset. The only thing FIFA got wrong here is not immediately suspending the red card after the match.
Been arguing with soccer fans about Baloguns red card.
Their logic would dictate that the first baseman should be ejected and suspended since Julio got hurt on the play. See how ridiculous not including intentionality in the rule is dumb?
@VGremese97724@RefereeC21621 It’s a contact sport. Accidents happen all the time in other sports and you can and should differentiate between accidents and malicious plays. I get that’s not how it works currently. I’m arguing that it should.
@VGremese97724@RefereeC21621 I’m saying the application that all reds are the same within the current rules is wrong and can/ should be improved to differentiate between these types of plays
@lemonmoth10@RefereeC21621 No I’m saying there’s a difference between driving recklessly and intentionally driving into someone and the laws should be able to differentiate between the two same with fouls
@VGremese97724@RefereeC21621 I’d argue that positioning for the ball is different than a high kick but I’d also argue that intentionally kicking at someone’s head is different than incidental contact or a high kick. Should be room to interpret that all differently. Thoughrs ?