Okay. Well since you asked... Buckle up.
Our poisoned chalice of Right to Manage.
"Well, have you thought about Right to Manage (RTM)?" I get asked this so many times, and with good intentions.
So you're struggling with excessive service charges and poor management, so why not? I've put off addressing it because the situation with our building is considerably more complicated than it might first appear.
On the face of it, RTM sounds perfectly reasonable. Take control away from the housing association, appoint our own contractors, scrutinise expenditure and make decisions in the interests of the people who actually live here.
But what happens when the problem isn't simply poor management?
In our case, we'd be taking responsibility for a Grade II listed Victorian building with serious, longstanding problems involving the roof, recurrent issues with damp, the cellar and deteriorating original fabric. Problems that were never properly addressed when the building was converted into apartments and sold as modern homes.
And that's a crucial distinction. We bought modern conversions within an older building, reasonably assuming that the same diligence applied to the new accommodation had also been applied to the Victorian structure housing it.
The surveys commissioned by purchasers did not cover vast areas of the communal building. And therein lies another problem: the residential accommodation actually represents a relatively small proportion of the overall structure we're now financially responsible for maintaining.
The enormous roof, the cellars, the communal spaces and the original fabric all require maintenance, regardless of how much of the building is actually occupied by our homes.
When a surveyor visiting my flat candidly remarks that the building should never have been converted into homes in the first place, it raises some profoundly uncomfortable questions. Particularly when you consider how much of the original Victorian structure was left untouched.
These aren't simply routine maintenance issues. They're the legacy of a conversion that left enormous future liabilities embedded in the building itself.
And RTM wouldn't make any of those problems disappear.
We'd gain control over management, certainly, but we'd also inherit the responsibility for organising repairs, collecting service charges, managing contractors and finding the money to keep an increasingly expensive building functioning.
I can almost imagine the housing association rubbing its hands together.
"Go on then. Knock yourselves out. One less headache for us."
Of course, RTM wouldn't automatically absolve the housing association of existing legal obligations or liability for historic defects. But it could leave leaseholders carrying the practical and financial burden of managing problems they neither created nor knowingly agreed to inherit.
Worse still, it could turn neighbours against one another. Instead of challenging the housing association over unaffordable bills, we'd potentially find ourselves issuing those bills to each other.
We already experienced how difficult collective financial responsibility can be during our First-tier Tribunal case. Even raising the money for legal representation became a bone of contention. Many leaseholders who had signed up to challenge the freeholder simply didn't have the money readily available when it was needed.
That wasn't a lack of commitment. It was the financial reality of ordinary people already struggling with the costs of their homes.
Now imagine those same neighbours having to agree on, fund and administer potentially hundreds of thousands of pounds in future repairs.
RTM can be a valuable solution where the fundamental problem is inefficient or exploitative management.
But what if the fundamental problem is the building itself?
We didn't buy an unfinished restoration project. We bought what we believed were completed homes, with modest and manageable service charges.
Now we're being asked to finance the consequences of decisions made long before we understood what we'd inherited.
We can challenge the charges. We can fight over management. We can take control of the administration.
But none of that changes the condition of the building or the enormous cost of putting right what should arguably have been diligently addressed before the first flat was sold.
If anyone with relevant legal expertise feels they could help us navigate this predicament, or identify avenues we may not yet have explored, please do get in touch by DM. We would be genuinely grateful for any informed guidance.
بالنسبة إلى الله، كلُّ يومٍ هو يومُ الطفل.
وكلُّ من يقتل الأطفال، سيأتي يومٌ يواجه فيه جزاءَ أفعاله، في هذه الدنيا وفي الآخرة.
🗓️🎒 20 نوفمبر
اليوم العالمي للطفل
The Imperial Propagandists Are Exposing Themselves Like Never Before
"Now is an excellent time to awaken the public to the fact that the western news media function as propagandists for the US empire."
Reading by Tim Foley.
Killing that clown would be the single dumbest move the Kremlin could make.
The West would turn him into a martyr overnight, complete with a halo, a Hollywood biopic, and a standing ovation.
No, keep him alive.
Let him stick around for the grand finale of his own tragic circus.
He should be made to answer for what he has done to his country: the reckless escalation, the sabotage of peace, the consolidation of power, and the transformation of the state into a mafia-run enterprise where criminal gangs and neo-Nazi militias call the shots, while men are hunted down like stray dogs and shipped off by the thousands to die at the front against their will.
Zelensky should live long enough to face the consequences of his actions — preferably from behind bars.
After all, why make a martyr out of a man when you can let him live to see his own political obituary?
A prison cell would make a far more fitting final act than a state funeral.
Tell me an MP's stance on Gaza, and I can almost guarantee I can tell you where they stand on climate change, disabled people's rights, immigration and just about every other issue that demands a shred of humanity, compassion or empathy.
IT'S ALWAYS THE SAME FUCKING ONES.
And that tells you an awful lot about the values driving British politics.
Labour should be asking how we make all jobs less shit: better pay, stronger protections and a greater share of profits going to workers rather than capital. Instead, it tells young people to accept any job, however shit.
Labour is dead. Burnham ain't bringing it back.
Israel just bulldozed one of the most prosperous Palestinian farms near the Jordan Valley area
This farm feeds 10,000s of people, and is a prominent source of food in the area
The vast majority of the UK population couldn't give a flying fuck about supporting the Zelensky regime. We would rather spend the money on domestic issues.
This waxy-faced pet shop arsonist cunt can get fucked, along with NATO, the EU and all the other warmongering cock suckers.
#MilburnReview
Cutting Health Element UC & PIP for disabled people 18-24 is a direct attack on young disabled people’s lives. This is about cuts. The result of these social security cuts?
Benefit Sanctions
Poverty
Homelessness
Deaths
many will die as a result
Callous
أجاب السنياتور عبد الرحمن السيد بطريقة ذكية للغاية على سؤال: 'ما هو ردك على شخص يأتي إليك ويقول: "حسنًا، أجد أن انتقاداتك لإسرائيل تؤجج مخاوفي من معاداة السامية"؟'
وقد نال رده الاحترافي والذكي إشادة واسعة من الكثيرين الذين تمنوا لو أنه كان في منصَب الرئيس
إحابة السيد:
" آسف لمخاوفك. من الواضح أنني لا أريد فعل أي شيء يغذي خوفك. في نهاية المطاف، هناك فرق بين الأمان (أو غياب الأمان) وبين الشعور بالراحة. إذا كان ما أقوله يجعلك تشعر بعدم الارتياح، فينبغي عليك أن تشعر بعدم الارتياح إزاء الظلم الذي يُرتكب بحق أشخاص آخرين. يجب أن يسبب لك ذلك عدم الارتياح.
إن التعامل مع مسألة الأمان ومسألة عدم الارتياح هما أمران مختلفان تمامًا؛ لأنه إذا كان شعورك بعدم الارتياح و/أو الخوف هو ما يجب أن يبقيني صامتًا بينما أشاهد 70,000 شخص يُقتلون، ومنازلهم تُباد، ومستشفياتهم تُدمَّر... ولا أستطيع انتقاد ذلك، فأعتقد أن ما تقوله لي هو أن إنسانيتهم أقل أهمية من إنسانيتك. وأنا لن أقبل بذلك."
Debunked 🚨
@LucyAJackson_ explains just how many young people are in receipt of disability benefit payments
She describes the media's approach to this narrative as 'abhorrent' on this week's Media Watch
Margaret Thatcher famously declared "THERE IS NO ALTERNATIVE."
It became the defining justification for decades of neoliberal economics, privatisation, austerity and the systematic transfer of wealth and power upwards.
But today, that argument is even more indefensible.
BECAUSE IT IS BLINDINGLY OBVIOUS THAT THERE IS AN ALTERNATIVE.
We live in a world where wealth is concentrating into fewer and fewer hands, where governments bend over backwards to accommodate multinational corporations, subsidise private investment and facilitate the enormous energy demands of Ai and data centres.
We live in a dystopian world where unimaginable wealth can accumulate in the hands of the few, while billions, and I do mean billions, worldwide struggle to afford the basics of life.
And yet, somehow, we're being told that the great economic problem we must urgently solve is the cost of supporting sick and disabled people.
That the answer is to strip financial security from vulnerable young people, while handing public money to private employers in the hope they'll offer them work.
WHAT AN ABSOLUTELY PERVERSE SET OF PRIORITIES.
And perhaps most disturbing is how readily much of Parliament and the mainstream media have accepted the premise that welfare spending is the problem, rather than questioning the economic system creating so much insecurity in the first place.
The #MilburnReview could have been an opportunity to fundamentally rethink how we create opportunity, security and prosperity for the next generation.
Instead, we're once again debating how much support we can take away from those who have the least.
BUT THERE IS AN ALTERNATIVE.
We could tax extreme wealth fairly. Invest in universal public services, education, healthcare, housing and genuine opportunities for young people.
We could build a regenerative economy that creates and circulates wealth within our communities, rather than continually extracting it, concentrating it and siphoning it upwards.
We could confront the structures that allow trillions in global wealth to accumulate while public services are starved of investment.
And we could start measuring economic success by human and planetary wellbeing, rather than simply how much profit can be extracted.
THE MONEY EXISTS. THE RESOURCES EXIST. THE ALTERNATIVES EXIST.
What's missing is the political willingness to challenge those benefiting most from the status quo.
So please, @andyburnham, @UKLabour, spare us the Thatcherite bullshit that there is no alternative.
There is. And stripping away the dignity and security of sick and disabled people is a political choice. Not an economic inevitability.
@ZackPolanski@TheGreenParty
I've been skimming through the Milburn Review, and I genuinely struggle to comprehend the sheer SHORT-SIGHTEDNESS of what's being proposed.
And, of course, @Helen_Whately, below, is already salivating at the prospect of slashing sickness benefits, like some sadistic accountant who sees human suffering as an opportunity to balance the books.
But let's look at what's actually being proposed...
We're talking about fundamentally restructuring the welfare system for under-25s, stripping disabled young people of vital financial support, while simultaneously handing taxpayers' money to private employers to incentivise recruitment.
And here's the staggering part.
Employers receiving the government's £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant are NOT required to retain employees for any minimum period.
They're not even required to demonstrate they've created an additional job!
This is one enormous WEALTH TRANSFER.
Taking financial security away from some of the most vulnerable people in society, while funnelling public money towards private employers without sufficient guarantees of sustainable employment.
So what exactly are WE being asked to fund?
Genuine pathways out of poverty? Or a revolving door of subsidised employment, with vulnerable young people potentially dumped straight back into unemployment and financial insecurity?
And those who genuinely can't work? Are we simply prepared to push them further into poverty from the outset?
WHERE THE FUCK IS THE ACCOUNTABILITY?
What happens when the subsidies end?
How many of these young people will still be employed in 12 months? Two years? Five years?
We're talking about the future of an entire generation, yet still confusing short-term corporate initiatives with the fundamental economic transformation that's desperately needed.
And perhaps most absurdly, why should a disabled 24-year-old receive fundamentally different financial protection from a disabled 26-year-old?
Does their disability suddenly become more expensive at 25? Does their rent change? Their food bills? Their need for dignity and independence?
OF COURSE IT FUCKING DOESN'T!
Yet we're contemplating a system that transfers financial security away from vulnerable young people, while directing public money towards employers without adequate guarantees of lasting employment.
This is the fundamental problem with treating welfare primarily as a COST to be reduced, rather than social protection that allows people to live with dignity.
Where's the long-term vision?
Where's the investment in genuinely sustainable employment, education, healthcare, infrastructure and an economy that creates opportunities for EVERYONE?
Where's the commitment to protecting those who simply cannot work?
Instead, we're in danger of weaponising poverty as an incentive to force people into employment, while rewarding businesses for offering opportunities that will most likely disappear as soon as the financial incentives do.
A functioning welfare state protects people from poverty.
A functioning economy provides meaningful opportunities.
WE NEED BOTH.
Otherwise, we're not fixing the crisis. We're simply recycling it, at an enormous human cost.
And politicians celebrating the prospect of cutting support for vulnerable people should seriously question what the hell they've come into politics to achieve.
#MilburnReview
@ZackPolanski@TheGreenParty@andyburnham@UKLabour
Don't you mean YOUR moral compass.
My moral compass was just fine Andy.
It was the likes of you and Ed Miliband who kept quiet while Keir Starmer cheered this genocide on.
So speak for yourself mate.
Saudi warplanes bombed the Al-Kholani sponge factory in Hodeidah today and resumed bombing civil defense rescue teams, resulting in martyrs and wounded among the ambulance, rescue, and civil defense teams, as well as injuries to the Yemen TV crew.