Some people also just want to be as weird as possible. Thats why you can watch transgenders have sex (if you can call it that), with swasticas rippling on their bouncy booty cheeks.
Why do white nationalists constantly have to make up more and more weird shit? Neo-paganism, aryans, bronze age minset or whatever. Can't they return to the simpler times of the KKK, white power and just plainly hating minorities?
They aren't, it's a founding myth just as many contemporary narratives, not a factual statement about their origins. There are no greeks in the Dune universe, it's a name from ancient at that point thousands of times misremembered era.
Dune: How is it possible that House Atreides is able to remember their history and ancestors back to the mycenean age of ancient greece, with all the lost history of earth after ten thousands of years?
What are these takes? This isn't true at all. Shaddam isn't "fiercely authoritarian" from the limited time he actually gets in the book. He's a ruler within an already established system and is infact portrayed in a submissive position to the CHOAM and the Guild multiple times.
The biggest mistake in the movies: Shaddam
No Dune adaptation has done justice to Shaddam IV. Whether due to casting or script, both films disappointed: the Emperor is nerfed.
In Lynch's film, in the very first scene the Emperor is coerced by the guild's navigator and loses all the credibility the character needs.
In Villeneuve's film, he is an apathetic and superficial character without any layers. His script boils down to one sentence: "the emperor is a jealous man." All the political maneuvering and shrewdness that would belong to him is transferred to Irulan, after all, Florence Pugh will carry this spotlight into the next film.
Portraying him as a frail old man is the opposite of the book, which describes him as an adult, elegant, imposing, militarized, wearing armor and extremely authoritarian, adored by a private army of fanatical soldiers.
Obviously, behind the mask the Emperor is a lonely and insecure character in the political game, but the films err in only exposing this side. He doesn't even seem like the big boss of the known universe.
Such context is often omitted specifically because it rubs religious audiences the wrong way, it's more risky than presenting them an atheistic vision of the future, because it directly challenges the idea of their contemporary spiritual undestanding being eternal and unchanging.
This is an example of changing a work to suit a socially conservative/religious audience. I agree that it is an erasure of a very clear cultural influence, but I can guarantee you that muslims themselves wouldn't like a more originalist adaptation of Dune, and not just them.
'How Dune: Part Two erases its Middle Eastern, North African and Muslim influences'
From the use of beads and prostration in prayers by the Fremen, to the almost-Arabic language, phrases pulled from religious texts and the wearing of veils, it felt like Dune takes a heavy amount of inspiration from Islam, Middle Eastern and North African cultures yet simultaneously erases us from screen
Phrases, names and words like 'Muad'Dib', 'Shai-Hulud', 'Lisan al-Gaib', 'jinn' and 'Mahdi' aren't simply made-up from a make-believe language – they come from and are inspired by Arabic and Islam. The Mahdi, for example, is a revered religious and spiritual figure who Muslims believe is a messianic deliverer that will fill the earth with justice and equity. Unsurprisingly, Timothée Chalamet isn't exactly who I envisioned to bear such a name.
Another word from the book that is notably left out in the film is 'jihad', the Arabic word for 'struggle'. Instead, the phrase chosen by scriptwriters is "holy war", likely due to being in a time where 'jihad' is now unfortunately synonymous with violence and terror. For me, to leave it out of the script is an intentional choice which shows that creators recognise their influences, yet choose not to highlight them on screen if it didn't serve an aesthetic purpose. Like, Dune can be Muslim, but not too Muslim.
This is by no means the only example, in the early chapters of Dune, Paul is gifted with a copy of the "Orange-Catholic Bible" by Dr. Yueh, and just as the title would, and as most things in Dune, it is a giant mutt of intermingled historical spiritual traditions.
@opticalpit We need more people to realise that the idea of a BBC is a racist stereotype perpetuated by the pornagraphy industry and is actively harming black men today
And yes this is true you literally just have to know the history of where that idea comes from and you can see why
With "incels" it's atleast just a joke, so called "normies" unironically believe in BBC and BNWO. It's such a weird discrepancy. Everyone assumes when you say anything about blacks you're comming from a place of sexual insecurity, but none of the same people would fuck a black.
Porn brained is the most hilariously moronic insult, modern society has an inherent pornographic bias and it doesn't even matter if you actually consume porn or not for it to express.