@SamsaraSings For the 100th time. Yes, you can bring your life experience with you to make your own judgement. The quoted text does not say you can try to persuade others based on your own personal expertise. That is the rule that they violated.
@iseeeeyouuu Good job. I didn't notice that at first. The nurses broke the law by testifying in deliberations based on their own "expertise" and then this woman broke the law by talking about what another juror did.
I suspect the Lindsay Clancy foreperson is now lying. She originally wrote simply "doubt" on the note and has subsequently learned that not all doubts are reasonable so now she's making sure to say that he said he had "reasonable doubts."
@CollinRugg At 5 minutes into this video, the juror said that other jurors who were nurses spoke from their own professional understanding of the number and amounts of drugs in her system. This is forbidden by law. Jurors are not supposed to do that.
I can’t believe I have to say this. Apparently, a lot of people don’t watch trials. Beyond a reasonable doubt is not beyond all doubt.
Legally, the standard of proof for reasonable doubt is uniform across U.S. criminal cases, but practically, individual jurors interpret it through their own personal judgment and life experiences.
The jury has deliberated for over twenty hours. They have not come forward before this point to say this juror has refused to deliberate (which would be a case for removal).
Hung juries happen, they just do regardless of the split.
This juror may have had a doubt, but he/she can still vote guilty. It’s a fact. He/she can vote guilty if they believe the evidence proves guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, not all doubt.
Guys, murders usually don’t occur on video. It is up to each individual juror to decide what was proven or not proven based on their knowledge of the evidence and experiences.
@AshleighMerchan The judge specifically said reasonable doubt is not the absence of all doubt. This juror may have said he has doubts but perhaps he doesn't judge them to be reasonable. I know nuance is hard but please try.
CourtTV commentators suck at understanding nuance in Lindsay Clancy. From the note, the holdout juror said they had doubts but the definition of reasonable doubt is not the absence of all doubt. You can have an unreasonable doubt in your head and still vote to convict.
We need to get rid of random juries. Studies show 30-50% of jurors misunderstand reasonable doubt, intent, recklessness, malice and frequently rely on intuition and their own moral reasoning instead of the law. With 12 jurors, the odds are you get at least one with a sub-80 IQ.
This Lindsay Clancy jury must be wondering if they are prisoners. This is crazy. They must feel they won't be let go unless they reach unanimity. They should have been told the process so they know they only have to say they are deadlocked one more time to be let go.
@CitizenFreeKane Regarding your headline 8/11/2026, are we to care more about the college student dying because she was "beautiful?" I don't see how attractive she was is newsworthy unless you are contending that attractive people are more valuable than the ugly.
@TomSilvaTOH https://t.co/jgr5Xrhe0c Have you seen this? They propose that if you have to make a hole in a joist, don't just make one...add smaller ones to the side to increase joist load capacity.
@josettecaruso@JonathanTurley Even if 94% of people in NYC would auto-vote to convict because he is Trump, the probability that a jury would be made up of 12 such people is still less than 50% (0.94^12).
@DrPimplePopper I can understand your assistants not giving shots, suturing or removing cyst sacs but could they help you squeeze steatocystoma multiplex to save your hands?