In case you missed this ......
RE: FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025 - Nafiu Bala Gombe Vs ADC & Ors
Subject: GROUNDS WHY THE JUDGMENT PURPORTEDLY NULLIFYING SEN. DAVID MARK LEADERSHIP AND ATIKU ABUBAKAR'S CANDIDACY IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL, VOID AB INITIO AND LIABLE TO BE SET ASIDE ON APPEAL
1. LACK OF JURISDICTION - IT IS A NON-JUSTICIABLE INTERNAL PARTY AFFAIR
This is settled law in Nigeria up to the Supreme Court.
In Eyitayo Jegede v. INEC (2021) 14 NWLR PT. 1790 and APC v. Marafa (2019), and PDP v. Saka Lawal, the Supreme Court held that leadership, membership, and management of a political party is the exclusive internal affair of the party. No court has jurisdiction to determine who should be Chairman or Secretary of a party.
Nafiu Bala Gombe's claim is a leadership tussle arising from resignation of Ralph Nwosu. The Federal High Court cannot foist a Chairman on a political party. The ADC Constitution Article 14 and Article 15 clearly provides for NEC to constitute a Caretaker Committee where a vacancy occurs. That was what was done. The court cannot re-write the ADC Constitution for the party.
2. MISAPPLICATION OF THE ADC CONSTITUTION
The plaintiff relies on automatic succession as Deputy National Chairman. That provision is nullified by the fact that:
a) The entire NWC led by Ralph Nwosu resigned en bloc, not just the Chairman. There was no NWC left for a Deputy Chairman to preside over.
b) The ADC Constitution Article 18 (4) empowers the National Executive Committee [NEC] to dissolve the NWC and appoint a Caretaker Committee in an emergency.
c) The meeting that appointed Sen. David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola was duly convened by the BOT and NEC, the highest organs of the party, with over 90% attendance.
You cannot inherit what no longer exists.
3. CANDIDACY OF ATIKU ABUBAKAR IS PROTECTED BY LAW AND CANNOT BE NULLIFIED BY PROXY
Even if - without conceding - there was an issue with the Caretaker Committee, Atiku's nomination is saved by three layers of law:
a) Section 84 of the Electoral Act 2022:* Atiku emerged through a duly monitored Presidential Primary by INEC, with delegates, as required by law. INEC, the 2nd Defendant in that suit, monitored and published his name. A leadership dispute does not vitiate a primary conducted under Section 84.
b) The Principle in Eyitayo Jegede: The Supreme Court held that the irregularity of a party Exco does not invalidate the candidacy produced by the party. The candidate is not a party to the Exco dispute.
c) INEC Publication is Prima Facie Validity: INEC has already published Atiku Abubakar as the ADC Presidential Candidate for the Jan 16, 2027 election after verifying compliance with Sections 82-84 of the Electoral Act. Only the Federal High Court in pre-election matters under Section 285 (14) of the Constitution, initiated by an aspirant who participated in the primary, can challenge a candidacy. Nafiu Bala Gombe was NOT an aspirant. He has no locus.
4. FATAL DEFECT - NON-JOINDER AND LOCUS STANDI
Nafiu Bala Gombe lacks locus. He resigned/ceased to be a member of the NWC before this suit. You cannot challenge a party you are no longer an officer of for personal aggrandizement.
More importantly, Atiku Abubakar, whose candidacy is directly affected, was NOT joined as a party in FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025. You cannot nullify a person's nomination without hearing him. This violates Section 36 of the 1999 Constitution (Fair Hearing) and renders the entire judgment null and void.
5. FORUM SHOPPING AND ABUSE OF COURT PROCESS
There are at least 3 subsisting judgments of courts of coordinate jurisdiction affirming the David Mark leadership. The principle of stare decisis, and order of court means Lifu J. cannot sit on appeal over his learned brothers. The proper action is to go to the Court of Appeal, not to procure a conflicting judgment.
This judgment is a textbook case of judicial overreach into internal party democracy. It will not survive 48 hours at the Court of Appeal. It is:
@SadiqMaunde I’m just wondering what the point is of discussing all these issues now, when all the key indices affecting the lives of Nigerians are on a downward trajectory.
@NigEducation Because my child got admitted in one the institution and the management of the school is forcing us to to register him as a boarder, eventhough we cited health ground and proximity to the school. We are actually just a walking distance away from the school.
Pls I have a question, which i believe is bothering alot of parents whose children got admission into the Federal Government Colleges across the country.
Is compulsory for a child to be enrolled as boarding students or it is optional?
Pls someone @NigEducation should clarify.
@Uno_009 When they said YES, they were probably doing the bidding of someone who promised them automatic tickets. And now that they were obviously shortchanged, they will definitely make a U-turn.
It is said that the young man in the photo, named Ahmed Abdullah, was a pharmacist working in a pharmacy. Every month, an elderly poor woman would come to him for her medicine. She would then approach him at the cash register... Whenever she saw him, her face would light up with joy. For years, she had been buying this medicine, and this young man would only take 200 Egyptian pounds from her. She would pay and leave.
Then, the young man passed away... The elderly woman returned to the same pharmacy, requested her medicine, and went to the cash register to pay 200 pounds. But he was not there.
Before she could ask about him, the new cashier said: “What is this, madam?”She replied: “This is 200 pounds for the medicine.”He responded: “But this medicine costs 2,000 pounds, madam.”
Surprised, she said: “But for more than three years, I have been getting it for 200 pounds from the young man who was here... Where is he?”
The new cashier replied: “He passed away, madam. May God have mercy on him.” Upon reviewing the records, it was discovered that this young man had been covering 1,800 pounds of the cost every month from his own salary at the pharmacy.
When the pharmacy owner learned of this, he decided to continue selling the medicine to the woman at the same price as an ongoing charity (sadaqah jariyah) for the sake of the young man’s pure soul. The least we can do to honor this exemplary young man is to let his photo travel the world without stopping, so that everyone may pray for mercy upon him. He deserves recognition.
@AbbaM_Abiyos@woye1 So adding fertilizer to the list of banned items is right. However, the govt needs to put measures in place that will ensure the price of fertilizer is affordable to the farmers.
@AbbaM_Abiyos@woye1 Looking at the numbers, Nigeria has an installed production capacity of fertilizer of 16 million MT/Year and the actual local demand of around 2 million MT/Year. This makes us a net exporter of fertilizer. Though the price is still very high due to FX, Energy and logistics.
@ruffydfire This seems like a deliberate act of undermining the process of enacting laws in the country. And by extension rendering the legislative arm of government useless. And the tone the NASS is using to address this seeming attack on their on their legitimacy is even more worrisome.
@bayoadetunji@AObilana This is a basic level economics where producers always have ways of pushing the tax burden of indirect taxes to the final consumers. So, it doesn't have to be expressly stated in the law for it happen. Unless someone is being naive.
@woye1 If precedent is anything to go by, then I fear that this same tax reform may go the same way like the subsidy removal fraud.
We can all remember all the gimmicks about using the funds saved from the subsidy removal to improve the lots of Nigerians. And see now!
@AObilana I get that, so the consumers should sort themselves out since the government cannot stop dishing out policies that keep pushing the price level.