Let’s judge the modern Irish state using Pearse’s own standards:
“Centuries of oppression and of unsuccessful effort have almost extinguished the military spirit of Ireland: if that were once gone — if Ireland were to become a land of contented slaves — it would be very hard, perhaps impossible, ever to arouse her again”
“Will we be freemen, or are we content to remain as slaves and idly watch the final extermination of the Gael?”
“It is evident that there can be no peace between the body politic and a foreign substance that has intruded itself into its system: between them war only until the foreign substance is expelled or assimilated. Whether Home Rule means a loosening or a tightening of England's grip upon Ireland remains yet to be seen. But the coming of Home Rule, if come it does, will make no material difference in the nature of the work that lies before us: it will affect only the means we are to employ, our plan of campaign. There remains, under Home Rule as in its absence, the substantial task of achieving the Irish Nation. I do not think it is going to be achieved without stress and trial, without suffering and bloodshed at any rate, it is not going to be achieved without work. Our business here and now is to get ourselves into harness for such work as has to be done.”