@kangamerchant I feel like I’m going crazy with Colby, what is the appeal with him at HF? Routinely goes missing, off HB he can provide genuine speed, and the take of him being a defensive liability feels pointless when you have Daniel there
@SydneySwansHub Amartey is terrible and Ladhams is completely useless, please can we just run McLean as the ruck chop out with McDonald and curnow as the keys
@mitch23bates Genuinely this one totally depends on the outcome, as shit as that is, if Neale got a concussion it’s an automatic 3 weeks, but because he was fine it’s likely not gonna get much attention.
@didtheswanswin@sydneyswans Ladhams, Amartey, Cleary, Logan were especially horrific tonight, with the first 3 needing to be out of the team next week, putrid effort
@Bigdog2477@MattGrsaids@TheWorm_90 Again only played 2 games in the VFL last season, we were so injury ravaged last year, I don’t remember him specifically but he probably copped a couple throughout the year.
No issues with you guys having a pop, he is SA born, I just don’t think he’ll be cheap.
@Bigdog2477@MattGrsaids@TheWorm_90 What makes you think he’s a fringe player?
He went out of the team 3 weeks ago with an injury and is straight back in since recovering.
Played 19 games last year and 23 the year before that. He’d cost a hell of a lot more than a mid 2nd or late 3rd like is being proposed.
@charles_haig01 I was heartbroken when we lost him, but realistically at the time he was out of the side, he’s totally revived his career with the move and honestly, most swans fans are happy for him regardless of who it’s benefiting now.
@smorganism@fromthe_topdeck Would’ve been a brilliant feeling to see players’ careers like that with that added perspective. But which players do you believe he was clearly better than on my list and why?
I’m always up for a debate but I’m curious if the team you support is influencing your perspective.