A collaborative effort to illuminate the K-12 curriculum landscape for educators & advocates. We get into the important weeds for popular and emerging programs.
Does direct instruction work? Some claimed Stockard et al. (2018) meta-analysis didn't compare DI to inquiry-based teaching for math. We reanalyzed the data. DI was significantly MORE effective than inquiry-based (d = 0.60, 95% CI = 0.49 to 0.70). @CECMembership@NCTM@ehanford
GED student in last night’s Word Mapping Project class (after complaining that this work is breaking her brain):
“Tell Mr. Morrisey thank you. No, wait, wait. Tell him his lessons are having an impact on our brains.”
The WMP is absolutely incredible. @smorrisey has created something very special. A child who has the opportunity to learn all three levels (or more!) of WMP will have an astounding vocabulary. WMP should be a staple of upper elementary curricula. Hirsch’s findings on vocab:
Important insights from @DTWillingham.
First, the strength of evidence for DI varying by realm:
"I do think there is good evidence that DI leads to strong academic outcomes. The evidence tends to be overstated in some quarters; it’s uneven, and it’s strongest for foundational skills..."
Second, the framing issue:
"The narrative of Sold a Story encourages listeners to interpret resistance to DI primarily as a failure to understand or respect the evidence. But I suspect that explanation is incomplete."
Important reading.
I hope this week we can focus our attention around teachers doing some brilliant work. Elana Gordon is not only one of the best teachers I know, she hosts and amazing podcast. The Road to Reading Podcast is now in season 5. I can't wait to listen to this one later tonight.
Vocabulary win of the day:
My most struggling student asks me to go to the water fountain. He pauses before I could respond and says...
"Please don't deprive me of water Mr. Morrisey."
By the end of the year, I'd better get...
"Please don't deprive me of water Mr. Morrisey, I'm feeling a bit parched."
This student is reading the room. He knows that he is going to get a more favorable response by including the word deprive. And he is right.
Every assessment has a finite test item bank. Take vocabulary for example. Some assessments will only ask vocabulary questions in certain ways and the vocabulary bank is limited. For any assessment you can game the system to a degree.
Take the NYS ELA assessment. The writing section isn't really about writing. Answer the question and give two supporting details is basically what you have to do on the NYS ELA assessment. It has really nothing to do with actual good writing. So what do schools do, they practice this stuff (using things like RACE), but actual writing gets pushed out of the curriculum. Sixth grade teachers in my district wanted to know what the elementary teachers use in regards to writing strategies like RACE - Restate, Answer, Cite, Explain. There were no questions for us regarding how we actually teach writing. See the isssue here.
Adaptive tests like NWEA MAP and iReady are no different. They do have fairly big item banks, but they are finite. With the advent of AI, I hope those item banks are getting substantially larger. iReady claims that using their lessons improve scores on the iReady assessments. Well, ok, but the lesson questions are set up in the exact same way as the assessment. It is practicing to the test to a degree. The same can be said about the MAP. I just googled and there are literally quizlet questions etc. geared towards MAP questions. I can't say to what degree, but teaching to an assessment kind of invalidates the assessment, right?
I despise all of this because it is spending instructional time on things that can game the system a bit, but the opportunity cost is fairly substantial. This is why I always go back and forth with regard to state assessments and adaptive measures like MAP. Certainly, we need accountability, but the accountability can work against actual learning if we spend time teaching to the tests.
Are we keeping students stuck in strategy dependency in math for too long, causing them to never get to automaticity?
For one of my 3rd graders, I think this is the exact problem.
@brian_poncy@HKorbey
Reaching Escape Velocity In Math: The Problem https://t.co/VmemwkGzLA
“One of the most interesting things about expertise is that it changes how difficult the same material feels for an expert and a novice:
The more we know, the less mental effort we need to expend on things that once required all our attention.”
I run a fairly tight ship in my 5th grade classroom. I have my students all day except for math. 75% of my students go to other classrooms for math. When my students came back into my classroom after math today, one student belched rather loudly. I noticed a few students look at me for my reaction. This became a teachable vocabulary moment. I looked wide eyed at this student and without saying anything walked slowly to my whiteboard. I began writing. Students were actually rapt with attention.
"Eructation is banned in this classroom."
"Eructation is strictly prohibited in this classroom."
I called on a student to read these sentences so everyone could hear the correct pronunciation of the word eructation. I then had students chorally read the sentences as a class. A quick turn and talk to discuss what this means. Yes, eructation is the act of belching/burping.
I like the word eructation as you can break it into syllables and meaningful parts for spelling and meaning.
e ruc ta tion (syllables)
eruct + ate + ion -> eructation (morphemes)
Little do my 5th graders know that I can eructate the alphabet song. It is quite a skill that I have.
I am going to begin tomorrow with a sentence combining activity.
Directions: Combine the following sentences into one sentence. Keep all the important information and avoid repeating words.
Eructation is strongly discouraged in our classroom.
Flatulence is considered an even more serious violation.
Both offenses violate our classroom air-quality standards.
While eructation is strongly discouraged in our classroom, flatulence is considered an even more serious violation of our air-quality standards!
Sharing this vocabulary experience as a class is what it is all about.
More attention, but not more learning?
In a new RCT, additional support made students much more attentive during reading lessons (65% vs. 41%). Yet their reading outcomes did not improve.
A reminder that visible attention and learning aren't necessarily the same thing.
https://t.co/OkK5MzUO9h
Here's the thing about writing: it's not separate from what students are learning in ELA, science, and social studies. It's how they show they understand it. ✍️
Listen 🎙️ https://t.co/IGaBga6niM
Important note:
A number of parties have developed new, thoughfully-designed materials since 1976, when Project Follow-Through data collection concluded.
It has been fifty years, after all.
My fifth grade class got to watch the Matilda the Musical performed by our Middle School. Word Wise, I love this song. I was in my glory listening to the lyrics in this one.
https://t.co/tSR4yZOLeW
Daily spelling dictation doesn't take much time (5 minutes), yet can really help move the needle when it comes to improving students' overall spelling skills. At times, I have students spell the words using word sums or I have them circle the prefixes and suffixes and underline the base.
Today, one of my struggling students spelled the words consideration, representatives, and responsibilities without a problem.
We have to make a commitment to spelling instruction. We can't just let spelling go when students reach third grade.