Never will I believe Higgins called into the Hoodboogers...this is so fake. Listen carefully, it's a one way convo, it doesn't flow. Easy to fudge when you're a self proclaimed 'plastic wrapper'😉 https://t.co/ez6xJZQqOR
O'Keefe v. Read et al Wrongful Death Suit
C.F. McCarthy's is asking the court to exclude the expert report and testimony of Marissa Orlowski, the hospitality management expert retained by the plaintiffs in the civil lawsuit involving Karen Read and the establishments where alcohol was served.
The motion challenges whether Orlowski's opinions are legally admissible.
HERE'S WHAT C.F. McCARTHY'S IS ARGUING:
🔶 1. HER OPINIONS DON'T ESTABLISH VISIBLE INTOXICATION.
Orlowski was retained to address alcohol service practices and the standard of care applicable to establishments serving alcoholic beverages.
However, C.F. McCarthy's argues that her opinions rely exclusively on what attorneys call "method of operation" evidence.
The defense maintains that this type of evidence is not recognized as proof of visible intoxication under Massachusetts dram shop law.
In other words, the defense argues that examining how a bar operates does not establish that Karen Read appeared visibly intoxicated when she was served alcohol.
🔶 2. HER OPINIONS CONFLICT WITH EYEWITNESS OBSERVATIONS.
The motion argues that Orlowski's conclusions contradict the direct observations of witnesses who were actually present.
Attorneys contend that her opinions are unreliable because they conflict with firsthand testimony and are not grounded in scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge.
This is significant because the question isn't simply whether Read consumed alcohol.
The issue is whether there is sufficient evidence that she was visibly intoxicated when alcohol was served.
🔶 3. THE DEFENSE SAYS HER TESTIMONY ISN'T EVEN NECESSARY FOR A JURY.
C.F. McCarthy's argues that Orlowski's opinions address matters ordinary jurors can understand without expert assistance.
According to the motion, her conclusions concern issues within a layperson's common knowledge and experience.
The defense argues that allowing her to testify would improperly intrude upon the responsibility of the judge or jury to evaluate the evidence.
🔶 4. THEY WANT HER EXCLUDED FROM BOTH SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND TRIAL.
C.F. McCarthy's is requesting that the court:
🔷 Exclude Orlowski's expert report.
🔷 Refuse to consider her opinions when deciding summary judgment.
🔷 Prevent her from testifying as an expert at trial.
C.F. McCarthy's is challenging the admissibility of expert evidence the O'Keefe family seeks to use in its civil case.
The bar's position is that expert opinions cannot substitute for legally sufficient evidence of visible intoxication. If the court agrees with the defense's arguments, the plaintiffs could lose the ability to rely on Orlowski's report and testimony.
#KarenRead #JohnOKeefe #CFMcCarthys #KarenReadCase #Massachusetts
Full Filing in link below⏬⏬
https://t.co/n5LbOfneAU
@kelly_steffee I don't get them..I read something recently that says to rub vapour rub into your temples 🤷♀�� Might be worth a try..hope you feel better soon Kelly 🙂
But she was apparently insistent on ordering the state police to arrest Karen Read, nearly 5 months after she had been initially arraigned in Stoughton District Court, despite the fact that she was represented by counsel, had complied with all terms of release and had made all court appearances.
That office sure had its priorities straight.
“You’re leaving”?
“Ya, we’re heading over to the Waterfall, you should come”.
I wish I took him up on that offer.
Let me make this clear to anyone I used to know….I will leave no stone unturned to try and find out what happened to John O’Keefe.
He deserves JUSTICE.