@SevenSheeps keep in mind a lot of the submissions this cycle were AI slop. if you remove those papers from the pool, leaving only the papers that actually maintained a standard of scientific integrity, perhaps the acceptance rate would still look similar to what it has been in the past
@OliverKamm@mrkkat2@MerriamWebster Idk who you're hanging out with but I still know legion otherwise talented and well-read people who revere S&W and other such language authorities whose pronouncements are at odds with descriptive facts
I'm really going to miss Opus 5. Every model has had its quirks ("You're absolutely right!"), but Opus 5 was serving up chicken fried tokens like none other. I did my best impression of the Opus 5 dialect of Claudish in the Opus 5.5 announcement thread on HN. Ubi sunt!
@mattyglesias if you're talking about why it's 5.5 and not 5.1: that's because ai companies have accepted that the public processes this as "halfway to 6" rather than "minor version 5 of opus 5" and have stopped trying to do version numbers with them
TMLR has faced a deluge of submissions, necessitating stricter desk rejection policies due to limited reviewer capacity
Co-EiC Nihar Shah reached out to authors of 10 papers slated for desk reject. Could they answer questions about their *own* submission?
https://t.co/vhX5w6gcx2
@tallinzen before AI my philosophy was that if i leave a bad review then i need to be very careful to explain why, but when i review slop now idk what to do. Do you just outright say "this is clearly slop" or what?
ACL Sustainable Reviewing Policy: We are introducing changes in the @ReviewAcl reviewing and submissions. The changes will cap authors and introduce changes in the reviewing to keep our community sustainable. #NLProc
made the mistake of asking claude to proofread an email in which i described claude output that i had not reviewed as potential "slop" and claude got really really mad at me
@jaycaspiankang 2. a wordle-esque daily challenge where everyone sees the same questions and the results are somehow shareable would be fun so you can tell your friends how dumb they are for missing #7 etc.
@jaycaspiankang this is awesome, replying because i can't dm you:
1. it'd be interesting if you posted either the exact prompt or just some key details somewhere so we can know what the process is like