@AgentLink99@LegoManPlastic@traderadio@rheem that's just not facts. cats got stengle (50+ goals in flag year) & smith (norm smith medalist) for free. jezza for 1st 3 rounders (none in top 10) is still unders. plus unders given up for bailey smith. pick 25 + other draft picks for esava is overs too.
@LegoManPlastic@traderadio@rheem fair enough re: smith. bevo didn't play him midifeld too last few years. realistically, what would cats offer for butters? 3 1st round picks from dogs over 2 years is still unders in my opinion. should be freijah and 2 1st rounderst to get to 75% market value at least.
@LegoManPlastic@traderadio@rheem missing the point mate. cats underpay for stars more than any other club. and expect overs for their own players. look at smith's 2021 finals campaign and tell me he wasnโt/isn't a star.
@FOXFOOTY can't have sicily being an afl captain. not his 1st time behaving like a sore loser after a final. dylan moore was stripped of VC role for a far less serious incident.
@BAFLD@AFL compare the price port & carlton pay for cochrane & walker this year. to pies with moore + daicos, brisbane with ashcroft brothers, dogs with darcy & jamarra etc etc etc. and see where the real stench is.
@Addyant23 end result for us is probably the best we can get. provided dogs take on marshall's remaining $. the 2 picks next year help us get pilot, salopek & rodan next year.
@anthonyalesiani@PAFC what are the dogs actually giving up here? pick 12 & future 1st for a top 10 player in the comp. are they even paying 100% of marshall's salary for remainder of contract in this proposed deal? they surely have to trade a star to get pick 6 to us.
@Addyant23@simo_pafc@RalphyHeraldSun probably just want draft picks this year and next year. to kick-start rebuild & help get pilot. plus maybe use them to get nas again next season.
@Addyant23 surely the narrative is this should biggest trade haul in history. given his age and injury history vs judd (OP), dangerfield & Cameron.
what should we get from dogs? for me, jones/freijah plus 3 top 10 picks (1 this year, 2 next year to help get pilot, salopek + rodan)
@PaulZauch our game plan revolved around him and hid his flaws. if moraes replicates form from last round and luko stays injury free, it's the worst trade of all time. even without this, berry + whitlock for houston is still a massive win for us.