because the christian and the atheist are using two different definitions of natural. the christian is talking about the natural capacities and order of a thing, meaning what its functions are naturally directed towards. the atheist is confusing this with an appeal to nature fallacy. the christian isn’t saying “because it’s unnatural, it’s bad”, he’s arguing that certain actions are contrary to the natural ends of our faculties and therefore contrary to the goods proper to human nature. you can disagree with the moral premises, but calling it an appeal to nature fallacy doesn’t refute the argument. natural has more than one meaning num nuts.
@MagnumP0TUS@Polymarket iran literally released a video showing how they would send robots and an attack plane over florida to kill trump while he is golfing lol. even if you hate israel, iran is just as bad and more open about their evils.
its the same church before and after 1546 and in 300-400ad. the early catholic church that hosted those councils submitted to rome. the authority has and always was the same catholic church. the early church and trent are not mutually exclusive catholic churches. also florence already established the exact same canon in 1442. there is no historical record of a discontinuity like you are implying.
@grok@SoWhatAaaand so @grok we can safely say the original post of the protestant is misunderstanding what he read, thinking he “owned” the catholics but really it was confirming what the catholic was asking?
@grok@SoWhatAaaand so @grok under this fact we can safely say that catholics canonized the bible and sola scriptura was not believed by the people who canonized the bible?
@dStoolofWisdom you’re missing 2 things:
1) Jesus was also fully human
2) Just because Jesus acted like he didn’t know doesn’t prove he didn’t know. He could also know that it’s better to play out history in this way.
@jeman_khan@modollars78@freemonotheist you need to learn history jews like jesus dont exist anymore they all became christians. the jews of today are creating a new book to follow after jesus went to heaven. islam was created by a jew manipulating a narcissist arab warmonger. he used him to get israel back
By “natural,” I mean the capacities and tendencies grounded in what a thing is, together with the characteristic ends toward which those capacities are ordered. You are using natural as “anything humans didn’t influence”. For a topic like this it would be weird to assume your definition. For example, the OP could have been talking about and I guarantee he was talking about the natural capacity that humans specifically are ordered. Making the entire discussion of what’s natural to another thing irrelevant because not all things have the name natural order. I would say all homosexuality is unnatural under my definition because it is contrary to nature with respect to the reproductive end.
yes, the post is saying that if something is “natural” it should be allowed and if something is not natural then it should not be allowed. the op also made it even more confusing by stating that humans and animals are no different, meaning what humans do is also “natural”. therefore homophobia is natural. obviously the entire argument is an appeal to nature fallacy, which is exactly why it falls apart so easily. its just a bad argument.
animals dont build technology so we shouldnt build technology? we do a lot of things they dont and we think in ways that you would agree are good and beneficial to society that animals dont. but on that subject, you are saying humans are animals therefore what humans do is also “natural” and therefore homophobia is natural.
@tangledupinme@greendragonhq@schmad23 it wouldn't be fair actually because horde and hive-minded big cities would still ultimately run the country. rural states would have virtually no say in an election.