GOAT FUNDED: 30+ TRADER COMPLAINTS. THESE QUESTIONS DESERVE ANSWERS.
First, we are NOT targeting @GoatFunded.
A member of our team previously approached the firm regarding an affiliate partnership. That was a mistake, and we openly apologise.
But let's not divert attention from the actual issue.
25 PUBLIC TRADER CASES WE HAVE DOCUMENTED:
1. @Bmwgol β Account terminated over alleged group trading.
2. @Gustavseepp β $8,400 rejected, 44 alleged matching trades.
3. @XalesTheGreat β Payout denied over group trading allegations.
4. @eliteayomide β $3,066 rejected and account terminated.
5. @x_43hapy β $5Kβ$6K rejected, $100K account terminated.
6. @Bhoma909 β 11+ previous payouts before rejection and closure.
7. @mohit_kelkar β Rejected after four successful payouts.
8. @xauusd34 β $808 rejected over 15 alleged matching trades.
9. @SonobarKhalid β $1,950 rejected and account closed.
10. @__chatt β Terminated over matching trades/shared IP allegations.
11. @0xkliq β Challenging a group trading allegation and requesting proof.
12. @PhilBro14326231 β $1,000+ payout denial.
13. @david_viado β $3,000 payout denial.
14. @KwadwoAdj β $7,000 payout rejection.
15. @spsourav5 β Rejections involving own Instant accounts.
16. @niffera0 β $4,000 denied, evidence concerns.
17. @DonTradesNQ β Shared screenshots of a payout dispute.
18. @Victor18748754 β Alleged breach appeared at payout stage.
19. @hemantnayak02 β Reported a similar experience.
20. @mayorofcryptotp β Previous payout received, another account denied.
21. @pip_core β Account closed despite claiming independent trading.
22. @Ibdchacha β Payout denied and account closed.
23. @DJ_BOYz1 β Friend's approximately $1,000 payout rejected.
24. @abduulkoko β Similar payout dispute.
25. @NacerNacer65061 β Related payout complaint.
NOVEMBER TRUSTPILOT CASES:
26. $200 β $5K Instant HERO payout denied over alleged group trading.
27. $426 β $25K payout denied over copy/group trading allegations.
28. Emanuele F. β Account terminated and payout denied after 29 trades were flagged.
29. Akila Dis β Approximately $4,000 rejected on a $200K account.
30. Jeevarathnam K. β Two payouts rejected over alleged group trading.
31. Stefan Catalin β Coordinated trading breach allegation.
32. Muhammad Sohaib β Copy trading allegation on a $25K Instant account.
33. Julius β Two payouts denied over coordinated trading allegations.
@NazGFT, instead of publishing partial screenshots suggesting we demanded $100, why not address the actual complaints?
That screenshot does not represent the full context. Publishing half a conversation while ignoring the rest is unfair.
We are not asking anyone to blindly believe traders. We are asking for evidence, transparent explanations and proper resolutions.
33 complaints deserve more than an affiliate discussion.
@GoatFunded@EdwardXLreal@NazGFT
#GoatFunded #PropFirm #TraderRights
π¨ GOAT FUNDED FACING MASS ACCOUNT TERMINATIONS OVER GROUP TRADING 15+ TRADERS AFFECTED
This is no longer looking like an isolated incident. Multiple traders are raising similar complaints against @GoatFunded.
Accounts are reportedly being terminated and payouts rejected under allegations of group trading, matching trades and coordinated activity.
TRADERS WHO HAVE PUBLICLY COME FORWARD:
1. @Bmwgol Account terminated. 6+ years of ICT trading experience. Demanding specific proof.
2. @Ibdchacha Failed 30+ accounts before reaching payout stage. Payout denied and account closed.
3. @eliteayomide $3,066 payout rejected and account terminated.
4. @0xkliq Received a group trading email. Demanding evidence.
5. @Bhoma909 11+ previous payouts before the latest rejection and account closure. Reports being blocked after speaking out.
6. @x_43hapy Approximately $5,000β$6,000 rejected and $100K account terminated over 51 alleged matching trades.
7. @mohit_kelkar Payout rejected after four successful payouts.
8. @xauusd34 $808 payout rejected over 15 alleged matching trades.
9. @SonobarKhalid $1,950 payout rejected and account closed over alleged coordinated trading.
10. @__chatt Account terminated over matching trades and shared IP allegations.
11. @DJ_BOYz1 Friend's approximately $1,000 payout reportedly rejected over group trading.
12. @abduulkoko Reported a similar group trading dispute.
13. @PhilBro14326231 Payout denied and account closed after becoming profitable.
14. @NacerNacer65061 Also reported related payout and account issues.
15. Multiple additional traders have raised similar complaints in discussions under PropFirmShinobi and Goat Funded posts.
AND THE COMPLAINTS KEEP COMING.
@GoatFunded@EdwardXLreal@NazGFT@Sammy_GFT
You keep saying that evidence is shared privately.
But several affected traders are publicly questioning whether the evidence actually demonstrates coordinated trading or simply identifies matching trades.
Let's be clear:
Matching trades alone do not automatically prove group trading.
Independent traders can trade the same pair, follow similar strategies and enter at almost identical prices.
If coordinated activity occurred, provide specific evidence. If accounts were terminated correctly, explain the exact rule violations.
Traders deserve transparency, consistent enforcement and a fair opportunity to challenge these decisions.
How many more traders will face the same allegations before these cases receive a proper public explanation?
STATUS: 15+ REPORTED CASES | GROUP TRADING & PAYOUT DENIAL DISPUTES
ββββββββββββββββ
DISCLAIMER:
This report is based on publicly shared trader complaints, statements and screenshots. The allegations have not been independently verified in every individual case.
PropFirmShinobi aims to report both sides of every dispute. Goat Funded is welcome to provide detailed explanations and supporting evidence addressing these individual complaints.
The firm has not yet provided detailed public responses addressing every case listed above.
We remain open to publishing the firm's response and any additional clarification.
#GoatFunded #GroupTrading #AccountBreached #PayoutDenied #PropFirmShinobi
π¨ GOAT FUNDED, HOW MANY PAYOUTS ARE YOU GOING TO REJECT BEFORE YOU ANSWER THESE TRADERS?
12+ traders have reportedly come forward with similar complaints. Different accounts, different payout amounts, but the same accusations: matching trades, coordinated trading and group trading.
Traders claim they passed challenges, received previous payouts and suddenly became rule violators when they requested more money.
11+ previous payouts? Suddenly a violation.
$5,000β$6,000 payout? Suddenly 51 matching trades.
Ask for proof? In some cases, traders claim they get blocked.
Seriously, @GoatFunded?
You cannot keep throwing around serious accusations like copy trading and group trading while refusing to show traders exactly what they supposedly did wrong.
Matching trades are not automatic proof of coordinated trading.
If you have evidence, SHOW IT.
If traders violated your rules, identify the exact trades and explain the violations.
If your decisions are justified, why is transparency such a problem?
A risk team email is not a substitute for evidence. A generic allegation is not a proper explanation. And previous payouts should not suddenly become irrelevant when a trader requests a larger withdrawal.
@GoatFunded@EdwardXLreal
STOP HIDING BEHIND VAGUE ALLEGATIONS. ANSWER THESE TRADERS AND SHOW THE EVIDENCE.
12+ complaints deserve more than silence and copy-paste responses.
#GoatFunded #PayoutRejected #PropFirm #TraderRights
π¨ GOAT FUNDED: 12 TRADERS REPORT PAYOUT REJECTIONS, ACCOUNT CLOSURES & UNANSWERED QUESTIONS.
How many traders need to raise concerns before @GoatFunded provides a detailed public explanation?
At least 12 traders have now come forward with complaints involving rejected payouts, terminated funded accounts, alleged matching trades, copy trading, shared IP connections and blocked communication.
What's particularly concerning?
Several traders claim they had already received multiple successful payouts before their accounts were suddenly flagged or terminated.
LET'S REVIEW THE REPORTED CASES:
1. @Bhoma909: Claims he received 11+ successful payouts before his latest payout was rejected and his account closed. He also alleges he was blocked after raising concerns.
2. @x_43hapy: Reports a rejected payout of approximately $4,804β$6,000 and termination of a $100K account over 51 allegedly matching trades. Claims he was blocked on X and Discord.
3. @mohit_kelkar: Says his payout was rejected after four successful payouts, despite spending over two months generating the reported profits.
4. @xauusd34: Reports an $808.64 payout rejection over 15 allegedly matching trades. Denies copy trading and questions the investigation.
5. @SonobarKhalid: Reports a $1,950 payout rejection and account closure over alleged coordinated trading. Wants supporting evidence.
6. @__chatt: Reports account termination over alleged group trading, matching trades and shared IP connections.
7. @NacerNacer65061: Claims his payout was rejected and account blocked because his payout wallet was allegedly connected to multiple accounts.
8. @DJ_BOYz1: Reports that a friend's approximately $1,000 payout was rejected over an alleged group trading violation.
9. @abduulkoko: Also came forward reporting a similar experience and shared screenshots.
10. @rexytrades07: Says he experienced a similar situation back in July.
11. @zinoo_fx: Claims he was blocked following a dispute involving GFT and reports a similar experience with another firm.
12. @MoustaphaFomba1: Reports that his funded account was closed in March without clear communication.
THE BIGGER ISSUE: TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
Let's be clear.
Prop firms have every right to enforce their trading rules. Traders are also responsible for following those rules.
But shouldn't traders receive clear explanations when their accounts are terminated and payouts rejected?
If there were 51 matching trades, can the relevant trade records be provided?
If there were 15 matching trades, what instruments, timestamps and execution details established the alleged coordination?
If shared IP connections were involved, how were they evaluated?
If a payout wallet was linked to multiple accounts, what evidence supported the decision?
A matching trade or shared IP connection alone should not replace a proper investigation of the complete circumstances.
And if these decisions were justified, why not provide a transparent explanation?
@GoatFunded@EdwardXLreal@NazGFT@HafeezGFT@igweGFT
12 reported cases deserve a serious response.
This is not just about individual payouts. It's about the confidence traders place in the entire prop trading industry.
Traders invest money, time and effort into these accounts. They deserve transparent rules, consistent enforcement and a fair opportunity to challenge decisions.
Reputation is earned through actions, not marketing.
GOAT FUNDED, THE COMMUNITY IS WAITING FOR ANSWERS.
Address the reported cases. Explain the decisions. Provide the evidence where possible.
TrustedPropNews will continue to raise trader concerns and push for transparency.
#GoatFunded #PropFirm #PayoutRejected #TraderRights
π¨ GOAT FUNDED: 12 TRADERS, MULTIPLE PAYOUT REJECTIONS, ACCOUNT CLOSURES & STILL NO DETAILED ANSWERS?
How many traders need to come forward before @GoatFunded publicly addresses these complaints?
At least 12 traders have now shared reports involving rejected payouts, terminated funded accounts, alleged copy trading, matching trades, shared IP connections and blocked communication.
And what makes these cases even more concerning is that several traders claim they had already received multiple successful payouts before facing these issues.
LET'S LOOK AT THE REPORTED CASES.
1. @Bhoma909 : Claims he received 11+ previous payouts before his latest payout was rejected and account closed. Says he was blocked after raising concerns.
2. @x_43hapy : Reports a rejected payout of approximately $4,804β$6,000 and termination of a $100K account over 51 allegedly matching trades. Claims he was blocked on X and Discord.
3. @mohit_kelkar : Says his payout was rejected after four successful payouts. Claims it took him over two months to generate the profit before receiving the rejection.
4. @xauusd34 : Reports an $808.64 payout rejection over 15 allegedly matching trades. Denies copy trading and questions the review process.
5. @SonobarKhalid : Reports a $1,950 payout rejection and account closure over alleged coordinated trading. Demands evidence.
6. @__chatt : Reports account termination over alleged coordinated group trading, matching trades and shared IP connections.
7. @NacerNacer65061 : Claims his payout was rejected and account blocked because his payout wallet was allegedly linked to multiple people/accounts.
8. @DJ_BOYz1: Claims a friend's approximately $1,000 payout was rejected over an alleged group trading violation.
9. @abduulkoko: Also came forward saying he experienced the same situation and shared screenshots.
10. @rexytrades07 : Says he experienced a similar issue back in July.
11. @zinoo_fx : Claims he was blocked following a dispute involving GFT and reports a similar experience with another firm.
12. @MoustaphaFomba1: Reports that his funded account was closed in March without clear communication.
THE BIGGER QUESTION IS NOT JUST ABOUT THE PAYOUTS.
It's about the way these situations are being handled.
If traders are genuinely violating your rules, you have every right to enforce those rules.
But traders also have the right to understand exactly why their accounts are being terminated and why their earned payouts are being rejected.
51 matching trades? Show the 51 trades.
15 matching trades? Show the timestamps, instruments, execution details and the basis for identifying coordination.
Shared IP? Explain how that connection establishes a rule violation.
Shared payout wallet? Explain the investigation and the accounts involved.
A matching trade alone should not be treated as automatic proof of coordinated trading without examining the complete context.
And if these traders are wrong, publish the evidence that demonstrates it.
@GoatFunded@EdwardXLreal@NazGFT@HafeezGFT@igweGFT
12 traders coming forward deserves more than silence or generic explanations.
You cannot build trust in the prop trading industry by asking traders to trust your decisions without showing them the basis for those decisions.
Traders are risking their money, time and effort to earn these payouts.
They deserve transparency, a proper review process and a fair opportunity to challenge account closures.
GOAT FUNDED, IT'S TIME TO ADDRESS THESE CASES PUBLICLY.
No generic response. No vague matching-trade explanation.
Show the evidence. Explain the decisions. Answer the traders.
#GoatFunded #PayoutRejected #PropFirm #TraderRights
I would like to respectfully express my concern regarding the recent decision by @FTMarketsLive affecting Pakistani traders.
FTM has always been one of the firms I genuinely admire, respect, and trust. Iβve had a positive experience with the firm and truly appreciate what it has built for the trading community. Thatβs exactly why this decision is particularly disappointing.
Limiting Pakistani traders to a maximum account size of $50K is unfair to those who have consistently followed the rules and built a genuine relationship with FTM.
If the issue is caused by certain individuals abusing the system through multi-account hedging, there should be targeted measures against those responsible rather than restrictions affecting an entire country.
Pakistan has many serious and dedicated traders who deserve the same opportunities as everyone else.
I genuinely hope FTM reconsiders this decision. We believe in your firm, and we hope you continue to believe in Pakistani traders too. π΅π°
@NoorCOOFTM@RZFTMARKETS@Ye_FTM@FTMarketslive