@jrroszman @redhistorian Butt didn't write about his own political beliefs, that I can find anyway. His defence of Protestantism was more an assertion of a minority political identity than doctrinal fundamentalism. But there is some revealing insights in a book by James Collins called Life in Old Dublin
@jrroszman @redhistorian Boyton reported back to O'Connell that while he liked the idea, he couldn't sell it to his fellow Tories for sectarian reasons.
@jrroszman @redhistorian Boyton is interesting as he and O'Connell had talks about creating a Tory-Repeal coalition in the early 1830s, with the common denominator being a dislike of the English Whigs. With Home Rule, Butt was basically during the same thing in 1870, whether consciously or not.
@jrroszman @redhistorian I think a lot of the shift from Irish Protestant/Tory Butt to Fenian defender and Homer Ruler is down to disillusionment with the the inability of the British to create meaningful spaces for what he would call 'Irish patriotism' to be channelled politically. And the Famine.
@jrroszman @redhistorian Collins was probably his illegitimate son. He wrote that Butt was an 'orthodox Protestant' but observed a number of 'Catholic practices' - he had a cross brought back from Jerusalem by a Catholic MP, a book called 'The Glories of Mary' and a set of miraculous medals.