"And independent of intent I believe that the presentation of shithole in the desert is a superior choice to the bustling Tatooine."
Why are you so married to this idea? What makes Jabba the Hutt, an international Crime Boss and leader of the Hutts, the type of person to do most of his traffic out of a shithole as opposed to a bustling spaceport that is both dangerous and filled with crime? What makes your view on this better than that of the artist who made it and give yours credibility? Also, doesn't it create huge plot holes if Mos Eisley is so undeveloped that it takes the Stormtroopers this long to find them?
"It's a great stylistic contrast having the quiet outside and the activity inside."
Wtf are you talking about? The same could be said of what is going on in the Cantina?
I mean, you're talking about guiding a child's experience through Star Wars so they can regurgitate your views uncritically without disagreement. I'm pretty sure that when you bring up those topics, I'm allowed to express my concern about how much of a loser you sound with your desperate effort to create a clone of yourself.
Being a corporation and behaving like a typical corporation are two different things. I figured you would understand that you're arguing a "technically..." when I'm not even remotely referencing anything you're talking about because what you're talking is brain-dead, root "but Lucasfilm is a corporation so I don't understand what you mean, it is pro-corporate no matter what" type of reasoning that doesn't advance anything.
It's very clear you just wantto waste my time with this nonsense post.
Again, you didn't answer the question of what would you do if you found out they disagreed with you whole heartedly and thought the SE were better? And no, I'm sorry, but your hand holding your kids in how exactly to view things and why. That is not parenting that is trying to create a little mini-version of yourself, which kids are not. Kids should just watch the originals and then the SE and then you have a conversation about what they thought without significantly influencing them, allowing them to make up their own minds. This notion of "i have to impart my worldview onto my children" are narcisists. You don't children as their own people, you view children as a means of having your own views regurgitated back at you.
wtf are you talking about? The first six Star Wars films were made by independent media owned by a single person. It's literally the definition of Indie films. Hell, even the licensed materials such as books, comics, video games, and the tv show, were all done by independent licensing laws, allowing Lucas Publishing to act as an independent license agreement, thus giving out all the material that exists.
You really have no idea wtf you're talking about? Also I made a specific arguement and point of preference that you're not even bothering to respond to.
Ah yes,lets embrace death of the author for everything then because after all, you just want to alter the works of artists to your own selfish ends because you dont care about the person who made it. Art to you is a product to be bought and sold with no regard to the person responsible for it. It is not something that evolves over time, its static, unchanging and completely without any other I terpretation or opinion possible other than yours.
You're not pro-art or pro-cinema, you're pro corporate and pro-consumer.
@weiss1163770@mightydudbolt Oh so we're including insults and quotes out of context as ad hominum when that ain't even what an ad hom is. Thanks for wasting my time bub.
@thrashinbatman@DGDDavidson He's not refusing anything. When George cleaned up the original negative for transfer to digital, they literally changed them to the point where it would not look like it did originally.
You don't even know anything about this topic so stfu already, you're wasting my time.
@TimeFish57@Gojisaurus@JacobKenne92848 All your posting, and you could have done a sentence-long explanation of what you mean. But instead you think you can make react to your trolling.
I'm talking about the hypocrisy of preservationists because many of these people see what George has done to create the SE amounts to artistic vandalism. An artist wanting to finish his work to make it the movie he wanted it to be, is apparently vandalizing an historic piece. But when you pull back and examine the claims, you find pretty quickly that these people do not think what George is doing as being valid to the creation of art, even though artists do this all the time. This is an implicit bias and ultimately contradictory in terms of what is art and what is worth preserving. These people think the initial thing that got praise and made history is worth preserving, but anything George does to change things is seen as vandalism, despite this being normal for artists to do begin with.
So as you can see, while both can exist, this position of the only the originals are historically relevant of preserving implicitly denies the SE their place in the history of the films changing. It also denies them as art, as people often prefer to use terms like slop or garbage to diminish the groundbreaking work with those additions.
So you are here not to provide anything useful in a conversation; you just want to fuck around and make vague bullshit references that probably don't even exist.
Either way, you brought something up, you provide the reason for what it is and why I should care. Otherwise, you're just a sad little troll trying to frustrate someone by looking like a deranged loser.
It's always a wonder when people go on and on about preserving film history yet these people would prefer that George never have his changes to his art preserved. Also, art in general seems to be a selective notion. What makes George's SE any less worth preserving than that of an artist considered inferior?
Incorrect on that I view the thing as a franchise. I view the movies primarily as art, mainly the prequels and the original trilogy. As such, an artist is fine to change it if they feel they can improve on it. Saying the Mos Eisley addition isn't an improvement is incorrect as it literally sets up at the very beginning a theme of conflict and danger that the place represents. You can say the SE clash with the rest of the movie, but that is a matter of opinion of what you think looks better. Obviously, I think the SE are better than what came before, primarily because it offers the artistic "through the looking glass" effect of seeing a living breathin world, which is the artistic intent.
By contrast, you only see these movies as historical and cultural touchstones, despite the fact that it literally divorces art from being a part of culture and that the history of the changes to that art is also not a part of culture. It's a very sloppy and completely contradictory position that holds really no validity beyond the idea that you don't think artists have a right to change their work.
The fact of the matter is, I respect George Lucas as an artist who has the right to change his work to his vision, while you, on the other hand, have created this Frankenstein reasoning that, in the end, is unsustainable.
@Zhaktronz@mightydudbolt Except that was never the intent. You're literally bragging about the superiority of the presentation of a place based on faulty intent of the artist. Are you even bothering to take into consideration that it was meant to be a bustling hub of debauchery and crime?
@thrashinbatman@DGDDavidson wtf are you talking about? We support the originals because its not only Lucas' vision but its also an enhancement to the scenes. You've never actually seen the originals, as is evidenced of you saying the CGI is bad when its not.
My guy, the originals were never suppressed. George Lucas stopped publishing them, that's all. And he says its multiple reasons, such as having to touch up the original negative for digital conversion ended up altering it permanently, something they didn't know would happen because its literally one of the first time something like that has been done. And up to the release of the SE, he ran a huge campaign on where to find the last copies of the original run, knowing fans would want that. He didn't suppress the originals, hell he guaranteed anyone who is a fun would have at least the originals on VHS or laserdisc.
Seriously, original fans really live in this alternate reality of facts and "um actually..." arguments.