This model started with setting McDavid as the baseline at 100, and Robo at ~80 (I thought that was fair, but depending on contract that could change). So those two were very high compared to everyone else
Collected a bunch of mock trades to estimate what "the public" thinks is fair value for NHLers.
Obviously there wer a lot more trades for Werenski/Robo/Larkin (over 1k).
These are values based off estimating pick values (then reset so McD is 100)
They also have a lot of total games played last year, T1st again for Fs, and 3rd overall. This means even less I feel, but I had the #s so I figured I'd look at it
Pens have the T3rd most Fs that played at least 1 NHL game last year (19), and T1st most D men (12). Dubas loves his depth. Does this correlate to success at all - no. But it seemed like they had a ton of guys so I wanted to look into it (holy shit CGY too). Rosters as of ~7PM
In terms of guys who actually played last year, the pens have T1st Fs but only 6 Ds with 40+ GP. Still one of only 4 teams with 20+ NHLers on roster. Again, doesn't mean much, but they don't need to make trades to fill out the roster or rush rookies.
People commenting on the pens 38 d men as if we don't also have 200 depth Fs, Robo, Dewar, Lizotte, Brazeu, Soderblom, McGroarty, Hayes, Broz, Hallander, Howe, Koivunen all potential "guys" plus Chinakhov/Kindel/Novak fighting for 2 top 6 spots
I remember Dubas signing like a billion depth guys/older prospects I liked in TOR. Guess he's still doing that in PIT, hopefully a few more hit this year
@piexpri@trithart_@j_a155 I'd be more worried about the limited retention spots than cap space for any potential Rust/Raks/EK deals (incredibly minor issue)
Don't understand the near universal hate on this deal. Korczak put up probably better defensive numbers, better offensive numbers (did not play with EK), is younger (and bigger) and signed to a reasonable deal vs Wotherspoon u potentially have to overpay right before he turns 30.
The Penguins have acquired defenseman Kaedan Korczak from the Vegas Golden Knights in exchange for Parker Wotherspoon.
Details: https://t.co/JDAkhmBVXH
@TopDownHockey@EDLAnalytics Tbf I do think there is a benefit in keeping him in at 7'1. Obv ur extrapolating the model, in this case, too high, but if u changed his height to 6'6 he's ranked ~1k. I do think there is benefit being 7'1 vs 6'6, enough to be ranked 110 prolly not, but to be worth pick 201, yeah
@NBI_Hockey Yeah, this covo just gave me an idea to look into the ~100 most similar prospect profiles to someone and look at what the 99th percentile outcome is, what the 1st percentile outcome is etc
@NBI_Hockey Yeah that's kinda what I was saying. I guess I read "potential" in the literal sense of the best that player could get/the 99th percentile outcome.
I think people also vastly overrate the chances a player hits said ceiling is the larger "issue" in online prospect discourse
Bc prospects never gain weight with NHL S&C coaches and meal plans.
I think skating and weight/strength are 2 of the easiest things to "fix" about prospects.
Plus these guys can score despite those limitations.