I love that you're trying some direct instruction. Will be watching to see how it goes... I wonder if you will land somewhere in the middle by using some di but still using other strategies and pedagogy that also work. The pendulum keeps swinging back and forth but I believe we need to stay in the middle.
“The parents aren’t doing their jobs.”
I agree. Too many parents are a hindrance to their own child’s education.
But under our current system, the school still has to serve their kids.
If we can teach them despite their parents, then we have work to do. If we can’t, we need to explain why we’re requiring them to spend their childhoods in buildings where, by our own admission, they aren’t going to learn anything.
Apparently, school is so essential that children must attend it, but so powerless that we can’t expect it to accomplish much unless their parents have already done everything right.
Perhaps you’re keeping them safe. Perhaps you’re making it possible for their parents to go to work. Those are useful services. They’re also services provided by a babysitter. They do not, by themselves, justify making attendance compulsory.
And the obligation has to run both ways. If a student persistently refuses to behave well enough to be taught, despite reasonable efforts to address that behavior, the school must be able to end that placement. We cannot require a school to keep a student who prevents everyone else from learning and then hold the school responsible for everyone’s failure to learn.
A school that cannot educate its students needs to be fixed. A school that cannot be fixed needs to close. A placement that provides no education should not be compulsory merely because we haven’t bothered to create one that does.
Bad parenting is a reason a child needs a functioning school. It is a piss-poor defense of a school that doesn’t function.
“The parents failed them first” is a remarkably poor argument for being allowed to fail them next.
For YEARS, I was told to “meet students where they’re at”…
…then, I was questioned about why so many students are behind and need an IEP before they’re working at several grade levels BELOW their current grade level.
Districts have dug us into a hole and they do t know how to get us out. We’ve created a culture of “meeting students where they’re at” with no actual plan to get them where they need to be.
Stop lowering the bar for our students! Raise the bar, provide support and explicit instruction and GET THEM TO WHERE THEY NEED TO BE!
Best presentation I’ve heard in years! Dr. Huggins is saying what every teacher has been too scared to say out loud for years!! @researchEDCan
There are several reasons:
Teachers are tired of having to defend low grades to parents, students, and admin when their colleagues just give out good grades.
Sometimes teachers are told by admin and district offices to make sure that students pass courses.
Students lack background knowledge and are unable to complete grade level work. 1 teacher cannot fix this in 1 year so just passes the students.
Grade inflation is a terrible problem, and people from every aspect of ed need to work together to fix it bc many high school graduates can barely read, write, or complete a math problem. And that affects everyone's futures.
@justinskycak A couple of weeks ago one of my teachers was teaching Alg 2 to 11th graders. Several of the students did not know what horizontal meant. 😠 How does this happen???
We have got to teach so that students learn to mastery (or least proficiency) at every grade level.
Yes, it's a major problem. I lead a virtual school that accepts students from 12 different high schools. An A at School A is not the same as an A at School B. It makes it difficult for students and teachers.
We need to do a lot of work with calibrating student work to fix this problem.
I really like your approach because it makes teaching professional and focuses on student learning. While having positive relationships with students can help, it is not essential to student learning. Students probably learn more from the tough demanding teachers than they do the friendly teachers.
We have to get away from focusing so much on relationships and shift to how do we get students to learn the most in school.
Excellent read. Yes, educators and all of those who influence the decisions that educators make need to be accountable. Educating students is the most important job there is, and we need to get it right.
“Let's just move on" isn't a plan. It's an escape hatch.
Kids didn't learn to read. Someone needs to say: We were wrong. Now that we know better, we're doing better.
@MissyPurcell says it perfectly 👇
https://t.co/5Nk4zZPSBy
#ScienceOfReading
Grade inflation is a hot topic right now. Read my new post to find a solution —- calibrating student work. How many of you have done this work? What did you learn from calibrating student work? How did it impact teachers’ instruction and student learning?
https://t.co/YYlOPfIhQA
@JamesAFurey You will win them over eventually. They might not appreciate your dedication and expertise for years to come, but at some point, they will appreciate you.
Just posted a new Substack that I hope many will read and give me some feedback. I am very concerned about education in America and hope to offer some solutions to the issues we face.
https://t.co/BTSGAVQc24
@rpondiscio
There's a lot of talk about whether we can trust PISA scores or not.
PISA is not the only international test. TIMSS & PIRLS are run by a different research group, and have a slightly different focus. They test reading, maths & science but with more of a focus on specific curriculum knowledge.
England is also the only country outside East Asia to come in the top 10 on all the TIMSS & PIRLS tests too.
More here.
https://t.co/YHjxkx0VP4
Teachers are at least partly responsible as they are the ones giving the grades. This is not the fault of parents. I agree that Superintendents and school boards are also at fault but I don't understand why you think teachers would be made scapegoats. I think most people understand that any problem in education is not the fault of one person or group; rather any issue is multifaceted and will take multiple solutions.
What are the most effective methods of improving student achievement? An NYT investigation.
For me, the data point in the bottom left quadrant is absolutely critical to understanding why student achievement goes wrong so often: teachers making up their own curriculum.
https://t.co/EOMK2kkwi9
Yes! School leaders and instructional coaches do NOT know everything. There should be a back and forth dialgoue during the feedback session that honors teachers' expertise and encourages them to share their perspectives. Also, I think that school leaders and instructional coaches should have to teach model lessons that teachers critique using video to increase understanding, analysis, and reflection.
When I was an elementary school princiapal, I used to argue with math "experts" who told me that it wasn't important for our students to learn their math facts backwards and forwards. I thought they knew more than I did so I let it go.
Looking back, I wish I would have dug deeper and stood my ground.
I think we can spot students who will be able to take high level math classes in high school... it's the 4th and 5th graders who know their math facts.
And only those few students will have the choice to become engineers, astronauts, surgeons, etc.,
Because when we don't ensure that 4th and 5th graders have mastered their math facts before they move on to middle school, it's exactly the same as not teaching them to read.
There are academics who have built their whole career on making the teaching of simple arithmetic unnecessarily complicated. Practice has been turned into a bad word in math & explicitly teaching is often something that’s supposed to be avoided. Children have suffered for it. Math has suffered for it.
Universities and academia are partly to blame by often rewarding the publication of flawed education research. The problem is that these academics can be hugely influential on curriculum, textbooks, teacher education, and professional development. Because who would think an education expert isn’t really an expert?
When someone has built their whole career on bad ideas, it’s going to be hard to get them to change course. That is why it is true that math needs a phonics-style revolution.