It’s now over four years since Ed Slater was diagnosed with MND. Went round for a coffee and to watch him at work as a video analyst for Worcester Warriors, a role that’s given him invaluable purpose. Some man.
https://t.co/WQXcNGl2gM
Went through France’s 223 tackle attempts against the Springboks. Only 12 resembled knee-drops. Only five (IMO) in danger of being penalised. And none clear and obvious enough for a TMO to come in.
https://t.co/9Re2i5YBzq
@FredrickCochra2 first one can be incompetence I think - someone has suggested was Wiese’s 20-minute red was also cut short (would have to check). Second, I was surprised the “team offence” scrum pen didn’t bring a yellow with France on last warning, definitely. Would like to hear explanation
@TheOtherGuySays@NPR1976 I’m not trying to be. I think if, say, Florian Verhaeghe’s on Wiese at the end of the first half was penalised then it might have changed behaviour a little – agree there. But that was one of five *potentially* illegal tackle attempts out of 223, to me.
@Johan1802@Hilgardneethlin You’d naturally scrutinise try-scoring phases more carefully and it looked like he was clearly closer than ten metres pre-throw. But I said at the time it was unfortunate for SA and that remains true
@TheOtherGuySays Yep, no doubt. But I also think they were in the grey of it enough to get away with what they did. Personally (and maybe you won’t agree, and that’s cool) I think De Jager’s against Italy was more clear and obvious than any of what France did.
Recurring theme was that the margin for error for taller forwards defending close to the ruck, when carriers are also stooping and they want to go low enough to avoid the head, is minuscule.
Went through France’s 223 tackle attempts against the Springboks. Only 12 resembled knee-drops. Only five (IMO) in danger of being penalised. And none clear and obvious enough for a TMO to come in.
https://t.co/9Re2i5YBzq
Went through France’s 223 tackle attempts against the Springboks. Only 12 resembled knee-drops. Only five (IMO) in danger of being penalised. And none clear and obvious enough for a TMO to come in.
https://t.co/9Re2i5YBzq
@moi_pseudo PM, appreciate you calling me not too blind ❤️. As I hope you suspect, I’m not trying to bait anyone. First clip in vid you’ve posted is a textbook example of simultaneous floor contact/tackle. Others are *potential* pens (and highlighted in my article). TMO needs clear though
@grapgatza Seeing as you’ve been in my mentions for two days being abusive (and real weird), that’s one of the five that could have been penalised. Screenshots not as useful as dynamic clips, though. And in that case, SA came back anyway. Impact on game negligible.