@Samantha1111X@jk_rowling JKR has never stood against single-use facilities available to everyone of every sex and gender. But single-use facilities as a safe alternative are considered discriminatory and invalidating by trans advocates.
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling I'm not confused at all.
A trans woman is someone who identifies as a female but was labeled male at birth.
A trans woman is a biological male who personally believes he is a woman.
Both statements are true. Neither makes a trans woman a woman.
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling -then transitioning physically doesn't make a trans woman MORE of a woman, and not transitioning with cross-sex hormones and/or surgery doesn't leave her less of one.
Womanhood is either biology based or self-identity based; it can't be defined both ways without contradiction.
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling Why can she? Where does "can" come from, here? And why must anyone else?
"And transition materially changes that body . . ."
And here you materially fall into what trans maximalist positions considers a heretical position. If gender-identity determines gender and sex--
Cont.-
@BrainsinNo@navyon3@jk_rowling "A woman is an adult person whose gender identity corresponds to the category associated with female sex." You begin by assuming the premise.
The counter is "A woman is an adult human female."
One assumes identity = gender. The other assumes that biology does.
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling "Saying “sex-based rights” louder doesn’t supply the missing argument."
Neither does saying "Trans women are women. Explain the basis on which they should be excluded from women's sports, facilities, programs, etc."
But the answer is: "Because they aren't women."
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling “Invalidated to death” is a proper dig at trans people's claim that automatic validation is their right and that to not agree they are the sex/gender they say they are is to "invalidate them," and to see being "invalidated" as a literal attack on their humanity and existence.
@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling Anyone with "antinatalist" in their tag forfeits the right to be taken seriously, but I do see some serious answers below. I'd hope you found them enlightening, but nobody ever gets their minds changed by these X exchanges. We're just throwing our convictions at each other.
@LGBTQPrideUK@jk_rowling@bindelj Obsessed? Oh I doubt she spends more than a few minutes a day keeping up with the issue and occasionally posting on it. Certainly nothing like the hours she spends grinding out her next story. 😋
@miroirdufou@Sillyshib@jk_rowling Q: Are there sex-based rights?
A: "Yes, sex-based rights refer to legal protections that allow for single-sex services and spaces based on biological sex. These rights enable organizations to provide services specifically for women or men when necessary for safety or privacy."
@HilllbillyHugs@jk_rowling At this point I think each of us understands where the other stands on the issue, which is about all one can hope for in X exchanges. So for all its snarkiness, perhaps it's done it's job.
Have a good weekend.
@HilllbillyHugs@jk_rowling Their argument runs that sex/gender isn't determined by genes, gonads, or secondary sex characteristics at all but by self-identity. Which brings us back to the beginning of the discussion and your quote which focuses on neurological differences and elides the rest.
cont.-
@HilllbillyHugs@jk_rowling Hormone Replacement Therapy does not change someone's sex, even if begun pre-puberty. But now you're falling into the argument denied by trans-advocates; conditioning sex upon phenotype at birth or later. Their argument? Sex/gender isn't determined by phenotype at all.