هناء Hanna

Algerian-British. Founder & CEO of @fearlessfutures. Brent is best. Educator. she/her. Views are mine and mine only. Rarely on twitter though.

[The Fraud @StarmertheFraud]

PAUL HOLDEN STATEMENT IN RESPONSE TO INTERVIEW WITH JOSH SIMONS ON BBC NEWSCAST

Yesterday, BBC Newscast published a lengthy, forty-minute interview with former Cabinet Minister Josh Simons MP. The interview addressed how Simons, as a director of @LabourTogether, had appointed a firm called APCO Worldwide to investigate me and my colleagues.

I was not told by the BBC ahead of the broadcast that the episode was being recorded or aired. I was not approached to respond to the lengthy comments made about me or the small anti-corruption organisation, @ShadowWorldInv1 , that I run with my colleague @andrewfeinstein. Andrew, who is also repeatedly mentioned, was also not approached for comment.

I only found out last night, when a friend texted me, that the person who hired a major multinational reputation management firm that produced a despicable and defamatory report on me and my colleagues, and who reported me on the basis of these false and defamatory reports to the UK’s security services, was being given forty minutes to give his version of events on a major podcast published by our national broadcaster.

To be clear, the BBC has NEVER - not once - approached me to comment on a story that is, ultimately, about me, my investigations, my family and my colleagues. They did not approach me when the story first broke, and they did not approach me for this episode.

If the BBC had done so, I would have raised several issues with the way in which matters related to me were discussed. For example, Simons repeatedly stated in the interview that he instructed APCO to investigate whether my reporting or sourcing derived from a ‘hack’ of the Electoral Commission. The word ‘hack’ is used eight times in the interview.

At no time was it acknowledged in this discussion that this allegation – that I might have received hacked materials – is entirely false, and I have repeatedly proven it to be false.

Following the broadcast, I contacted the BBC to complain and to raise serious issues with the broadcast. I was contacted by the Newscast editor, Sam Bonham, to say the BBC would update the Newscast episode and further reporting to reflect some of my concerns. This has not yet happened with regards to the podcast, although I note some online reporting finally reflects a very small and limited sampling of my comments. I will wait to see if amendments and updates will follow. If they do not, I will be escalating this matter to OFCOM.

In the interim, I have decided to share the full statement I provided to the BBC, which is produced below:

I would like to put certain things on the record.

First, my reporting on Labour Together and Morgan McSweeney was entirely factually accurate and based on impeccable, legal sourcing. My sourcing has been reviewed by multiple media outlets, who confirmed the authenticity and legal provenance of my sources. Revelations based on my book, The Fraud, has subsequently been covered widely across the mainstream media, including in multiple front-page scoops, in outlets such as The Times, Daily Mail, The Guardian, The National and ITV.

The stories I produced in 2023 and 2024, and which prompted Labour Together's investigation into me, were subject to extensive editorial and legal checks. They were, I believe, entirely accurate reporting on matters of profound public interest, which included raising concerns about the character of powerful individuals like Morgan McSweeney. Considering the recent Mandelson affair, I believe I have been entirely vindicated in attempting to alert the public about McSweeney's past, including how McSweeney made use of £700,000 in funding that he unlawfully failed to declare to the Electoral Commission to procure power and influence for himself and Sir Keir Starmer.

Second, Josh Simons states that he never intended for APCO Worldwide to investigate me or my journalistic colleagues. However, a copy of the contract between APCO Worldwide and Labour Together, addressed to Simons, has now been published. The contract sets out a scope of work written in plain English.

It states that APCO will 'investigate the sourcing, funding, origins of a Sunday Times article as well as upcoming works by authors Paul Holden and Matt Taibbi.' The contract then states that the aim of the APCO investigation will be to 'provide a body of evidence that could be packaged up in the media in order to create narratives that would proactively undermine any future attacks on Labour Together.' The contract then sets out a range of potentially invasive investigative methods that will be used to generate this 'package', including 'financial investigations' and 'human intelligence investigations.' I provide the full text of this contract below.

This contract is clear. APCO were hired to investigate me to produce materials that would 'proactively undermine' my factually accurate, public interest reporting. They would use a range of investigative techniques to do so. APCO then did exactly as was suggested in the contract, using these investigative methods to "investigate" me. This investigation has caused me and my family significant anxiety and distress.

Third, Josh Simons was provided with a report called Operation Cannon. It is the result of a lengthy investigation into me and my colleagues by APCO Worldwide. I have seen a copy of this report. It makes a series of extremely defamatory and utterly false allegations against me. It identifies my home address and sets out private information about my family. I cannot express how profoundly shocking, outrageous and defamatory this report truly is.

Simons may claim he never intended for APCO to investigate me, but on receipt of this despicable report, he then chose to use it. He submitted sections of the report to the National Cyber Security Centre to convince them to investigate me. The Guardian has published the email correspondence in which Simons repeated some of the substance of the allegations in the APCO reports.

Fourth, multiple media freedom advocacy organisations, including the NUJ, have strongly criticised the APCO investigation and these related matters. They have all, to my mind correctly, strongly criticised Labour Together and APCO for investigating journalists producing factually accurate reporting in the public interest.

Finally, I am still reviewing the Newscast interview. I will be responding in due course and I hope that the BBC will, this time, give me the platform to set out what really happened and why.

Text of Contract Between Labour Together and APCO Worldwide, addressed to Josh Simons

Dear Mr Simons

We are pleased that you have selected APCO Worldwide Limited (“APCO”) to provide the following scope of work (“services”) during Term:

APCO will devise a concise strategy to aid Labour Together. APCO will investigate the sourcing, funding and origins of a Sunday Times article about Labour Together, as well as upcoming works by authors Paul Holden and Matt Taibbi – to establish who and what are behind the coordinated attacks on Labour Together. The approach should provide a body of evidence that could be packaged up for use in the media in order to create narratives that would proactively undermine any future attacks on Labour Together. The material can also inform any future legal strategy that Labour Together might wish to pursue against any of these parties.

The work will include:

• Open Source Investigations (OSINT): Recovery and Preservation of Evidence
• Human Intelligence Investigation (HUMINT): Recovery and Preservation of Evidence
• Financial Investigation: Forensic Accounting Focus
• Digital Forensics Investigation: Recovery and Preservation of Evidence
• Stakeholder Outreach
• Media Packaging and Dissemination

[Jason Hickel @jasonhickel]

BREAKING: Today the Algerian parliament passed a law stating that “full and fair compensation for all material and moral damages caused by French colonisation is an inalienable right of the Algerian state and people”.

Unequivocal support for this.

[Raphael Dogg @raphaeldogg]

So... the people who currently pay no taxes will leave the country if we make them pay taxes, and we'll lose all the taxes that they don't pay.

No, let me try that again...

[Zack Polanski @ZackPolanski]

The Spectator are confused.

It's not going to be cost free.

Billionaires are going to pay more.

https://t.co/0qbagSvIYp

[Rivkah Brown @rivkahbrown]

Every single person who describes people who chant "death to Arabs" primarily in terms of their Jewishness, not their rabid ethnonationalism, is endangering Jews.

[Curtis Daly @CurtisDaly_]

Ash has a real gift of communication - she has the entire room listening intently, one of a kind.

[Novara Media @novaramedia]

“I do understand that this is inconvenient for you, but I’m afraid the charge of public nuisance is very serious.”

Activist Isobel Rock and a group of women from @CitizensArrestN just placed Mark Thurston, CEO of Anglian Water, under citizen’s arrest. They charged him with three counts of public nuisance, focusing on environmental damage and illegal sewage spills.

“I’m here to hold Mark Thurston to account for the crimes Anglian Water is committing everyday against our environment and pockets,” Rock said. “These water companies are ignoring environmental protections and are focused on shareholder profit making over public safety or keeping bills affordable.”

[Majid Freeman @Majstar7]

Remember when Saleh found that Palestinian boy lying on his mother’s grave at night?

He showed us their pain and strength, being our eyes and ears in Gaza. Through him, we felt their suffering and love. He inspired us all. What a beautiful soul. We’ll miss you, Saleh. 🌹💔😢

[AMANI @AmaniUniverse]

@QudsNen https://t.co/VJuhXMhEfi

[Quds News Network @QudsNen]

NEW | Instagram has removed the verified account of Gaza slain journalist Saleh al-Jafarawi, who had 4.5 million followers.

Archived snapshots of his page on the Wayback Machine, the largest public internet archive, also appear to have been wiped or disabled, raising concerns about digital erasure of Palestinian documentation.

Al-Jafarawi, known for his frontline reporting on the Gaza genocide, had previously faced repeated censorship. He was killed yesterday by an armed group collaborating with Israel.

Observers warn that these developments may signal “a new phase in efforts to erase evidence of Israeli war crimes from the internet.”

[EuropeanPowell @EuropeanPowell]

I hope at some point the wider public understands what's happening to the UK.
Big govt is being dismantled, governance powers are being outsourced to corporations hand over fist, who are in turn making serious incursions into critical public infrastructure.
Deregulated free zones all over the UK are hosting corporations at great expense to taxpayers with 90% profits going to the private sector.
This means for the next 25 years (the duration of free zone licenses) corporations are extracting State aid for profit motives, with 10 year tax holidays on top.
This aspect of UK state aid being used as profit motive is illegal in the EU, this is why Brexit happened.
So for the next quarter of a century the UK cannot rejoin the EU because their free zones policy deliberately contravenes the EU’s regulatory framework regarding State aid in free zones.
Corporate coup characteristics:
•Transfer of planning powers from democratic local authorities to “Mayoral Development Orders” and private sector-led boards
•25-year business rate retention deals that lock in revenue streams regardless of democratic changes
•Regulatory sandboxes that “enable regulatory experimentation and facilitate market entry”
•Trade union representatives “invited” to boards but not given statutory voice or veto

[The Resonance @Partisan_12]

“Do you think President Trump deserves the Nobel Peace Prize?”

Slovenia's President, Nataša Pirc Musar: “Francesca Albanese deserves the Peace Prize for this year”

[One-Dimensional Manning @TobyManning]

What Zack is paraphrasing (and exemplifying) is Raymond Williams' “To be truly radical is to make hope possible rather than despair convincing.” Naturally centrists are falling over themselves to fulfil their sacred duty towards the second part.

[Jonathan Cook @Jonathan_K_Cook]

1. The Starmer government has been repeatedly caught lying in claiming it has limited arms exports to Israel during the Gaza genocide. In fact, Ch4 finds there were record arms sales to Israel in June and September.

2. The only major group trying practically to stop arms exports – by targeting weapons factories in the UK – was Palestine Action. The Starmer government outlawed the group as a terrorist organisation in early July, just as the steep rise in arms sales was underway.

3. More than 2,000 people have been arrested so far on terrorism charges for peacefully protesting Palestine Action's proscription – as police forces repeatedly voice concern that resources are being overstretched to enforce the ban and normal policing is suffering.

4. The government has just announced further limitations on the right to protest, effectively letting the police decide which issues the public can protest. The police have already made clear that they want to stop protests against British government complicity in Israel's genocide, including on the matter of UK arms exports.

5. The bigger picture: All of this is being done to keep UK weapons flowing to Israel as it continues its annihilation of Gaza.

[Jesse Brenneman @Jesse_Brenneman]

My theory is that all the data centers being forced on us aren’t for future public demand, they’re for current military/govt demand—that AI is the backbone of the new surveillance state but they can’t say that so they pretend it’s because people love making videos of Pikachu.

[Owen Jones @owenjonesjourno]

I admit it: that’s the first time I’ve cried over a party political broadcast.

Years of fear, hate, insecurity, death.

This was like coming up for air

[Matt Kennard @kennardmatt]

NEW: A source very close to the senior leadership of MI6 has got in contact. They wanted to make public the opposition within the intelligence agency to the proscription of Palestine Action.

Senior figures are said to feel it is a distraction from the battle against real terrorist threat - and should never have happened.

The source has been verified.

[James Meadway @meadwaj]

Madness, absolute madness.

Hyperscale data centres typically are:
- hugely resource intensive (typical equivalence would be 30-50k homes’ water use)
- of limited impact on productivity
- create very few jobs
- depreciate rapidly - you’re building a white elephant.

Paper below

[Leah Goodridge @leahfrombklyn]

In case you haven’t heard:

Women are suing Pfizer in a class action lawsuit because the birth control shots (Depo-Provera) have been found to cause brain tumors.

1 in 4 women use this birth control. And Black women are prescribed it at double the national rate.