HOLDING STATEMENT OF OUR PRESIDENT ISAAC SSEMAKADDE, SC (@IsaacSsemakadde): Producing Sam Mugumya Does Not Absolve Government Lawbreaking. Accountability Begins Now
Kampala, Uganda - 18 November 2026: Sam Mugumya’s production this morning before the General Court Martial, after 449 days of enforced disappearance, does not erase what preceded it. From 26 August 2025, when armed men seized him at NIM Hotel in Mbarara, until today, the State repeatedly denied custody in sworn affidavits. Those denials were false.
The act of producing him now, without prior notice to family or counsel, and charging him with treachery and security offences under the UPDF Act, does not legitimise the abduction, the incommunicado detention, or the conditions that left him frail and needing physical support to walk. Production before a court does not wash away the crime. The government remains the holder of a hostage. There is nothing normal or lawful about that situation.
This moment is a triumph of whistleblowers. The testimony and material released by Lt. Herbert Matanda Mabonga, the persistence of Kakwenza Rukirabashaija (@KakwenzaRukira), Director of the Institute for Justice and Accountability in Uganda (iJA), and the disclosures amplified by Agora broke the wall of official denial. Their actions, at personal cost, forced the production that the courts and the public had demanded for months.
Our partnership with these voices proves we were right to abandon neutrality. Silence is complicity. Those who knew and said nothing should be ashamed. A few chose to speak, and they broke the silence. The Bar will keep amplifying those who speak out, and we will use every lawful avenue, in Uganda and abroad, to turn evidence into accountability.
Boycott Rukungiri CJ Thanksgiving
Executive Order RNB No. 14 of 2026 is still in full force. The Uganda Law Society continues to denounce and call for a total boycott of Chief Justice Dr. Flavian Zeija’s umpteenth Thanksgiving Ceremony on Saturday, 21 November 2026, at Karama Primary School Playground, Rukungiri.
This is not a private family event. It is a public show to make his office look legitimate, even though the Bar has called it a Global Judicial Pariah. And it is happening in the home district of Dr. Kizza Besigye, Sam Mugumya, and other opposition figures whose freedom the courts have so far failed to protect. Lawyers, law firms, and our allies are directed to stay away, decline invitations in writing, and withhold any sponsorship or support.
Government as Lawbreaker
US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis famously warned against government law-breaking: “Decency, security and liberty alike demand that government officials shall be subjected to the same rules of conduct that are commands to the citizen. In a government of laws, existence of the government will be imperiled if it fails to observe the law scrupulously. Our Government is the potent, the omnipresent teacher. For good or for ill, it teaches the whole people by its example. Crime is contagious. If the Government becomes a lawbreaker, it breeds contempt for law; it invites every man to become a law unto himself; it invites anarchy.”
The false testimony in court affidavits, the public boasts of custody and threats of execution by the Chief of Defence Forces, and the subsequent attempt to regularise secret detention through a military tribunal are textbook examples. The State has taught that its own rules do not bind it. That lesson breeds contempt for every court, every affidavit, and every claim of due process.
The harm is plain and personal. A man taken from breakfast disappeared for more than a year. His family lived with silence and fear. Videos showed him weakened and struggling to walk. This morning he appeared before a military court without his lawyers present. Families of other disappeared persons watch the same pattern and understand that any citizen can be taken, held in secret, and later “produced” as if the preceding months never happened. This is not abstract. It is the daily fear that a knock at the door or a meal in a hotel can end in months or years of unknown custody. It is the erosion of the most basic expectation that the State will either charge a person openly or leave them alone.
Way forward
The Uganda Law Society will convene joint stakeholder engagements to probe concrete accountability pathways. These must stress command responsibility. Senior officers and political figures who directed, authorised, or publicly endorsed the taking and holding of citizens outside the law must be identified and held to account. This includes Gen. Muhoozi Kainerugaba (@mkainerugaba), whose public statements claimed custody and threatened execution while formal denials were filed in court; Andrew Mwenda (@AndrewMwenda), whose recent commentary we have impugned as encouraging or abetting unlawful measures; and the Patriotic League of Uganda (@PLUsecretariat) structures associated with these patterns. Accountability is not limited to junior operatives. It reaches those who set the tone and issued the orders.
The State must now facilitate immediate independent medical examination and treatment for Mugumya consistent with his condition, grant private access to his family and lawyers, and open a transparent joint process with counsel to address the 449 days of secret detention. Anything less confirms that the production was theatre, not justice.
RESIST LAWLESSNESS. FREE ALL POLITICAL PRISONERS.
Isaac K. Ssemakadde SC
ULS President & Head of the Bar
#ULSAT70 #RNBVision2060
#BangTheTable #BackOnTrack
@SamMugumya@MODVA_UPDF@DailyMonitor@newvisionwire@DailyExpressUg@TheLegalReports@observerug@nilepostnews@ntvuganda
@OldMutualUganda it’s over two weeks since I emailed you to add a next of kin and update my bank account information. The silence from your end is so loud. There’s need for an adult in that office.