Keying

computer vision, deep learning

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@Haoquan03 是这样的，又要批评incremental，真的有novelty的时候又开始抓小放大，各种挑刺找茬

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@ylfu02 麻了，我这个1分说我严重缺乏相关工作对比，因此不能判断novelty

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@bose_joey I’m not sure if llm pre-reviewing really helps. I used gpt5.6 sol and Opus5.5 to review my paper, either gave Weak accept or weak reject. But humans reviewers gave me a clear rejection…

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@flyingpetal472 没事，keep moving on

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@HrrsMjd Interesting. Is it the ranking of the ratio of AI generation?

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@chhaviyadav_ very mean indeed

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@KaishenWang_tt More random seeds, statistical significance test. Most likely to be AI generated reviews.

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@KaishenWang_tt Their submissions should be desk rejected due to not fulfilling their duties

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@pratzohol @NeurIPSConf The same.

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@chanwoopark20 Can’t agree more

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@sidgairo18 Same condition. It seems like acknowledging the limitations might invite more criticism, and some AI-generated attacks

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@itayevron how about 432

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@CSProfKGD yes, it just copied the comments from three reviewers without reflecting ac’s own opinion，or making minor revisions on the adjectives that reviewers had used to describe the work

[Keying @Keyingkarras]

@EzgiKorkmazAI @iclr_conf really amazing!