This guy is mad that I'm going to take my kids to see the 50th anniversary release of Star Wars. He accuses me of brainwashing.
I should probably have told him that my children are all girls so they won't give a shit about Star Wars anyway.
I mean, you're talking about guiding a child's experience through Star Wars so they can regurgitate your views uncritically without disagreement. I'm pretty sure that when you bring up those topics, I'm allowed to express my concern about how much of a loser you sound with your desperate effort to create a clone of yourself.
But just imagine the sheer wonder and joy on a child's face when, after a lifetime of only being exposed to George Lucas's impoverished vision of the Star Wars universe, you finally show him the REAL Mos Eisley: a zoomed-out shot of the street with the cantina, and a zoomed-in shot of the street with the cantina.
@VOR467 I didn't answer you because I don't take your insults or accusations seriously and also because my parenting is none of your business. Nobody disowns his kids over a movie.
Frankly, you're unhinged. You need to get offline and go do something else.
@VOR467@martinmattl Lucasfilm was incorporated in '77, but I don't think that's particularly important here.
As for the argument I didn't answer, I probably missed it. Breathe into a paper bag for a minute and then repeat it, more calmly.
@VOR467 Yes, I am teaching my children and that teaching involves imparting my worldview. That is called parenting, not brainwashing (and please remember we're talking about a damn movie, so calm down). They will of course develop their own opinions as they grow older. /
@VOR467@martinmattl "Pro-corporate"? The movie is a corporate product. Any defense or criticism could be called "pro-corporate" in some sense.
I'm actually pro-archives. I don't know how that's selfish, exactly, but if you think it is, so be it. But yes, I am "death of the author," somewhat.
@VOR467@martinmattl I agree there are gray areas. The endless tweaking since the original release mostly falls into those gray areas, but the Special Editions visibly broke with earlier versions, and audiences were unhappy because the changes were obviously anachronistic.
@VOR467@martinmattl I don't really know how you can defend the sequence under discussion on any grounds. If you can't see why it is discordant, well, then you can't.
I'd oppose Da Vinci if he wanted to put sunglasses on the Mona Lisa. I don't accept the idea of artist as eternal owner of the work.
@VOR467@martinmattl "franchise," whose older parts must be made to conform to newer parts so there is continuity. I, however, see it as a piece of history, and I see vandalism of it, even by its creator, as akin to censorship.
@VOR467@martinmattl negatively to it because it is obviously and visibly a later insertion, out of step with the look and feel of the rest of the film.
However, this argument is acrimonious in part because the two sides view the matter quite differently; you see Star Wars as a world, a /
The Star Trek special effect "improvements" are just as evil as the Star Wars special editions. These things should be seen for what they are: Vandalism.
They lovingly re-did all the special effects for Star Trek TOS and TNG blurays, improving them and cleaning them up while still making them look like they could be from the 1960s / 1980s.
Yet if you want to enjoy Star Wars in HD you still have to put up with George Lucas's half-baked retarded do-dads and PS1-graphics monstrosities cluttering up the screen.
I have a beautiful bluray set of Harmy's De-Specialized editions, but I would love something that cleans up the rougher effects while still keeping with the '70s '80s aesthetic.
On the Star Trek blurays, purists can even switch between original and new effects. How hard would it be for Lucas to simply do something like this?
Kids today don't have the attention span or mental capacity to watch A New Hope. Sorry, George. Shove all the CG farting aliens in there you want; most are not making it through 20 minutes of droids wandering the desert.
The people who will continue to enjoy the OT are the fans, their high-iq kids, and their grandkids. Let us have the movies we've dreamed of having. Otherwise we will just go ahead and do it with A.I. anyway. But we're giving you the chance to do it first, George. Thank you.
SF authors are STEM majors, fantasy authors are modern liberal arts majors, so that means that SF authors are widely read in the liberal arts, unlike fantasy authors
@martinmattl That may be, but to be honest, I don't care about and don't respect his dissatisfaction. He created a landmark piece of cinema that deserves to be preserved and seen.
Also, the newer Mos Eisley sequence is ass.