@BrainsinNo@ShanNeal57 We don't need to show "comparable risk profiles" for males who "identify" as women to justify excluding them from women's intimate spaces, any more than we need to show that for any other subset of the male population. ALL adult males are excluded.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch@grok Yet again, you're trying to refute a claim I DIDN'T MAKE.
What I did say, correctly, is that YOUR CLAIM that crime data "prove" that trans-inclusive bathroom laws do not cause any increase in sexual and violent crimes is FALSE.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch@grok There is no "backpedaling." You keep claiming that I wrote things I didn't write, and then trying to refute those non-existent statements. I can only assume you keep doing this to try and distract attention from the fact that you cannot refute the statements I DID make.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch@grok I didn't say that "public restrooms normally enforce chromosome or ID checks at the door" or that a male predator could not "already physically walk into a restroom before trans non-discrimination laws existed"
I don't know why you keep trying to refute claims I never made.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch@grok Yet another irrelevance. I DIDN'T CLAIM that the NCVS is evidence that "trans-inclusive restroom laws caused any rise in unreported restroom crimes." I said YOUR CLAIM that there was no increase is not supported by the evidence you cited.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch No, I literally contradicted your "point." Making it easier for male sexual voyeurs to access spaces where women's private parts are exposed is likely to increase the rate of such crimes, and the vast majority of them may never be detected.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch "If 1 in 4 incidents get reported and assaults actually went up, the reported 24% would go up tooβbasic math!"
More nonsense. Show us your evidence that these laws had no effect on the rate of unreported crimes in women's public restrooms.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch We don't need to "imagine" it. We have clear evidence of it, both from studies of the prevalence of voyeurism by men and from cases where the voyeur was detected and prosecuted. All a man needs to do is hold a mirror or his phone under the stall partition.
@HCarry94693@pynkchola@thot_crime@___TheGOOdWitch "The data conclusively proved..."
The data can't prove there was "no increase in crimes, safety violations, or sexual assaults" because of both unreported crimes and unidentified crimes (undetected voyeurism).
@MGH2026@BrainsinNo@jk_rowling Yes. But @BrainsinNo defines "woman" in terms of a "social category" defined as "how people are recognised, addressed and situated in relation to expectations historically organised around female bodies." That is, expectations about clothing, hairstyles, makeup, names, etc.
@BrainsinNo@Yerune_D The risk of women being harmed through a policy of unrestricted access by males to women's facilities is vastly greater than the risk of trans women being harmed through a policy of excluding them from women's facilities.