New , Kangalal Kaidhusei , etc ., movies were small and Flop but the albums still ruling Playlists . Small scale or Big scale movies , ARR delivers the same 👌❤️
#ARRahman
@Pitysoulgod@pranesh_v_ TVK lost in Christian Majority areas like Kannayakumari, Nilgiris, Muslim Majority areas Like Tenkasi, Ramanathapuram. Their votes mostly from Obc Hindus.
"There is no law prohibiting eating of Biryani over the Ganga river. It's not an offence. Yet they were arrested for it and denied bail for three months. Can people be jailed without bail for months for such an act? Citizens are watching.”
— Justice Ujjal Bhuyan, Supreme Court
@tvkoverseas@raj23011989bal@dostoevesque Modi Will target Ministers of TVK,IUML & Congress by CBI,ED& IT,Not Directly they won't Target Vijay,This in turn will damage TVK party
What is the representation of SC,ST,OBC in CA Profession?
A mystery since ICAI refuses to publish caste wise details.
However we caught hold of one paper " The interplay between caste and the emergent accounting profession in India" by two professors of Melbourne university where the details are provided, but for earlier years.
Graphics are attached
This clearly shows complete domination of upper castes in CA Profession.
Bihar Caste Census, Telangana Caste Census has revealed the same.
It is for this reason, why reservations are needed.
I need to tell a campaign has been started against me for taking for this.
But I can tell you my friends, Im right.
@nethrapal writes for his people and nobody can stop me from writing the truth.
When SC,ST,OBC are just 5% when they should be 50%, am I wrong talking about it
None of the politicians will talk because they want votes from everyone.
Source: https://t.co/JXcyv2ptHg
ICAI is a educational institution
For tax laws, various high courts have held ICAI has an educational institution.
ICAI v. Director General of Income Tax (Exemptions)
W.P.(C) 1927/2010, Delhi High Court, 19 September 2011 (Dipak Misra CJ & Sanjiv Khanna J) · and DGIT(E) v. ICAI, ITA 869/2011, (2012) 347 ITR 86 (Del)
So if ICAI is a educational institution, than Article 15(5) of the constitution should apply to it.
Even private educational institutions have to provide reservation if it is mandated by state laws. Only a handful of them are exempt in India today.
Now if ICAI was declared as an institution of national importance than reservations will not apply. But ICAI does not figure in this.
So clearly, if we consider ICAI has a educational institutions, reservations for SC,ST,OBCs have to be given.
One of the argument which im seeing in my comments is that CA is a skill and ICAI does the certification of that. It is not a degree. The same argument was taken in PG Medical were it was argued that reservation is inappropriate at higher levels because of the skill involved. In the famous supreme court judgement of Neil Aurelio Nunes vs Union of India, the courts reasoned that merit is not compromised and efficiency is also not hurt because of reservation using various evidences.
Now Bar Council of India which conducts the All India Bar Examination, the qualifying marks for General and SC/ST/PWD is different. Why is it the same for everyone in CA examination is the question.
Reservation is already there in Medical PG.
But no concessions and reservations in ICAI.
Another argument is that ICAI is state since government appoints eight persons. Government has the power to regulate any affairs not like a private body. It is therefore comes under the definition of "State" as well and hence reservations needs to be provided.
The more important thing is the mandate provided by the 2022 amendment. It says the following
Long title and Preamble — as amended by Act 12 of 2022
"An Act to make provision for the regulation and development of the profession of Chartered Accountants."
The Chartered Accountants, the Cost and Works Accountants and the Company Secretaries (Amendment) Act, 2022 added the words "and development" (in force from 10 May 2022). "Development" of a profession reasonably includes widening the social base it recruits from. That is now a statutory object, not just an aspiration.
So clearly it can be seen that mandate given to ICAI was to widen the social base that is make ICAI certifications more inclusive so that atleast 50% SC,ST,OBCs are taken in.
In July 2004 the Ministry of Company Affairs directed ICAI, ICSI and ICWAI to reserve 22.5% of their staff strength for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. However till date all this have not happened.
All the above points to one thing on how reservations can be avoided at highest pedestal inspite of constitution allowing for it.
மேகதாது குறித்து கர்நாடகா அரசுடன் பேச்சுவார்த்தைக்கே இடமில்லை ~ @mkstalin 🖤😎💥
"மேகதாது, மாநில உரிமை பத்திலாம் தெரிஞ்சிக்கனும்னா ஒரு நாள் அறிவாலயம் வாங்கடா கிளாஸ் எடுத்து அனுப்புறோம்"😎💥 @TVKVijayHQ