Whoever wants music instead of noise, joy instead of pleasure, soul instead of gold, creative work instead of business, passion instead of foolery, finds no home in this trivial world of ours.
— Hermann Hesse
Of course, I see chess parallels here! One, chess programs on ever-faster hardware proved that brute force was enough to beat the world’s best humans. That is, unlike the beliefs of the early days of computer chess going back to Alan Turing, they didn’t have to think "like a human" at all in order to play much better than a human. Two, chess tablebases solve chess for a limited number of pieces (7-8), making them useful for endgames and esoteric studies. Some of the solutions to forced checkmate are hundreds of moves long, most of the moves being incomprehensible to humans.
“For most of history, people assumed reality was built on something deeper than matter. Then science came along and the universe started looking like a machine. But now some ... researchers are starting to question that”
https://t.co/U5b6VZxkMC
@melinda_esen The concept of intuition is not very intuitive 😅. It is one of those words whose original meaning has been lost or distorted over time. As I understand it, intuition is direct knowledge, that is, gnosis, or non-conceptual knowledge:
https://t.co/jU5vKGgQeo
I’ve worked on the Riemann Hypothesis. When the news broke that an Anthropic researcher "solved" it, I called hype. After reading the actual Lean Zulip chat, my intuition was spot on.
Here is what actually happened:
It’s a Logic Verifier, Not a Proof. The AI generated a 61GB, obfuscated code dump. As mathematician Joël Riou noted, it's "messy" and ignores standard Mathlib spelling. It's not a readable mathematical proof; it's a machine-verified logic tree.
Lean Deserves the Credit, Not AI. As Max Nowak said in the chat: "This is not thanks to AI, this is thanks to interactive theorem provers like Lean existing." The AI brute-forced a codebase, and human-made Lean kernels checked it in 7 hours.
It's Market Hype. Formal proof expert Assia Mahboubi literally called for a quarantine on such announcements, saying: "what we are contributing to is not science but market and finance."
Earlier, I tested an AI on this. It built a fake React slider app and declared "99.9% Mathematical Singularity." This time, it built a 175,000-file Lean dump. The scale is different, but the hype is the same.
Until a human can read it, understand it, and explain it, it’s a logic verifier outputting "True"—not a mathematical breakthrough.
note my test was back in 2025 not this year
#RiemannHypothesis #LeanProver #AIHype #Mathematics
Every scientific experiment needs an observer, and every measurement depends on one, yet the observer itself remains out of reach.
Andrew T. Jaffe compares this to a scientist inside a dream: they might map out the physical laws of their dream world, but the scientific method alone could never reveal that they are dreaming.
This isn’t a blind spot that future science will eventually solve, because the observer isn't just another physical object in the universe.
Consciousness is fundamental: it comes before the world that science attempts to describe.
Tap the link to read more: https://t.co/i02cOENGi7
@HametaBenengela La ética de Spinoza es realmente metafísica. El nombre de La ética, fue más una sutil estrategía para expresar ideas que para su época eran muy controversiales y riesgosas.
@salmasdassan One cannot return to a place either: "No man steps into the same river twice, because it is not the same river, and he is not the same man." (Heraclitus).