@gcalva42@AustinOravec You’re conflating two different things - ohtani’s intrinsic value to the dodgers organization when considering the financial incentives that come with him, and ohtani’s literal value on a baseball field.
@gcalva42@AustinOravec I guess I should say, relative to other players production and median price per WAR (~8-9 mil). Obviously he’s still worth it to the dodgers because they have infinite resources
@gcalva42@AustinOravec From a pure baseball value standpoint Ohtani did not deserve 70m last year. Endorsements and outside cash flows and what have you are really irrelevant to the conversation of baseball value.
@gcalva42@AustinOravec “Players at the top won’t willingly take less” teams will just offer less across the board. There isn’t going to be one team willing to pay x player 70m aav while the rest are at 35.
The MLBPA claims a salary cap and floor system would “dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players”
Is that really a true statement?
@gcalva42@AustinOravec I am walking you through the economics step by step. NFL team value is inherently concentrated in those majority of players. Who do you think is more likely to contribute to game outcomes: the 40th best player on an NFL roster, or the 20th best on an MLB roster?
@gcalva42@AustinOravec This is the decision problem facing every single front office. If you think teams are just going to neglect proven talent on the market that can contribute to winning then I have an oceanfront property in Kansas to sell you.
@gcalva42@AustinOravec Baseball isn’t basketball. Ohtani doesn’t win you a championship on his own. You need somewhere close to 26 contributors! You can’t give hundreds and hundreds of AB and IP to minor leaguers and expect to beat a team with more balanced construction over the course of a season.
@gcalva42@AustinOravec There are five levels of minor league baseball, only one of those levels fields any players that are anywhere close to as good as the majors.
How do the rays and brewers compete? Not with minor leaguers, that’s for sure. Further those teams are obvious outliers
@ufosorwhatever@NoahW_25 So parity cannot fundamentally exist because Quentin Grimes may get an extra toothpaste commercial if he signs in LA as opposed to Sacramento. This reality supersedes the equal financial playing ground all 30 teams are on because, reasons
@LeashYoKidz@gcalva42@AustinOravec Is this supposed to be a dig against a salary cap? Obviously it doesn’t work the same if one team is self imposing financial restrictions and others aren’t lmao
@TJenksTampa@luckyyLefty1027@tipping_pitches When did anyone ever argue that owners don’t want money? A system where owners get more money and that is more fair for all 30 teams is not contradictory.
@gcalva42@AustinOravec This doesn’t make any sense with the structure of baseball. There isn’t just “cost controlled talent” in abundance. If you want to win as a baseball organization you have to field a competent, balanced team of players, not a bunch of minor leaguers and Ohtani.
@TJenksTampa@luckyyLefty1027@tipping_pitches most power TO speak out would be the ones being directly hurt by the new system. Like do you really expect, I dunno, Michael Massey to come out and be like “fuck Bobby Witt and his salary, MLBPA is wrong”?
@TJenksTampa@luckyyLefty1027@tipping_pitches Not only is it an incredibly unpopular opinion to agree with the owners perspective just for normal people like you and I, but then you would have to further consider the political drawbacks of speaking out against your own players association, and the highest paid guys with the