Dead Land Deal Series #1
We had 29.4 acres under contract in Grand Junction, Mesa County, CO listed at 425k, and I thought it was a typical minor double or just under a double, which would have been our first minor in the western US.
The plan was five lots at about 6 acres each, and I had it at a conservative 250k a lot for 1.25m gross since 30 acres of irrigation shares came with the sale and 5 acre parcels like that to the northwest were selling at 300k to 325k.
We went under contract with 4k down and DD ending January 20.
The percs were fine, and I'd never had a water issue on a parcel before so it wasn't even on my radar, until I found out the line in the road was only 2 inches and the one to the north was 3 inches, which meant to split it we had to upsize about 2,200 feet to 6 inches and put in hydrants at our cost. The engineer priced it at 209k which was far more than we expected which began to make the project seem unfeasible.
There was still money to make even with the water costs that high, but the new line had to tie into an 8 inch line another developer was supposed to install and I couldn't get a timeline out of them, so that was an unknown variable we couldn't take a risk on.
Then the county retracted after telling us 5 lots was fine. They called in mid-January and said it might only be a single split, and on January 21 the city confirmed we'd only get one additional lot. Thankfully we had an extension on our DD.
I asked for the 4k back the next morning and we signed the termination January 24.
Convoluted water line extensions, county split retractions, irrigation rights, all new territory for us at the time. Great lessons for the future.
Most people think a rural 10 lot minor split is a 2 month payday
I said that myself the day after I closed on 80 acres in Jackson County FL for 220k, which is about 2.8k an acre, and I financed it with a local credit union for 165k, and they made me park another 11k at closing for future loan payments, so cash to close was 73,041
The plan was a 2 month plat and a property worth about 500k once it was cut into 10 lots, but the plat wasn't approved until November, about 10 months after I bought the dirt, and I couldn't close a single lot until that plat was on the books
Sales started in January 2025, a year after the purchase, and the first two were 5 acre pieces at 35k each, and the lender took 15k of the net from each one under a 50/50 split after commissions and costs, so I netted 14,861 on the first and 15,189 on the second
Lots 3 and 4 closed together in April 2025 for 70k and 30k of that went to the loan, so I netted 30,765
Lot 2 closed in July 2025 for another 35k and the entire sale went to a 30,118 loan payoff plus commissions and title, so I netted zero on that one
Lots 6 and 8 closed together in August 2025 for 95k, and 68,697 of that paid the loan off and I netted 14,280, which released the mortgage on the rest of the lots
Lot 9 closed in January 2026 at 70k and I netted 57,801 after 7k in commissions and 3,249 in 2025 taxes, and Lot 7 closed in February at 70k and I netted 60,466
That's 9 of 10 lots sold for 410k gross and 193,365 back to me after commissions, costs and the lender payoffs, and I'm into it for about 86k once you count the cash to close, about 4,400 in plat and traffic work and about 1,100 a month on the loan for 18 months, so profit so far is about 107k and the last 16.52 acres is listed at 80k
Here's what most people get wrong, and what I got wrong on this one
1. Treating plat time like a calendar you can set at the closing table. I said 2 months the day after I bought it and it took until November, and no lot closed until that approval landed
2. Thinking the tax bill stays simple after you split the land. Early lots had tax prorations of 15 to 226 dollars and then Lot 9 alone took 3,249 in 2025 taxes out of a 70k sale
3. Taking all the sale proceeds and leaving the loan sitting on the rest of the lots. The 50/50 split, then a sale that zeroed out Lot 2, then 68,697 from Lots 6 and 8 is what paid off a 165k loan so the later lots could close clean and put 118k in my pocket on just two sales
4. Assuming a rural minor split is just a survey and a recording fee. The plat work was 2,500 plus 1,137 for revisions, and the traffic exemption letter was quoted at 2,000 and I paid 750 after a courtesy discount, and the county still ran it through a public hearing
You can't sell the cut lots until the plat is approved, and in Jackson County that isn't a 2 month rubber stamp even when you already own 80 acres on existing roads. I bought in January, submitted the plat package in May, had a public hearing in November and got approved that month, and until then the 220k just sat
What I'd do again on the next one
- Underwrite plat time as a real hold. I bought January 31 2024 and didn't close a lot until January 24 2025
- Get the payoff mechanics in writing before the first lot closes. 50/50 of net after commissions and costs with a partial release on each lot is what we used until the loan was gone
- Budget commissions and taxes as real dollars. The 9 lots had 41,900 in commissions and marketing
- Be ready for a sale that pays the loan and not you. Lot 2 was 35k gross and 0 to me
- Carry adds up. About 1,100 a month for 18 months is about 19,800 before the loan was gone
If you're a private lender or a JV partner and want into the next one, the link is in my bio
Florida major subdivisions have costs people tend to skip in the pro forma.
On gopher tortoises, we pay $7k per turtle for relocation to a reserve, and this cost keeps going up. I've had sites with hundreds of GTs. That's the norm on large Florida tracts.
If you're funding a FL deal and the budget doesn't have a line for this, you're not looking at the real deal. Same with wetlands, off site work requirements, and soils analysis. I've had projects with hundreds of thousands of yards of unsuitable soil that were expected to be used to balance the site. Instead it was an import change order of over 1 million.
The early work isn't the closing. The work is everything that happens at due diligence and entitlement. Doing the horizontal infrastructure is a whole other ball game.
Lessons:
Price to sell, not to hope
Get the split survey done early. Our lender first read the lot release as half an acre
Interest is a real cost. Ours was $26,910
The first price cut is the cheapest one.
What would you have done about the pig farm?
If you'd rather post one tweet instead of the thread:
Bought 25 acres in Florida for $360k.
Split it in two.
Sold one lot for $275k and the other for $245k.
Next door: a pig farm.
After interest, commissions, clearing and every closing cost: $54,104 profit on $70,746 of peak cash.
Price cuts sold it, not patience.
We bought 25 acres in Florida for $360k.
Split it into two 12.55-acre lots.
Sold one for $275k. Sold the other for $245k.
Half of it is wetland. The neighbor runs a pig farm.
Here's every number, including the ones that hurt 🧵
Hill I'll die on - sleep training is bullshit. You're forcing the baby to mold to your schedule during extremely formative years. Most of the rest of the world co sleeps. We put our kids to sleep in our bed before we go to bed and then my wife and I get in later. I'll never regret squeezing between them to snuggle every night.