Good morning. This is urgent, for public information.
The second paper on cow research funded using India's public money under the SUTRA-PIC (Scientific Utilization through Research Augmentation - Prime Products from Indigenous Cows program) has undergone exhaustive post-publication peer review.
The paper was published in Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology last year. The authors are from Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) BHU-Varanasi and Birla Institute of Technology (BITS)-Pilani.
This is the paper: https://t.co/InN4H9safh
This study was done in Uttar Pradesh and the total amount of public money given was INR 31,04,162. The authors studied cow urine of different breeds and found "special" components in the cow urine that they claim will have major use applications in healthcare, technology and engineering.
They are wrong. The paper is a third-rate publication with poorly performed and grossly misinterpreted and falsified results of basic analytical chemistry. An official email for Expression of Concern and investigation into scientific integrity has been mailed to: @SpringerNature Ethics Team and Journal Editors-in-Chief (personal email) - Matthew P. DeLisa PhD
at Cornell University, Ye Ni PhD at Jiangnan University and Benedict Okeke PhD at Auburn University.
Here is the lay summary of the paper's forensic analysis:
Lab contamination has been (un)intentionally ignored by authors. The researchers mistook common lab contaminants, like plastic chemicals and solvents, for natural cow urine compounds. They failed to run basic control tests to catch these obvious errors.
Impossible chemicals claimed to be found in cow urine by authors. The paper claims to have found impossible synthetic chemicals in the urine, such as a banned pesticide, human prescription drugs, and toxic metals. This shows the authors blindly trusted computer software without checking if the results even made biological sense.
Fake health claims made by the authors. The authors boast about the amazing health benefits of over twenty different chemicals, claiming they fight cancer and bacteria. However, none of these specific chemicals were actually found anywhere in their own data or in the urine of various cows they tested.
Contradictory results are all over the place. The written text of the paper directly contradicts its own data tables. The researchers claim to have found certain groups of chemicals, like steroids, that are completely missing from their actual results.
Terrible referencing throughout the paper. The study's citations are completely mismatched, scrambled, and duplicated. They even cite unrelated plant studies and reviews on toxic chemicals to support their claims about the "benefits" of cow urine.
Zero statistics and flawed setup degrade the conclusions. The study lacks basic statistical analysis, sometimes testing as few as one cow per breed. They also failed to separate the cow's breed from its age, diet, or location, making their "breed-specific" conclusions totally invalid.
Misleading graphs are plastered all over. The graphs that are supposed to show specific, individual chemicals actually show messy mixtures of dozens of different compounds. These graphs look suspiciously identical to each other, raising serious concerns about image manipulation.
Thanks to the Government for destroying the scientific fabric and the rational temperament of its science instituitions. We wont forget.
Journalists from India to Brazil say they were hit with fake legal threats and spoofed Google notices — all for reporting on Ambani’s Vantara zoo. Read full story by @AzeefaFathima
https://t.co/DntgnLjfUo
The Election Commission of India (ECI) replaced text-based PDF voter lists with scanned images to obstruct data extraction and analysis, a move that cripples the ability to use tools like Ctrl+F or AI algorithms for error detection. Read to know why 🧵
ANI EXPOSED 🚨
Popular Youtuber Mohak Mangal has exposed Smita Prakash’s ANI’s running extortion business
First ANI sends copyright strikes on YouTube videos, which are usually safe under Fair Use policy
Later ANI forces YouTubers to pay ₹20-50 lakhs to restore their channels, in the name of ‘subscription’
Shame on Smita Prakash, is BJP’s dirty money not enough?
The best PM of India after Nehru is #ManmohanSingh
👉8.2% GDP Growth
👉 Lifted 25 crores people from Poverty.
👉FDI growth from $2.5b to $25b
👉 Exports growth of 18%
👉RTI, RTE, Aadhaar, UPI, Rupay Card, Broadband and Internet Revolution
👉Nuclear Power.
Do not watch this Video. There is a reason why Jio Cinema is not showing this episode. How can any outsider make fun of our Honourable PM and Unbiased Media. Sharing only for awareness purpose so that u know what u shouldn’t watch. Don’t retweet it unless for awareness purpose
This generation might only know a fragile and fumbling Vijayakanth. But the real face Vijayakanth is much bigger and taller than many of us could imagine. #Vijayakanth#RIPCaptain#CaptainVijayakanth