Interested in the mysteries of smell and taste? We bust myths and show how sight tricks smell. For ages 5-99+.
“Myth or Fact? Making Sense of Taste and Smell” Free AChemS public outreach event, May 8, 11 am CDT! Sign up here: https://t.co/N0p9rNTl7l
I was thinking about some of the comments I received on my F32 NIH postdoctoral fellowship application from 6-7 years ago. It’s surprising how frustrated I still get when I think about it. A thread... 1/
Check out our (@McGannLab) newest paper in NLM: https://t.co/J5OIebkMUA … …
In it, we find that when conditioned fear generalizes across threatening and non-threatening odors that there is a corresponding generalized hypersensitivity of olfactory bulb interneuron activity.
@scienceofscent@CNoppeney@science They don't name Broca (why would they?), but they use Turner's terms that were explicitly based on Broca. Ergo, Broca's influence. 3/3
@scienceofscent@CNoppeney@science ...devoted to odor processing are rudimentary...in comparison to the corresponding areas in macrosmatic mammals." 2/?
@scienceofscent@CNoppeney@science Here's an example from Braak and Del Tredici's book on Alzheimer's from 2014, pg 39: "In the microsmatic human brain, most structures... 1/?
@scienceofscent @stevenmunger @jokriolo Broca: Humans="non-smellers"
Turner: Broca shouldn't have said "non-smeller," let's say "microsmatic"
People since: humans=microsmatic 1/2
@scienceofscent @stevenmunger @jokriolo Broca was really commenting on free will beliefs, but subsequent scientists exaggerated his "anosmatique" classification into modern myth.
@scienceofscent @stevenmunger @jokriolo Broca classified humans as "anosmatiques". Non-smellers. Said olfaction atrophied in primates. 1879 paper in Revue d'Anthropologie, p.385.
@scienceofscent@CNoppeney@science Tight limits on word count and citation count were challenging, plus need to engage both expert and lay audience. What would you have added?
@scienceofscent@CNoppeney@science Poor human smell is widely believed and is taught as fact in many textbooks, but as you know is not true. That's myth, not just hypothesis.