@AncientWolfAWI@yungnickyoung I’m not immune to nuance, but you’re probably right that we wouldn’t have a productive conversation given that you are so far in the other direction that you use AI art, which even Yung has rejected.
I… don’t even know what to think anymore. I don’t know how you could charitably look at this as a reasonable take. To genuinely say that the costs of AI on local communities is justifiable is baffling, appalling even.
Environmental impacts on local communities due to data centers are a real issue in some areas, and AI certainly exacerbates them by greatly increasing demand for compute. However, we can distinguish the unavoidable resource costs of compute vs. the potentially avoidable harms to local communities caused by poor infrastructure and insufficient regulation.
I believe AI's benefits can justify its resource consumption, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't work to minimize its environmental impacts. We can advocate for addressing these issues without needing to entirely disavow AI as a technology.
This gets pretty complicated, since you can dive into water, electricity, land, and then national vs local regulatory bodies. Not gonna get into it here but I plan to make some more elaborate posts diving into it in the future
@zhntm@yungnickyoung I’m happy to chat solutions, there are alot of legislative options. The rate payer protection act is a start, tho it needs to go further in mandating limits as opposed to suggesting them. Team Human has some good ideas as well. Solutions need to be implemented before we accept AI
@zhntm@yungnickyoung Yung and I are Minecraft mod developers, that’s the context for the thread and the reason for the comment.
Cities arent entirely to blame, but are enablers. Comparable example would be employers mandating AI to cut costs. They jump on the solution, not worrying about the impact
@zhntm@yungnickyoung Cars didn’t become necessary until cities reshaped everything to make them necessary. AI is not necessary right now, especially in creative industries. It is not worth the cost of using them to make art
@yungnickyoung You support making AI more efficient, but also support using it in its current state. You say it’s not acceptable but are using your platform to support its use before those infrastructure changes are made. Is it justifiable in its current state or not?
@TrueSaltSouls@DarkhaxDev@yungnickyoung Basic questions can be answered by looking through documentation or forums. And you kinda are calling to replace modding communities with AI? ‘Humans are slow & flawed, AI is quick & reliable’. It sounds like talking to the community is a compromise to you. That’s so sad to me.
@TrueSaltSouls@DarkhaxDev@yungnickyoung This is what we foster community for. I’ve never encountered a problem that I couldn’t get answered by a fellow mod developer in the community, and share what I know when I can. AI can’t replace that
Zen is getting DRM support! Very soon you'll be able to watch and listen to your favourite streaming services like Netflix or Spotify directly in Zen!
We know this has been your most anticipated feature, and we're thrilled to finally deliver on it!
@delphi7393@TerrariumEarth@Krtzyy “Code” is technical. AI made code is code. Just as an AI written essay is still an essay. But that essay isn’t art if it’s not written from the heart as a creative expression of humans, and that’s how I see AI code. The whole project is just less “art” than it would have been
@delphi7393@TerrariumEarth@Krtzyy Lmao. Yeah I think that’s a very different conversation. I’m sure Yung won’t let his mod slip into slop, but it doesn’t take away the fact that the accomplishment is just less special when you cede dev to AI, just as it is when you cede art to AI. Cuz Dev is Art. I rest my case
@delphi7393@TerrariumEarth@Krtzyy I laid out an example that I worked on recently in the thread. I’d love to talk more about this, but there isn’t a ton I can say if you don’t explain why you feel the way you feel. It isn’t just technical, I feel strongly that it can be just as artistic as art done correctly
@delphi7393@TerrariumEarth@Krtzyy All of that is code, and in my opinion, all of it is art. I wouldn’t want an AI involved in the process of making that anymore than I’d want it involved in the process of making any asset for my mod
@delphi7393@TerrariumEarth@Krtzyy The animations are also all math. It uses the door’s lifetime to determine how large the quads should be and where they should be placed. It uses that same function to determine when it should shake, which literally just offsets its position randomly during rendering every tick