What happened today is very important. @thetimes has published a story, reporting that the Metropolitan Police is investigating the sale of a hotel by a bank's property arm. I believe it could set a precedent for other small businesses that dealt with the same bank unit. Andy Agathangelou of the @TransparencyTF shares that view and says a case like this, if won in court, could be followed by others.
16 years. That is how long Chris RIchardson has been fighting over what happened to his business and the Coniston Hotel in Kent.
He lost in the civil courts. His complaint to City of London Police was closed. Over the years he was told, in one form or another, that the matter was finished.
It was not finished.
The Metropolitan Police is now investigating his allegations of fraud. Detectives have sought a High Court production order to get documents from the bank about its 2011 purchase of the hotel. The Times reports it. There have been no arrests or charges so far.
Here is the background, so nobody gets lost.
The Coniston Hotel near Sittingbourne went into administration in 2010. Its bank was RBS, now part of NatWest Group. The bank's Global Restructuring Group, known as GRG, handled the case. Then West Register, the bank's own property arm, bought the hotel. The hotel went on the market for £3.9M and West Register won the bidding with £4.2M in cash. NatWest says that was the highest of six bids in an open process run by Knight Frank.
The interesting part?
In 2018 a regulatory investigation commissioned by the Financial Conduct Authority looked at GRG. According to The Times, it found the Coniston case was an extreme example of West Register helping to shape GRG's approach to individual cases. It found meeting minutes recording that a West Register representative talked down the value of the hotel in a discussion with the bank, insolvency practitioners and valuers before the Coniston entered insolvency. It found West Register was in a position to influence key people before a strategy was decided, and in its view did so..
So the bank's own property arm took part in the discussion about what the hotel was worth, and then bought the hotel. Nothing unusual there, apparently.
The same review found that GRG, set up to turn struggling companies around, systematically mistreated many of them after the financial crisis. It found GRG targeted them for fee extraction and even reacquired their assets for itself. A turnaround unit that mistreated the businesses it was meant to rescue. Impressive work.
Then .. the records.
The Times reports that Promontory, which carried out the work for the FCA, has destroyed documents. The bank still holds them. Detectives want documents including the meeting minutes behind the review's conclusions. So the police now have to ask the bank for what the regulator's own reviewer has reportedly destroyed. A tidy arrangement for everyone except the customer.
Chris Richardson says the courts and City of London Police never had access to the Promontory documents the Met is now asking for. By his account, he spent 16 years trying to prove his case without them. He says the fight has taken a devastating toll on his health and put his family under unimaginable strain.
Here is NatWest's position.
It says it will co-operate fully with the production order. It says courts have considered and dismissed the allegations many times and that City of London Police found no basis for them..
Chris Richardson says those courts and police never had access to the Promontory documents the Met is now asking for. If he is right, every earlier dismissal was reached without that evidence. It says the Promontory review found no evidence of properties being bought at a price clearly below market value. In 2014 the Court of Appeal found there was no evidence that the Knight Frank valuation could not be properly relied on. The Met says it reopened the matter in June 2026 after a review found further lines of inquiry, and that it is investigating alleged fraud offences from June 2011.
Now the questions ?!
If evidence relevant to allegations this serious was destroyed, who authorised it? What did the Financial Conduct Authority know? What records still survive? How many other GRG customers have hit the same wall when trying to prove what happened to their businesses?
I make no claim about the answers. The questions still need answering.
The FCA commissions a review. Its reviewer destroys papers.. A customer waits 16 years. The police then ask the bank for copies. If that is how accountability works, small businesses have every reason to ask who is accountable to them.
Chris Richardson's persistence deserves enormous respect. James Hurley of The Times deserves credit for investigating cases that powerful institutions would probably prefer everyone forgot. Andy Agathangelou of the Transparency Task Force sees this case as potentially important for others, and his group will discuss it on Thursday 19 November at 5pm. Lorraine M. Morris says Ulster Bank's GRG Ireland deserves the same scrutiny.
Please read and share this article. Whether you were affected by GRG or a similar case or you were not, add your comment under this article. Every voice helps keep this in front of the people who can act. If you are a victim of banking malpractice or regulatory failure say so.
https://t.co/9237CQ1CwE
The English Courts often wrongly make solvent people bankrupt to shut them up. The Trustee and the bank then collude to repossess all properties involved and sell them under value (£100,000 under is not uncommon) and steal all their possessions.
The Trustee will then run up bills and costs to extinguish any monies so the person wrongly made bankrupt gets nothing. The whole system is a racquet and not fit for purpose.
The Police will then refuse to investigate calling it a Civil. matter . Any complaints about the Royal Courts of Justice are referred to Charing Cross Police station where a dedicated team will invariably fob everyone off.
Chris Richardson in this case deserves credit to get the Police to investigate anything? Lots of other people have tried to no avail.
VERY IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT!
You are so, so right @MLorrM .
This (yet another) superb article by @jameshurley at @thetimes is significant on several levels:
1) It speaks to what can happen when you just refuse to give up; Chris Richardson’s tenacity, persistence, determination, focus and resilience over many years has been outstanding. We all salute you in your refusal to give up and back down, Chris - it is really inspiring and gives us all more of that one special ingredient we all need – hope.
2) It speaks about the power of the media in getting stuff ‘out there’ and once again we find ourselves very grateful to the amazing work of James Hurley. James, we know you know this already, but we are all off-the-scale grateful to you for your huge and seemingly insatiable appetite to continue to expose what needs to be exposed – thank you from us all, again.
3) It speaks to the other-side’s attempts to dodge justice through destroying records. IMHO it was never, ever right for Promontory to destroy records, or be allowed to do that. One wonders why @TheFCA allowed thato happen?
I’ve just spoken to Chris and he’s allowed me to quote what he just said: “The FCA allowed Promontory to destroy the records.”
4) And through that failure to disclose, is this not (yet another) egregious miscarriage of justice involving banks? And if so, how many other SMEs have been cheated out of justice through the control of evidence in this way?
5) It speaks to a theme that applies in so many cases – the allegation of manipulative sale of assets at below market value. That makes this case far more important than its own case. Just imagine the potential if it could somehow be a pathfinding, precedent-setting case that others may follow.
We’ll make this breakthrough a key talking point at Thursday’s 5pm TTF meeting on Zoom. If you are in any way a victim of banking malpractice and/or regulatory failure and would like to join US on Thursday (19th November 2026) at 5pm and are not already part of that group please get in touch through our website https://t.co/cSqXhlcNBl
Should the @CommonsTreasury Committee led by @Meg_HillierMP get interested in this?
@ArturNadol7566@stevemiddi1@Carlier_J87@BankConfidenti1@CarshaltonArt@johnmcdonnellMP@premnsikka
Police open ‘fraud’ investigation in 16-year saga over hotel sale
Chris Richardson says his health has been ‘devastated’ by the case, which he blames on RBS’s notorious restructuring division
https://t.co/HLSWK3tGom
@jameshurley keep up great work James 👍
I'm still unsure why Bates got an alleged multi-million settlement after losing to my knowledge circa £6k (you say £65k but that is a pittance when compared to other victims) when victims whose lives were destroyed, went to prison, were bankrupted & had their lives destroyed have still not received any substantial compensation or justice.
I make no findings on the matter I just need to understand the dynamics, of who suffered what and who got what...
I watched Noel Edmonds be promoted by the Turners, the SME Alliance and in my view, the corrupt Fair Banking APPG.
He had whistle-blowers approaching him and victims, he collected their files & evidence promising them he was behind them and would support them.
Then he got a deal refused to share any information with other victims - I am told - and then cleared off to New Zealand.
In bank fraud issues I am aware of & involved in, I have seen alleged victims profiteering from & preying on genuine victims for years.
This is an issue no one wants to talk about or expose but I do and will and I will name them...
Last night’s debate on the proposed finance bill included some welcome reality checks from @Johnmcdonnell on the risks in the financial sector and @neilduncanjordan again highlighting the ‘still’ covered up hidden credit line scandal & @james_glanville case.
Unfortunately, the majority of the discussion and alleged facts stated were illogical & borderline delusional, perhaps a long session in the Strangers Bar before the debate, on subsidised G&Ts led to such nonsense being spouted.
My own MP @grahamstuart who has ignored repeated requests to meet with me & support in exposing substantial fraudulent cover ups such as the Hidden Credit Lines and the Ulster Bank fraud, issues I made him aware of over a decade ago, made some nonsensical comments.
Mr Stuart suggested the bank surcharge introduced by @JohnHealey_MP that may raise circa £1.5B in revenue may restrict lending by circa £25 billion.
Where did that throwaway statistic come from?
If Mr Stuart met with constituents who are SMEs & who actually know something about finance/ lending rather than listen to fabricated stats, that his no doubt Treasury inspired advisers informed him on, he would know that banks have not been lending to businesses in any meaningful way since 2008.
Banks now mainly lend money to third tier lenders who are unscrupulous, barely regulated & charge three times what a competitive banking market should charge.
The banks cream higher profits with none of the regulatory risk.
The shadow minister @GarethDavies_MP unfortunately proved just how little so many MP’s know about the real facts on banking and financial services.
Mr Davies suggested that we should stop ringfencing retail banking stating:
‘The ringfencing forces our largest banks to separate retail banking from the rest of their business. That was right after the financial crisis, but the world has now moved on’.
The world has not moved on Mr Davies, certainly the UK has not, the current flatlined economy and ongoing austerity in the UK are daily reminders of how committing £1.2 Trillion plus to support criminal bankers in 2008/09 on, destroyed our economy.
Some nurses now rely on food banks because of fraudulent bankers illicitly leveraging their customers assets 20 years ago Mr Davies, learn your subject...
Those very bankers he wishes to ‘let loose’, were the same ones duping SMEs & consumers into complex regulated arrangements to use their assets as trading collateral, when the banks had wiped out their own through incompetent casino gambling.
Perhaps you may wish to ask @PremSikka for some true facts on the banking sector returns.
Lord Sikka who I would remind you is an Emeritus Professor of accounting, rightly confirms that the UK’s financial sector has in the last two decades had a net negative impact on the UK economy.
Then @Mark4WyeForest himself an investment banker who doesn't let simple things like facts & evidence get in his way, delusionally stated:
“It is incredibly important to remember that banks such as J.P. Morgan invest in the wider community, but Jamie Dimon has said that he is worried about uncertainty around the tax regime on banks in the UK”
Perhaps Mr Garnier should read some papers other more informed people have heard of & studied called the Epstein Files.
If he then considered the 279 times Jamie Dimon’s name appears, including suggestions he was in contact with Epstein on investment matters in 2013 (he rigorously denies this), 3 years after Epstein was released from prison as a known paedophile, would he then be so quick to quote JP Morgan and Dimon?
Perhaps he should ask JP Morgan why they faced state prosecutions for being the financial facilitators of Epstein’s global paedophile and trafficking network, before he suggests that such people should dictate our approach to banking.
How many other innocent firms does Mr Garnier know who have paid hundreds of millions to Epstein victims for something they state they never knew about...
I would have assumed Mr Garnier would be be much more cautious on which investment banks opinion he quotes, having worked for Edmond de Rothschild, quoted in the Epstein files circa 1,700 times (some time after Mr Garnier left) and Bear Sterns where Epstein worked in his early career & who Epstein was alleged to have done substantial business with over decades.
Who will Mr Garnier quote next, will it be the views of Peter Mandelson and Andrew Mountbatten Windsor on securing offshore investment or perhaps some imparted wisdom from Gary Glitter on Asian investment opportunities?
Perhaps Mr Garnier might recall a dinner in Wales in 2014 where I confronted him over the failure of the FCA to protect SMEs from the Hidden Credit Line Fraud on interest rate swaps.
The same dinner where Gueto Bebb when an MP, promised he would ask the FCA to meet with me in front of 250 people and then a week later denied making that statement.
Perhaps he recalls the nonsense he spoke against the request for a Public Inquiry into the Hidden Credit Line scandal in April this year?
Mr Garnier is unfortunately, nothing more than a City apologist and acolyte.
The view that the banks allegedly provide an 8% boost to UK GDP & drive the UK economy is so delusional it is embarrassing, I am tired of hearing this.
SMEs are the engine & the lifeblood of the UK economy not banks and/ or the City.
Banking criminality and financial sector fraud now drive annual losses in the UK economy, not gains.
Fraud is now the largest crime in the UK.
In the UK circa 45% of all crimes are fraud & under the auspices of the private police force @CityPolice , who lead on almost all UK fraud, only circa 1% of reported fraud crimes are prosecuted. No doubt stats the magic circle firms and banks that run @cityoflondon corporation boast about globally.
Global money laundering is now said to be between $2-5 Trillion per annum, it is publicly stated that circa 40% of laundering is through the City & the Crown dependencies.
@TheFCA do not regulate banks their real role is to promote the City globally as the leading centre for committing financial crime and getting away with it.
Are MP’s proud to work with and support a City that is the global leader in financial corruption, working with and laundering money for Mafia cartels, terrorists, human traffickers & paedophiles?
Laundering through UK banks is not by accident, financial fraud investigators at Barclays & NatWest - whistle-blowers, have confirmed to me that staff are routinely trained to ignore fraud red flags & managed out of the business if they report money laundering risks.
The City is the not the global money laundering centre by accident but by design.
@HSBC were not caught out accidentally money laundering for the Sinaloa cartel, they were caught out being in business with the cartel.
No doubt whatever deal they cut with the cartel (likely circa 10 or 11% of gross funds laundered?) to launder its billions annually, was a hard-fought deal against a line up of the other UK based banks @NatWestGroup , @Barclays etc. pitching for the same business.
The City is not a fairy-tale centre of financial integrity, it is a Groundhog Day version of 'Breaking Bad' & 'Better Call Saul', with a strong dose of the 'Sopranos' thrown in.
Rupert Lowe who previously I might have had some time for, unfortunately showed his true colours calling for de-regulation and a return to the good old days of "caveat emptor". So speak like minded benefactors of inherited wealth.
That delusional attitude is the exact view that led to carpet salesmen, builders, electricians, property owners etc. as SMEs being set up as counterparty’s, trading 'one on one' against the banks in interest rate swaps from 2006/07 on.
That caveat emptor approach led to the destruction of tens of thousands of viable SMEs due to the Hidden Credit Line Frauds perpetrated by the banks and still covered up by @TheFCA
Does Mr Lowe welcome the financial devastation that caveat emptor has brought to SMEs & the UK economy?
Does he remember the financial crash or did his private education at Radley and then wealth earned in the City lead to him to forget just where weak regulation led his former employer Barings Bank to?
As I recall Nick Leeson called Lowe very “upper class” and “aloof” when he ran the Barings trading desks before moving on to those bastions of morality & integrity at JP Morgan.
Or could Mr Lowe have been one of the wealthy benefactors who benefitted from rich pickings following the crash and & avidly awaits the next one?
As Mandelson effectively told Epstein shortly after being installed as business Secretary in 2008, get over here & 'fill your boots', we have distressed assets aplenty at knockdown prices...
Those distressed assets aplenty, being the life's work of many SMEs, destroyed by the bailed out banks.
MPs need to wake up, if the Hillsborough Act is to mean anything it must start by being relied on to expose the decades long cover ups of financial frauds perpetrated by the City that has destroyed tens, if not hundreds of thousands of SMEs.
I would suggest that reading @BankConfidenti1 report on the Hidden Credit Line fraud, may lead more informed MPs to stop concentrating on protecting bankers wealth, when much of it is derived from such unpunished frauds.
Forcing the banks to return the tens of billions they stole from SMEs post the crash would lead to a revenue windfall ten times that projected by adopting weaker financial regulation & in a fraction of the time.
We are on the verge of another decline/ crash. If the Government support the City's fraudsters again instead of the SMEs, there will no UK economy left to recover this time.
Wake up Parliament!
If @andyburnham intends to stand by his statements & principles in his & @MetroMayorSteve captivating book 'Head North', I would suggest one thing:
'Head Away from the City & Towards SMEs'.
Following the Hillsborough, Infected Blood & Post Office scandalous cover ups, its now time to make the City pay for the Hidden Credit Lines & other Frauds...
@appgonifandffs@TransparencyTF@labourlewis@IanByrneMP@normanlamb@mpsusanmurray@BankConfidenti1@efgbricklayer@johncock_wayne@AlliMiddleton1@MLorrM@mickmor16921994@CarshaltonArt@financialeyes@BomberMorgan@EmilyBuchanan@Nat_Worst@paulpygmy02@andyverity@jameshurley@EthicalDavid@StuartSyvret@RBSlielikeadog
THE RETIRED LAWYER WHO DID PARLIAMENT'S JOB AND WON A JOURNALISM AWARD FOR IT
Dan Neidle (@DanNeidle) retired at 49 from Clifford Chance, one of the world's most powerful law firms, where he spent nearly 25 years as head of tax. Most people in that position go quiet and enjoy the garden.
Neidle started a non-profit think tank and spent his retirement doing what journalists, regulators, and parliament couldn't be bothered to do.
In July 2022, he published detailed analysis showing that Chancellor Nadhim Zahawi (@nadhimzahawi) had used an offshore structure to avoid approximately £3.7 million in capital gains tax on his YouGov stake. Then he showed Zahawi had lied about it.
Zahawi's lawyers at Osborne Clarke sent him threatening letters marked "confidential" and "not for publication," demanding he retract the allegations within 24 hours or face defamation action. They told him it would be "improper" and a "serious matter" to publish the letters.
Neidle published the letters.
He also published more detailed analysis. Then he referred the lawyers to the Solicitors Regulation Authority.
@TheSun then revealed Zahawi had secretly settled with HMRC for the exact amount Neidle estimated, plus a 30% penalty. Total: nearly £5 million. Rishi Sunak sacked Zahawi in January 2023 after an investigation found he had breached the Ministerial Code by failing to disclose he was being investigated by HMRC while serving as Chancellor.
Neidle won Investigation of the Year at the British Journalism Awards 2023. He is not a journalist.
The SRA referred Osborne Clarke partner Ashley Hurst to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, marking the first time a solicitor had been referred to the SDT for abusive tactics in libel litigation. In December 2024, the Tribunal found Hurst guilty of misconduct and fined him £50,000.
A retired tax lawyer spotted what a sitting Chancellor was hiding, refused to be silenced by his legal team, was proved right in every detail, won a journalism award, and then got the silencing lawyer sanctioned.
Zahawi got a pension. Neidle got a prize. The lawyer got a fine. The public got to watch.
This is what accountability looks like when institutions won't do it themselves.
Sources: @guardian@BBCNews@FT@TheSun@PressGazette |
Does the FCA think we are stupid?
I was in contact with Simon Andriesz @SAndriesz. I wrote his story in August, before he took his own life in September, and I have kept writing since. That is why I am writing this today.
Who chose the person to review how @TheFCA treated Simon Andriesz? The FCA's only record is one email, sent by its chairman Ashley Alder to the non-executive directors at 7.20pm on 5 October, the night before its public meeting..
The problem
For weeks, the FCA has told the public, Parliament and John McDonnell MP @johnmcdonnellMP that its Board commissioned the review into how it treated Simon Andriesz after careful consideration. John McDonnell chairs the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Investment Fraud and Fairer Financial Services @appgonifandffs.
On 7 October, Jasthi Alom, a former FCA supervisor, asked the FCA for the records behind that decision under the Freedom of Information Act.
On 4 November the FCA replied, reference FOI2026/02281, and produced one email.
The FCA says it has found nothing else. John McDonnell says there is no record of the careful consideration and no record of the options the Board looked at. The reply also shows no record of any independence check, although the request asked for one.
The FCA's public account and its own paper trail do not match.
The proof
Here is the order of events, from @thetimes, the FCA and John McDonnell's statement.
1 October 2026:
Lea Paterson joins the FCA Board as a non-executive director.
5 October, 7.20pm:
FCA chairman Ashley Alder sends an email to the non-executive directors. In that email, Ashley Alder tells them he asked Lea Paterson to conduct the review shortly after learning of the death, and that she agreed. Lea Paterson and FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi are copied in. He says he is telling the directors now because of the likely publicity around the public meeting, where the review will be announced.
6 October:
the next day, at the FCA Annual Public Meeting in Edinburgh, Ashley Alder tells the room the FCA considered the independence question very carefully before it appointed Lea Paterson.
At the same meeting, Andy Agathangelou from @TransparencyTF asked Ashley Alder the right question, a yes or no question. Will you resign?
October:
according to the Times, FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi tells MPs the Board asked for the review..
2 November:
the FCA says the review was commissioned by its non-executive directors. John McDonnell says Ashley Alder wrote to him the same thing.
5 November:
the Times reports the FOI email. The FCA tells the Times that the Board discussed the idea of a review after Simon Andriesz died. The FCA says those talks took place outside a formal Board meeting, so no minutes exist. The FCA also says the directors discussed Lea Paterson's appointment and the terms of reference afterwards, and agreed the terms on 29 October. The FOI reply included no record of any of those talks.
The FCA's own reply describes the email as informing the directors that the review is going to take place. That is the full record the FCA has shown.
What John McDonnell MP says:
John McDonnell says he is astonished. He sees two possibilities. In the first, one person made the decision and it was later presented as the considered view of the Board. In the second, the Board did decide and failed to record it.
He says Simon Andriesz's family, other whistleblowers and Parliament deserve a clear and accurate account of who decided what, when and why. He says he will write to the FCA.
What I think
I support John McDonnell MP. I also support the Transparency Task Force. Andy Agathangelou, its founder, says the FCA is marking its own homework. He called the process a sham and a whitewash.
Look at who is doing this review. The reviewer is an FCA director. The FCA chairman asked her to do it. FCA staff provide her secretarial support. Her report goes to the FCA's own directors. She will not look at whether Simon Andriesz's allegations were true. It looks to me like the FCA has not learned the lesson.
In my opinion, how the FCA treated Simon Andriesz played a huge part in what happened to him. I have no doubts about that. The Parliamentary group says the FCA admitted that an official gave him wrong advice about losing his whistleblower protection, and that the FCA apologised. He deserved better from the regulator that was supposed to protect him.
After he took his own life, his story went viral. Journalists around the world picked it up and the media followed. People in many countries are watching what the FCA does next. The questions will not go away.
How much is a human life worth to the FCA if it keeps treating whistleblowers the way it treated Simon Andriesz before he died? In my opinion, that treatment was inhuman. I fear this review could turn into another cover up. We are watching, the world is watching, and we will keep watching.
What needs to happen
The FCA should publish every record showing who chose the reviewer, and when. It should appoint a reviewer it has no part in choosing, as John McDonnell MP asks.
Please share this article. Simon Andriesz deserves a clear answer.
@jameshurley@stevemiddi1@premnsikka@nw_nicholas@JohnCleese@Victoria_Rixon@MLorrM@Wftproof@pjhlaw@CartlandDavid@ClareCraigPath
You would have thought that multiple suicides and Self-harm related to one government policy #LoanCharge would have raised alarm bells.
Question: Is the actions of the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) incompetence, a cover-up or systemic failure
I’m pleased to share with you some important correspondence sent to @TheFCA CEO Nikhil Rathi by @johnmcdonnellMP in his capacity as Chair of the @appgonifandffs.
The correspondence was in the form of an open letter, hence our being able to share it with you.
The letter is necessarily detailed and long, but a fair summary would be as follows:
The letter challenges the FCA’s handling of whistleblowers and calls for greater independence, transparency and accountability following the death by suicide of whistleblower Simon Andriesz.
There are three important topics covered:
1. Independence and scope of the Paterson Review
John McDonnell MP questions the appointment of FCA Non-Executive Director Lea Paterson to review the FCA’s handling of Simon Andriesz’s case. He argues that Nikhil Rathi’s evidence to the Treasury Committee on 13th October was contradictory and failed to unambiguously establish whether the review is confined to the FCA’s communications with Mr. Andriesz or extends to wider whistleblowing practices. He requests clear, published terms of reference, clarification of who controls the review’s scope and reconsideration of appointing an independent external reviewer. He also seeks confirmation that the report will be published in full with only redactions as necessary.
2. FCA participation in the APPG’s summit about protecting whistleblowers from retaliation
John McDonnell MP criticises the FCA’s decision not to provide an executive-level participant at the APPG whistleblowing summit on Monday 2nd November, offering only an observer. He argues that discussing general principles of whistleblower protection would not compromise the Paterson Review and urges the FCA to participate meaningfully and engage directly with whistleblowers. By not doing so the FCA misses a unique opportunity to learn through engagement; not a good look when the FCA is undertaking a lessons-learned review.
3. Independent survey of whistleblowers
The letter strongly challenges the credibility of the FCA’s 2022 whistleblower survey, which received only 21 complete responses from 68 selected individuals, out of 1,041 reports received during the relevant period. FOI disclosures show the exercise was conducted in a purposive and seemingly contrived manner. For example, only cases selected by the FCA’s whistleblowing case handlers were included. John McDonnell MP calls for an independently administered survey of every individual who has contacted the FCA about whistleblowing since January 2022, with the methodology, questionnaire and results published.
The letter calls for substantive answers to important questions covering whistleblower protection, regulatory responsibilities and historical FCA practices. It requests an urgent response on summit attendance and a comprehensive reply to the other issues raised within 14 days, emphasising that credible scrutiny, demonstrable accountability and a culture of openness are essential to restoring confidence in the FCA.
The full open letter is available for you here:
https://t.co/rsnC3Epydq
We believe this is a legitimate and necessary challenge of @TheFCA's handling of whistleblowers, particularly following the death by suicide of whistleblower @SAndriesz.
And note that there have been serious concerns in Parliament and in particular by @CommonsTreasury about how @TheFCA deals with whistleblowers going back to at least 2016 - see here, by Lord Tyrie when he was Chair of @CommonsTreasury.
Also if you would like to express interest in taking one of the few remaining complimentary places available at the APPG summit in Parliament on Monday 2nd November, which is all about protecting whistleblowers from retaliation and dedicated to the memory of @SAndriesz, please see here:
https://t.co/MhnQZnyAOQ
Thank you for taking time to read what we believe to be an important message; we hope you agree.
Please share your thoughts and repost as you wish - we need to get this message 'out there.'
HE WARNED THE BANK. THE BANK COLLAPSED. YOU PAID THE BILL.
Paul Moore (@Paul_R_Moore) was Head of Group Regulatory Risk at Halifax Bank of Scotland. His literal job was to spot danger. In 2004, he spotted it. He told the board that HBOS was lending recklessly, growing too fast, and building a financial time bomb. They thanked him by sacking him.
KPMG was brought in to investigate his concerns. KPMG concluded everything was fine. The Financial Services Authority @TheFCA whose deputy chair was HBOS chief executive James Crosby, agreed. Nothing to see here.
Four years later, HBOS collapsed. Lloyds (@LloydsBank / @LBGplc) was pushed into a shotgun merger to absorb the wreckage, then needed a £20.5 billion taxpayer bailout to survive it. James Crosby eventually handed back his knighthood and forfeited part of his £25 million pension. He was not prosecuted. Nobody was.
Paul Moore went to the Treasury Select Committee in 2009 and laid out exactly what had happened. It caused, as one journalist put it, shockwaves through the British establishment. It also caused addiction, depression, and suicidal episodes for Moore himself.
He spent years warning anyone who would listen that the system was broken. He wrote a book called Crash Bank Wallop. He died in September 2020.
The men who built the disaster got pensions. The man who tried to stop it got destroyed.
If you think whistleblowers are protected in this country, Paul Moore's life is your answer.
Sources: @BBC, @guardian, @Channel4News | @Wikipedia | @TransparencyTF
THIS IS THE NEXT BIG UK SCANDAL
The Hidden Credit Line scandal has run since the 2000s.
NatWest (@NatWestGroup), Royal Bank of Scotland (@RBS_Help) and Ulster Bank (@UlsterBankNI) sold business owners loans with an interest rate swap attached.
It was marketed as protection if rates rose. It actually created hidden exposure against the customer's own assets that nobody clearly explained. When rates fell after 2008, banks used that exposure to call in debts, strip assets and push profitable businesses into insolvency.
Steve Middleton (@stevemiddi1) and Mark Wright, a former RBS manager, built BankConfidential (@BankConfidenti1) to collect the evidence.
Mark Wright put in about £60,000 of his own pension. Neither made a penny and both lost their careers for telling the truth.
In November 2022 they met the FCA (@TheFCA) with Lord Prem Sikka (@premnsikka) and derivatives expert Ian Tyler.
James Hurley (@jameshurley) of @thetimes had already written 4 articles calling it financial and accounting fraud. The FCA let NatWest review itself and concluded it was not technically criminal fraud.
BankConfidential published its full report in November 2025. On 14 April 2026 it prompted a Westminster Hall debate led by John McDonnell (@johnmcdonnellMP), chair of the APPG on Investment Fraud and Fairer Financial Services (@appgonifandffs). MPs asked for a judge led statutory inquiry under the Inquiries Act 2005. Six reviews had already produced no justice.
Ian Byrne (@IanByrneMP) said this scandal belongs alongside Hillsborough, Post Office Horizon and infected blood. He also noted the FCA is a private company limited by guarantee with immunity from civil liability.
Andrew Candy was hit with an undisclosed £70,000 break cost. He lost his business and family home and spent 17 years seeking answers.
Economic Secretary Lucy Rigby (@LucyRigby) replied that the FCA is independent and ministers should be careful about interfering.
The regulator failed for over a decade, and its independence is now the reason given for not investigating that failure.
Nobody has gone to prison... yet.
Sources: @stevemiddi1, @BankConfidenti1, @jameshurley, @thetimes, Hansard Westminster Hall debate 14 April 2026, @johnmcdonnellMP, @IanByrneMP, @appgonifandffs, @TransparencyTF, @TheFCA, @LucyRigby, @_moneymarketing