Everytime i see the "who shot first" discourse on TL i remember how even han solo's own actor doesn't give a fuck about it and is probably baffled that so many people care about this so much
What George meant by that statement is that the idea of a new generation of Skywalkers emerging existed both in his own imagination and in the EU — not that the characters and stories of the EU were canon to him.
Fans of the Expanded Universe cite this quote by George as if he considered the EU canon. However, according to "The Art of The Force Awakens", Vader's grandchildren in his version of Episode VII would have been Thea and Skyler, not Jacen and Jaina Solo.
George said more than once that the canon consisted only of his films and TCW, and that the EU was a "parallel universe" to his own.
But that is a lie I made up because I am ignorant.
*The fact that the Expanded Universe mentions TCW and vice versa doesn't make the EU canon.
@Gabriel1847835 This is a lie you made up for clout or out of lazy ignorance. TCW seasons 1 through 5 are part of the Expanded Universe. This is easily researched. The Gambit duology, No Prisoners, and Fate of the Jedi (EU novel series) all heavily reference events from TCW.
George's contributions to the 2003 series were minimal. He merely provided information on specific events and character concepts that were later reused in his films and in TCW. To him, the microseries served solely as a pilot for the 2008 series.
@Gabriel1847835 Dark Empire was written as a one-off continuation of the MARVEL comics from the 80s, dumbass. It was written BEFORE there even was an official EU, dumbass.
It is well known that George considered only his films and TCW to be canon, regarding his movies and the EU as "separate universes." So, there were distinct continuities at that time. Filoni didn't hijacked anything. Clone Wars MP was never canon to George.
I've wondered what exactly is mentally wrong with these people that have this fixation on the SW EU being canon. Lucas said many times that it was a separate entity, he said repeatedly that he didn't even read the EU books, so the topic is tedious because it's been answered since sometime in the mid-90s for anybody who cares to find out.
But there are many people like this guy who somehow find it important to spend their time online all day fighting about it. This guy's schtick it that, "George's actions speak louder than his words". Since anybody can find out what Lucas said on the topic, but what he said doesn't align with the alternate reality Brandon the Awesome wants to live in, Brandon spends time compiling evidence that he thinks shows that what Lucas meant is actually the opposite of what he said. He whips up infographics of quotes and reposts them incessantly. The thing is that, if you aren't a moron, you can see that none of the quotes he uses show what he's claiming that they show.
Lucas needed some more designs for background Jedi in AotC, so he looked around at some of the comics and things since those were designs he could use and had already paid for, and decided that he'd throw in a couple of them as extras. When he talks about this, he even refers to SW comics as "the comic book world" since he always considered those stories to be a separate world from his movies. But somehow throwing in an old design as a Easter egg means that he thought everything in the comics was canon? He obviously hadn't even read most of them.
Lucas did the same thing with Darth Talon- he wanted a female Sith for his ST story, he looked around at the work that had been done and liked some of the drawings of Talon, so he decided that maybe they could develop her. He wasn't interested at all with the story about her that was written in the EU, he either didn't know or didn't care that in the EU she exists a century after the time when he was going to put her in the story. He saw an image he liked and thought maybe he could use it for something else. This is how he always worked with concept artists for the movies, he would give them free reign to try a bunch of things, he'd look at it, some of it would spark ideas, some of it wouldn't. But just because he used a design, that doesn't mean that everything the concept artists designed was canon. It's extremely dumb to act like it does.
And even if recycling a design and putting it in the movie meant that he intended the EU version of that character to be canon- which it obviously doesn't because the movie versions aren't like the EU versions- but even if it did, Lucas did this all of three or four times in the history of SW, out of the thousands of characters the EU generated. The only two characters he really used at all were Aayla Secura and Darth Talon, which tells you that he's a big, big fan of Twi'lek chicks with bare midriffs, not of the EU.
Did Lucas sometimes offer an opinion on an EU story? Well yeah, if he even bothered to know about it. Did he sometimes nix an idea that he thought would be bad? Sure. That doesn't mean that everything he didn't nix, he personally approved of. There were several levels of management working at these companies, and sometimes if they weren't sure about something they'd run it up the ladder and get approval from Lucas. That's how these big companies work. It doesn't mean he was personally checking every single thing. That's impossible and ridiculous. He was paying hundreds of people to work on this stuff so that he wouldn't have to do it all himself.
I said at the beginning that this was tedious to talk about because it's not an issue with enough ambiguity that there's anything left to be debated. It's a question that's been answered. Now I'm kind of embarrassed I typed this much about it, but I've already typed it. The bigger question is why this matters at all to the Brandons out there. Who cares if it's canon or not? What does trying to argue about this prove for them? They're trying to validate their inner 12 year old who originally read the books and thought they were an official part of the story that they saw in the movies. If they hadn't been a fairly dim kid, they would have figured out the answer to that 30 years ago, but they didn't, so rather than admit that they haven't been able to figure out simple, observable things for 30 years, they try to prove that up is down and black is white. Posts like this actually aren't about SW at all, they're about Brandon's emotional problems. I hope you get the help you need, buddy
@Meranion_ Just because he allowed others to write his stories and his company benefited from it, that doesn't mean he had a moral obligation to follow a continuity that he had made very clear from the start wasn't his own. Two separate continuities can coexist.
George Lucas noticed that other people wanted to write their own SW stories and let them do so. He valued the EU but made it clear that those were other people's stories, not his own. He never contradicted them because they were not part of his continuity.
A mí esto siempre me ha hecho mucha gracia. Lucas permitió que otra gente crease historias en su universo y se benefició económicamente pero luego no les daba ningún valor y las contradecía cuando le daba la gana.
People treat what George Lucas and Dave Filoni did in TCW as disrespectful to the Clone Wars Multimedia Project, forgetting that they are two separate and distinct continuities. You don't see this same reaction regarding the Ultimate Marvel continuity.
Star Wars isn't the only franchise to do this. Star Trek, Doctor Who, and Dragon Ball also have their own non-canonical stories and universes. There is nothing wrong or strange with a franchise having separate yet coexisting continuities.