So you've either intentionally or unintentionally misunderstood a large chunk of what I said. When did I ever say "humans are slow and flawed and that AI is quick and reliable?"
I did say that the expectation you set on the community is not fair, as you seem to expect it to be there for you every single time you have an issue. You and everyone else. Modders are people as well and are busy and can't always be there to answer questions.
Your point on docs is just wrong. I have looked through the docs for both forge and neo, and believe you me, they are not good. They are even sometimes actively unhelpful. The only way I figured out how to do datagen was by finding another mod that did it and looking at their code.
The docs often over complicate or are even at times provide actively no helpful information. This was my first major point you seemed to just ignore.
As for forums. Again, why would I want to spend hours digging through old forums for a chance that maybe somebody had a similar problem and someone, maybe, answered it? Asking on sites like Stack overflow used to be good but is now an actual hellscape if you have a question.
Now for the AI. While yes it is fast, it is not always reliable. Hence why I said to abuse it with basic questions. Get too complicated or granular and it will start to struggle or outright lie. So no it isn't perfect.
AI is explicitly good at pattern recognition and finding the average solution. Which is why it is so good for basic, general questions and begins to struggle when you need more indepth help with things. It doesn't replace the need for knowledge and the ability to understand it. It is basically a much better search aggregation utility.
This choosing to ignore entire things I've said or interpret my words in the most uncharitable way is exactly the problem I mentioned with communities. I hold a slightly different philosophy for modding than you; but instead of looking at and acknowledging the potential benefits, you choose to paint me as some kind of villain.
That would be like a teacher calling a students lazy and their work incorrect and uniformed; because they got their information by search thing up online instead of exclusively from books in a library. It is the same kind of mentality that attempts to ban video games, just with a new coat of paint.
Now you're free to continue disagreeing with me. I'm not here to have some long winded debate about the efficacy of AI and the morals surrounding it. My goal was never to convince you to use it, rather just explain my stance and why I use it for what I do.
Like I said before, I have things to do; much better things to do than to continue arguing this point. I wish you and your modding endeavors the best and hope the community continues to support you in the future. Have a good one.
I'm not calling for replacing the modding community, but I can't be left waiting for several days if not over a week for an answer on a problem I'm having. I, like everyone else, have things to do. On top of that, no one in the community is obligated to respond to you or me at all, which I feel is also entirely fair.
What this ultimately creates is a scenario where many people looking to get into mod creation, are often left behind because the community just can't support them. It just isn't realistic for it to be able to do so.
Let's also not forget, that despite claims of how great communities are, they can also be some of the most hostile places for new people. I understand wanting to protect the community from people coming in and trying to ruin it, but often times it is done to a fault.
You have no idea how many times I, myself, have been shunned due to not knowing or understanding certain principles of modding or the language when I was first getting into modding. How many times I had asked questions and gotten no answer, or snide, mocking responses, even to this day.
If you are able to get answers and people are always helpful to you, then that's great. Just know that isn't everyone's experience and it is one of the reasons I, and many others, can't rely on the community for help all the time.
Now that being said I will say the community has helped me and I do greatly appreciate the help and those that did. But I also think you have to acknowledge that people will be people and expecting answers and smiling faces from everyone, all the time, is unrealistic.
People can't always be there to help and often times get fed up answering the same question over and over again. The machine never will. Abuse the machine for basic information and help and leave the more involved and interesting questions for the community.
I largely agree with this. I have used it before to do a small code only mod, and upon completion, felt no sense of pride or accomplishment for the mod.
I have since switched to having it strictly not give me the answers/write code, but point me in the right direction. This has resulted in a much more satisfying modding experience.
The reason I think it is still helpful even if you aren't using it to code or do art, is that it can do a great job at explaining/summarizing. My biggest issue with modding is the documentation.
It is the actual worst thing in existence. Gives almost zero examples of how things should be used/implemented. Entire features are left undocumented and require you to read source code.
I mean, even if you can find another mod that does something similar to what you are wanting, most people don't comment at all, meaning there is never any explanation of how/why things are working the way they do.
That's not to mention that growing amount of people attempting to copyright/close source their mods these days, making learning from other even harder as all that knowledge is locked away.
AI can help ease some of these pains. I would never use it to replace the knowledge requirements to make a mod, but I think it can be very helpful as a guide/teacher to help people in the process.
@Gamezillion100@ShitpostRock As for candles. I struggle to say that dungeons is responsible for that as they are such a generic item/block and have been both a requested feature and a block many mods have added long before dungeons was even a thing.
@Gamezillion100@ShitpostRock I'm unsure about the poplar wood set, but I do know the illager set of mobs were technically introduced to the base game before dungeons.
They wanted a mob to use as the enemy for dungeons and other spinoffs, so they created and added them to the base game.
@Gamezillion100@ShitpostRock The real question is if we will even get all those biomes. Dungeons 1 added a ton of biomes/mobs/dungeons and so on to the over world and even the end.
To the best of my knowledge, we never saw a single one added to the game. My fear is this will be a barebones implementation.
Stop being intentionally dense. That wasn't the argument you were making nor is it the one I'm going to have with you.
People die because they don't have means to protect themselves or their loved ones. Like I said, it happens all the time.
Taking away people's means/ability to protect themselves and others does not make society safer. That shouldn't be a hard concept to grasp.
@SincereHyp44120@ShitpostRock Not really. The last time they updates it I think it was primarily to increase graphics and add DLSS support.
That being said, this still largely feels unnecessary to me. The game was fine as is, and really would only slightly benefit from some simple gameplay enhancements.
@VictorMatchEN@ChibiReviews Do tell what other horrendously insidious thing is happening in the UK that the serial gang rapes of over 250,000 young girls are somehow the lesser evil meant to distract you? I'm very curious...
Or are you claiming that the other shit in the UK was meant to distract from this?
@jonahsonnyd @ChampionsOTIce@DwarvenConstit1 Being arrested and having a criminal background is exactly what is going to keep you in that situation and potentially make it worse for you and your kid.
I swear it feels like people genuinely lack foresight these days and are willing to die on the dumbest hills.
The problem I always see with this argument is that they don't account for maturity. Someone, like the MC here, can hit a mental block that prevents them from maturing being a certain point. That is what I believe happened to him, and why he still behaves like a child a lot of the time earlier in the story.
A huge portion of the story is not just about him growing up in a new world, but mainly him maturing and growing as a person. Coming to terms with his past, recognizing his shortcomings and failures, and accepting and moving past them. Being an adult is not just being old. It is a state of mind as well.
I believe, based on what we see and know from him, that he stagnated mentally as an early teen(I'm a bit fuzzy on this point). So, still a kid. He only started to move past that point at around the time he was in his teens again while in the new world. So mental and physical maturity eventually do align again, just 20-30+ years too late.
Does this lessen some of the earlier stuff he does in the series. No, not really. It does help explain the mentality behind it though and why he exhibited such behavior. Children are often not rational, and horny teenagers even less so.