@GiannisAddelle@clamatoes theres nothing beautiful or earnest ab suggesting that writing makes you worse as a writer. you will never get anywhere with that mindset
@provisionalidea no i was not "personally aggrieved" in any capacity by what you said, i just didn't agree with it and attempted to explain why that is, which i feel should be obvious if you stop trying to read my mind and engage with what i say
@provisionalidea you think i'm the only one not working to create a productive discourse here and that's actually what's uncritical about this conversation we're having
@provisionalidea it's the outcome you think hasn't happened yet because ironically, you aren't doing the work of interpreting me charitably, which leads to blundered paraphrasings that generate implicit strawmans (see "anything that doesn't affirm my position is inherently negative or bad faith")
@provisionalidea OK, and in that same vein, perhaps we should also question why you are urging us towards skepticism in the first place? Do you plan on being forthcoming about your carelessnesses, ambient influences, and biases? Or should I just engage with your argument on its own terms first?
@J_K_Chesterton@Zack_AKA_Da_Miz@EndHasNoEn@dee_of_e 's tweet points out this equivocation as something that people with literacy skills are likely to avoid. This is probably because reading books grants you a "smarter" mastery over language than someone who has never read one, and OP's claim reads as w/o merit
@J_K_Chesterton@Zack_AKA_Da_Miz@EndHasNoEn It is, but the first sentence uses the more functional, colloquial definition of 'arbitrary': it reads more clearly as "Reading books is an arbitrary way of gathering [knowledge about the world]." In this interpretation of OP's claim, "arbitrary" is used twice, and he equivocates
@F_Vaggi feels kind of hypocritical for someone arguing for the mathematical semantics of the word "arbitrary" to also use the term "continental philosopher" to describe his opponent, since that term has no consistent, agreed upon, or rigorously structured definition
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR oh i just read your reply on the other fork of this thread. yeah maybe we do just disagree about how OP meant "save" within the context of the original post. perhaps @EARTHM0VERRR could arbitrate?
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR how do you believe op meant it? i'm pretty confident OP would confer with how i am using the word "save" here as consistent with the show's overall themes and plot.
@VladChituc op's reply is silly but sridhar's defense of alz isn't exactly spectacular, because it relies on him misreading the tweet: he says there is "nothing special about books," meaning he uses arbitrarily wrong within the sentence; it's meant to be applied to "books," not smarts
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR i'm not sure i understand what you mean: are you suggesting we *not* refer to "saving" in the context of the original post? because i'm of the view that it does inform eva's point on self-acceptance and the importance of loving oneself
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR i'm talking specifically about instances where rei (and misato/asuka) talk about shinji not being able to be "saved" by others. if you're right about what 'saving' is, then rei is wrong there, and that kind of means a lot of EoE and ep26 of nge proceed under false pretenses
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR no one character in evangelion is fully "rational." the desire to be 'saved' is treated as something fundamentally human, not fundamentally "rational," and it would do the characters a disservice to assume that their desires are always 'smart' or 'healthy' in this way
@jesterc777@EARTHM0VERRR hm, i'm not sure i find that definition plausible. there are times when shinji is shown care when he needs it, and this is a point EoE makes in its dream sequence. if he was "saved" during those times then that would cause a lot of Rei's words, which you draw on, to be false